Substantial Performance and Contract Recovery
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe dispute involved a claim for the value of services rendered under a contract, where the claimant asserted they substantially performed their obligations despite alleged minor deviations, while the opposing party argued the performance was deficient, precluding full recovery. The court reasoned that substantial performance, meaning performance of the essential or important parts of the contract, justifies recovery of the contract price, less the damages caused by any minor deficiencies, adhering to the principle that a party who has substantially performed should not be wholly denied compensation due to trivial defects.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Substantial Performance and Contract Recovery: The court reasoned that substantial performance, meaning performance of the essential or important parts of the contract, justifies recovery of the contract price, less the damages caused by any minor deficiencies, adhering to the principle that a party who has substantially performed should not be wholly denied compensation due to trivial defects.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAApplied for the imputation of court costs to the appellant.
Texte complet
! "# $
$ ! %&'''''' ! " #$ %&'
'
( ) (( ** (( ( )+ *
()*+(
(
,0 !'1 2333333% 333333,454% '6111 ' 333333 7& 0
618 7& (' 9' 1 ,%&: ;<8)=6 )//+%1 1& &1 '6':1 &19 1'>1( 7? # @ )= '& 6: ,44-0 # ' '6 % 81 1 ' 1 A '1 & $1 9' 1 ,%A&'1 B6' '8 C1 DA,)-6=>E9 D,5?D-/6=@ 8 1 6F16 ,,GHI0
)0 =/6 )//+%A,+$.-%!023333331 1 9 1 1' J 1(KLC&' 8 &'1 161 A.-G6*$%' <81 M1 8':; 8' N '1 0 '1'% 9 6 ' ' < ' 61 8 7& ' % 6 ' &: ' '1 8 &'1 % 1 $0 ' % 1 8 1 : M1 6 ' 8 ' 1 A1 1 ' 0
=0 0 =,6 )//+%!'1 2333333% 9 81 % 11< # <8 )//-%'M1%' E9 1L &1 18 F6 $ ' 1< ' 8': 1'8 61 9' 1 '% <1 &1 1 6 '1 & $1 9' 1 K% 1& 6 ,%161 A-/6=0 61 61A'M1%B1' 6 1: I%C 11 9 6 %1'11 1& 8'& 61 '&1'1 ' 9' 1 K0
=& 1)//+%!02333333 1 6 % 11 M1 < 'M1 &1 <' 11 6 '79 <81 1 '1 8 6'C ''6' 1'0
:0 ,)& 1)//+% # 11< A!02333333 1 ' < 8 ' 1 &1 1& A'M1(<1 &1 M1 6 F ,) ' ': )//-( 61 8 7& (' 9' 1 , &: < 6'1%'M' 6 6 A8 1 ,+1 , 8' ' 9 O611' ' & $1 A1 1' ' 17 )P ' ': ,4P+> (#P.,0-,@081 8&1 ;61'11 1& 8 618 9' 1 %' 66 K08 1 . ' 11 1 1 8 61 A'1 & $1 9' 1 KQ18 1 ' M'1 6R6 ' 1 1 8 618 7& (' %<1 1 1 6 161 A 9' 1 ' < 1&1 610 ' < %!0 23333338&1 ;61 ' 1 A'1 & $1 8 9' 1 < ,0 1 &'1 & 61'&: 'S $%1 &1 '661 1M 1' A '1 M 1 1' ' 17 ,) 6: ,4-5 >#P.,0/, ( @% < 1 1' 6
*,-./*)//+ (=*+(
611 1& 0 '6 1 ' % # M 1& '& 61 '&1'1 A!023333330
.0 R ,= & 1 )//+% # 16 ' A !0 2333333 1 8 1F6'1& ' 1& 8 618 7& (' % M' 8 1 ,.1 ):1 '1M 1 1' ' 17 ,) 6: ,4-5 ># P.,0/, ( @0 1 8 ' 1 A 1 =/ 6 )//+% 81M 1'' 18 1 ' : 0
-0 ). & 1)//+%!0 2333333 1 # 0 1 & ' ' 96 1' 1 % 11 6 <1 1 A8' 191 81M 1' '$ A'M108 1 & 91$ # %'T !0 2333333 8 1 7 &'1 1 ' F6 $ ' 1< ' 9' 1 0 &1 6 618 7& (' ' 9' 1 K% 61 91$ 17 1 &1 61 61 ,% ' 1 8&1 & 1M1 1: 08911 A %16 : A'; E9 0 1 :' M'1R : M1 61K%&: 8&1 1 R A 1 61? 1 1 11 ' F ' % ' <81 '&1 '1 < & $1 9' 1 0 8 1 '6 ' & ' N =/6 )//+0 M1% !02333333'11 '1 1' # 11'0
+0 7 6 % !0 2333333 11 1: 611 1M 8 ' 6 8' 1 , 61)//+0' A8 1' 11' 1 191 A 1& 8 61K8 7& (' 18 0 % 1 1 8 96 1' & ' !0 2333333 & # 1&'< :' M'10 1 1 1< 81 1' 1 8 1 ,.1 ):1 %6 'T1&1 : :1 18 F6 $ ' 1< ' 61 <81 1 ' < '1 &'1 1& 61 K 8 7& (' % F19 ' 1 1 6'1 & 0 % # 8&1 1 '66 ' <1 1 '1 & $1 ;61 &'1 1 8 F6 $ ' 1< : <1 8 1 '1 < 1 1& 8 61% <1 1 117 6 $'< 0
P0 1 ' '6 1' ' ).61)//+0
0 !0 2333333 8 ' M1 <1 1 1 '$ 0 'M1 6 <81 &1 '11 1& 8 61 K 8 7& (' <81 8&1 1 <81 &1 61 : M1 8 61 8 9' 1 0 &1 ;9 9 A F61 6 61 ,)' ': )//-%1 ' R 19 1 0'$ M19 1 :1 B ,I0 &1 MM &' 61 $ ' 1< ' A 9' 1 %' F19 1 & % ' '1 & $1 9' 1 K 1 0
*,-./*)//+ (.*+(
!0 2333333 11< <81 8&1 ' ' N '6 <1&1 61A'M10#$ < &11 61K 1 8%1 8&1 16 6 1MM1 <81 & 1 '& '& 6: )//+0 MM1 '1 6 1 ' < 'M1'1 1 MU'1 ' 1 1'0
:0 # 61 11'% 11 M1 <818C&1 % '1 ' % 6 ' 61K8 7& (' %61:1 9' 1 ,%&: < 6'10!R6 81C&1 6 % 1 8 1 6'1 < ' &1 '1 & $1 ' <81 8&1 61&: 08 ' 1 '&1 : 9 1' 611 ' <8 8 1 '6 0 % 8 &1 M1F 61166 9 1F6'10
( *
,0 ; 6 1 & ; 11 1' '6 % ' &: > 0-+ '1 O' 91 1';111 ))'& 6: ,4.,( ( ) /-Q 0 += 0 , 1 0 '1 ' 611 1& ,) 6: ,45-( ( -,/@0
)0 '1 & $1 '6':1 R 1 1 O 61 '1 '% O1 MM ' O 19 % O 61 O 7& ( ' 0
' <1 '1 & $1 '6':1 R 1 1 8 61 '1 8': 1 1 61 8 7& (' 1 61 '( 1 1F 6'1 61166 <1 1& 1M 1'0 #1 '66 1M 1' & 8&'1 1 8E9 61166 <1 ' ': 1 61% 18 ' A 1 6'6 'T 8 1 > 0,.0 ):1 @0
8 7 % ' ' &'1 1 &'1 =/6 )//+% ' < ' 61% 6 ' &: ' & $1 <81 '11 % 1 1& A $ < ;' N 0 81M 1' <1 1 '$ ': :1 1 % ' < 8 A; 1 < # &1 1 '1 1'0
M1 <81 8 1: 6 &1' 8 ' # %<18 ' 61 ' :' M'1% 1<81161 1 8 61166 9 1F 6'1% 1: '1 610 ' < % 11' & R 'M1 6 0
*,-./*)//+ (-*+(
1: 611 1M ' ' <8 $:1 33333 K ' F% A &'1 &1 % 1 % A 81 :1 ' 91 % 6 ' :1 ' A 8 ' 1MM1 117 0
=0 ' '1 6 M' % ' ; 0 6'6 JK.//0( 61A$ 9 ' > 05P @0
, (* (
-./0$% 1
&: ' 1 ; , 61)//+ !'1 2333333' 11' &1 '6':1 &19 1',=& 1)//+11M19 18 1F6'1& ' 1& 8 618 7& (' ' 8 61 '1 Q
/0$ 1
; Q
6 A$ 9 ' 6'6 JK.//0(Q
1 < % 'M' 6 6 F 1 4P 1& '1 M O' 91 1' ;111 % R R ' % &'1 ' '1 611 1M% ;' 7 ' 1M1 1'% & 1: M Q 6 6'1 ' '1 11< '1'%6' 1M 6'C & ' 19 ' ' '6 1 Q1'1 R '1 F 6 1 6'1 1: M % ,/// ,.Q R 17 ' 1' ' %1&'< '66 6'C & %'1& R ;'1 AO &'1Q
'661< R A ! " #$ % &' ' 11 <O &1 '6':1 &19 1' AO'MM1 M ' A 0
#1 9 ? !6 '&C% 1 %!!0C$7 % $ 1%;9 0
*,-./*)//+ (+*+(
'6 1:611 1M?
9 MM17 (; 1 ;0? &1 ( 1 ? !0 ''1 0'&C
' 1 'M' 6 R '661< F 1 0
7& % 9 MM17 ?
*,-./*)//+