Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/330/2006 • CJ GE ATA/330/2006 Généré par l'IA

Recovery of Money Paid Under Mistake of Law After Repeal of Governing Statute

Numéro de cause ATA/330/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge du recourant
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A legal challenge arose concerning the application of a statute regarding the recovery of money paid under a mistake of law, where the payer sought repayment after the statute governing the payment was repealed. The court held that the statute permitting recovery applied even after its repeal because the right to recover arose upon the payment, which occurred while the statute was in effect, and the repeal did not extinguish this existing vested right; therefore, the payer was entitled to recover the payment made under the mistaken belief that the law required it.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Recovery of Money Paid Under Mistake of Law After Repeal of Governing Statute: The court held that the statute permitting recovery applied even after its repeal because the right to recover arose upon the payment, which occurred while the statute was in effect, and the repeal did not extinguish this existing vested right; therefore, the payer was entitled to recover the payment made under the mistaken belief that the law required it.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
droits acquis restitution de la propriété détournement de fonds abus de droit condamnation à payer une somme indemnisation de l'erreur judiciaire

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Généré par l'IA
C/14505/2011
Recovery of Mistaken Overpayment Under Tort and Illicit Use Statute
A/1289/2004
Statutory Amendment Retroactivity and Vested Rights in Cost Recovery
A/4233/2005
Statutory Repeal and Preservation of Vested Rights
A/3736/2006
Statutory Amendment Voiding Post-Agreement Payment
A/3799/2007
Statutory Interpretation and Cost Recovery in Financial Regulation Challenge

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

  

    



 ! "#$





%% &'''''' 



( ) (( ** (( ( )+ * 





     !"# 

( 

$(  )*+,,,,,,-.,,,$/#0-*111.+ 231(  1145*1167(

!(  2  1 81 5  31  *61    3191 :2 ;-1454..*1<111< 21(

%(   $# 31 !&&#- = &#>%0- 41.. 11  31   ?1 3 1131=0@ A*">-*9.1..1- ?31.11*1.=#&A*">=1( 11-.5* ..!@A*">(

@(   .11  !% * !&&'-  2   11 = )* +,,,,,,  11115*1-551141$'6 18..111<$!.*6$/#B:20@$(&$  ;(  31 81  8.  1  3.>1 5 ?  5*14.15.15.4111(

#(  )* +,,,,,,     .11 5 1 91.  16 *1118  @ 31 !&&'-   = 41   *( .1114614C*.1?4318.1D 5E31*5C.=31(23111=88  5.<3*  . 1*1  13 *91  21 *(   .1  >611. = *51  F>-  31 1*5.13*5311111-51* 515.1(

'(  51..*515!!*1!&&'(

 ( )* +,,,,,,  81*.  (  4 5 . 4D<  31?11.15>.81*.?4.1*.=.5  31G-311-?  8- 21(21*31H81*.-.113 5*1-?1*15151.1*5.1(

 6( 2 11?.?413181D.**11**.9-5. 4 D<  31 *C* 93-   ?41 511   .11(

"$!%#"!&&' %"# 

( * 

$(  G.  *5 1 3  G111 *5.-    36:(#' 1I911G111!!3*6$/@$    !&#J('%($1(15.*1113$! 5*6$/B#    #$&;(

!(  > 1 5  19D   *? -  511-  19D81D31*D1*:(!0($ J$'!!I 19111<#5*6$/0/ 2-20@$(!$J 7$&B '!;(

%(   I1.1  1.-  31 *D1* 9..  3.>1 5 1 #& A*">- ?  11   -   11   311611.836I1@1.$I <9111<$%3*6 $/'!:  20@$($$J 7 $!$$!0- $//#''@;(

  2  G15  16 8..  *1< ID<  31 = I1.1I1.-.5*31*D1*1.#= !&A*">15931.?1G1811*531* I1$'1.% : 7$!!%0- $//00%%-1($-5( 0%0;-.31511<: 7$!%$&'- $//00!#- 1(!6-55(0!B 0!/.8(1(;(

   .5*  !$ = !@ A*"> 1- ? = 1-  181 *C*931*51?<99..15*1 I1$'6 (

   3>-  .5*  !# A*">  5 K  5115  161915*11-8*18D5153G181 ID<31D8I*611-3931.*1 9 ?I1 53?(   1 -  G15 1< ?  131191<I<98* :($'($((/&>(! J 7$!%$&'- $//00!#- 1(!-5(0%$.8(1(J 7$!%%0-1($-55(@& @$-2$//055( #!0 #!BJ "%B!"$//B$'G1$//B;(

  151155516?11111 836    ?  ..   818 1 6  *31(  I91-  88-   *1<- I  .1.  1   831?516I.91.1*G116: 7$$/6 $#'J2$//%5(#%#J 7$$B$/&J$&B6'0J$&@6#$;(

"$!%#"!&&' @"# 

   I5<-  .5*   31 1.-  *  .-..!@A*">-5<.1*9.1.-?11 =1*15.1*C*93-11541$'61.$  -?4=G1?2 5.1 5*11(

@(   .  1  81D.   1(   I *1  *11**:($0(( ;(49I5*11.95 H 11  3  1511 ?1 I551?  1  5*1  11:(@#4.9I*115 3.>1=111<!06$/0'   20@$(#$J 7 $&B6'& '$;(

  I1*D1<.8115G155.1. 81D=*1.I111121-2 51 .11?1.>55=918( 81*.?61   1 D*1. 5 3-  2   4. 5 ..  *11 **.9(

#(  G.(

  341119-.** +7@&&( *1=>9 -?1*6:(B0 ;(

,  (*  (    

-.%/$0 1

. 36   1G.  @ 31 !&&' 5 )* +,,,,,,   .1131*613191!%*!&&'111 8195*11.91115*1J

%/$1

GJ

*=>9.** +7@&&( J

1 ?- 8*.* D 1 /0  13   1 8.. I911 G111-5.H5H5.-5311*1118-   G <  1811- 5 3  16 8..J  *.*1  111?1-*18*C53519 *1J11H.1D*51*1

"$!%#"!&&' #"# 

16 8..- $&&&  $@J  5. H   51<  51  -13?.*C53-13HG1=I31J

1?5.H=)*+,,,,,,11?I31*61 3191=I8818..=(

21.9L )*3C-5.1-))(C>< >.1-G9(

* 16*1118L

9881< G1G(L  31 5.1L     )( 1 (3C   

518*H..1?.D51(

 <3-  9881<L           

"$!%#"!&&'