Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/308/2007 • CJ GE ATA/308/2007 Généré par l'IA

Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Judicial Discretion

Numéro de cause ATA/308/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case addresses multiple appeals concerning the application of mandatory minimum sentences, with the court ultimately concluding that the original sentencing court failed to properly consider the interplay between statutory mandatory minimums and judicial discretion in imposing those sentences for various offenses. The court reasoned that while certain statutes mandated minimum terms, the trial court was obligated to fully analyze the mitigating and aggravating factors relevant to the specific circumstances of each defendant's case before imposing sentences, especially where the mandatory minimums potentially resulted in an unduly harsh sentence, thereby requiring resentencing in several instances to ensure proportionality and adherence to sentencing guidelines.

Regeste Legislator

Officiel

TORT MORAL; SUBSIDIARITÉ; AVOCAT; HONORAIRES; SUCCESSION; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR L'AIDE AUX VICTIMES D'INFRACTIONS | Recours admis. Les sommes héritées par la victime ne sauraient être imputées de la somme allouée à titre de réparation du tort moral. Prise en compte des honoraires d'avocat au tarif de l'assistance juridique. | LAVI.1 ; LAVI.11 ; LAVI.12 ; LAVI.14.al1

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
pouvoir d'appréciation du juge fixation de la peine circonstance atténuante cas grave coopération judiciaire en matière pénale atténuation libre de la peine

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/855/2007
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Judicial Discretion
A/1278/1999
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Statute Violates Judicial Discretion
A/2756/2006
Statutory Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Vagueness Challenge
A/1399/2003
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing and Proportional Punishment
A/622/2005
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing as Cruel and Unusual Punishment

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

 

      









 !!!!!!  !" #$%" 

" 

   " # "  $  "% 





     &'()&

"  

-.  !/ 000000    #  -' 1%# ',,2.   #   3# #4  !/ 000000 5#&67 !/ 0000008$   -)9-   "/### :.

'.   '9 1%# ',,2$ !/ 000000 ;   < ;#  =#/# #"     5#&67;#   8  ;# /##  " %" .   ##4 <   "#" 4  % =%#  < >? @,,.&/"#$%# #  :.

9.   '@ /#   -A 1# ',,2$  "//  >? -*;,,,.&   B-;',,.& "%   3 C#    < 3 !/ 000000    >?2)*$@+  "%  6  ; /    %# #/ "     # "#!/ 000000. "//" # # ;D# : " .

2.  ""2/',,2 '9"%/C',,+$;#   % < !/ 000000$ < #   "%##"$  "//  #%  >?+=@-*$A+  >?)2,.& #<"%# ##6 3#53#/ $;%#/ $;DE 8.

+.  -+" "C',,+$ ";#C#4  "6% ";:!/000000"C;#  %". ; "/<4#F#".

  G      "#" #%#  !/ 000000$  " ;#  " // "/;:%/ "// >?2,;,,,.&< #  #" " /" <#D:; #$"  >?+;,,,.&%  ## #"HD""#;%" ;# .

@.   ' "I  ',,@$ ;#   4#  ;#     %/   >?2,=,,,.& #"" " /"$##4"// >?99=,,'$A+ "" /"  D""#;%" $ #3;#  1##4" 33 "//:/ #.

*.   " ""  '' 1%# ',,*$ ;#        /"   3#H   " ;#  #     #" /"$ "#  >?2,;,,,.&.   " 3"# "# 4 %#  J  #/     "//7

& >?@=++*$A+ 5 >? +=@-*$A+ K >? )2,.&8 ""  H /"   ";#  < # "%##"L

(*'+(',,* &9()&

& >?-)=292$A+ 5 >? -,;,,,.& K >? *=2)*$@+ K >? -=)9*$',8 D#   !/ 000000.

  G;:#   "//: / #$ ;#    = /# < D   >?-@=''@$*+$"# 7

& >?@9+$2, # 3# C#L

& >?-,=+)-$9+  #   C"  #3 H 3#  %"M:$ =DC:& / $= 6$ .L

& >?+=,,,.& # ;D""#;%" .

  /"  3#"=%# < >?9,='92$,+$"  # J <+N6 --1%#',,2.

A.   '93%#',,*$!/ 000000## #C/##  #3 ; ".  "  < ; #"   ##" 4$ < ;" #" ;"// >?2,;,,,.&%# J <+N6--1%#',,2< #   #" " /"  >?9*=@*-$*+%# J <+N6'"I ',,@ 5 " ;D""#;%" 8< #  #"1#/ #.

  G"  1#  #C /##  #3$ ;" "#   %   ## #"HD""#;%" "< ##%#; "6;/JD# "/ /C"/ # 3# #  "//::"#3=#H%# #/=#3 #"2 " "C -))- 5  & G 9-'.+ & (-9(',,*  -@ 1%# ',,*L (@9*(',,@  'A "%/C ',,@8.   $  " #   "//: "" <" ;D""#%# J  "<" $6" 4 ;#    ;%#  "   # ; ##   ; #%#  "M #  "/C;D""%" < .

  "I #%;#3 #"/#;#  "//3#   #  "//: / # = #   "  .  %D$ ;# #/ ;# I#/ /"  "%##"33 "//:/ # "//"" " /".

  3#$;#  %# %#"##=# # #"=C# # # ;#/# " " /""//O< # ;D# : 33#.  : "%# J "#"//M  % #   " /"# J  4#3#   #" /". ?#  ;" "# ;#/# " " /"/"  OD# :%# < #:#  # / 3" #"#  #"/ #P1Q.

).  ;#   #  /##"  '@ /',,*.

(*'+(',,* &2()&

"  $ 

-.   1   /  # %   1## #" "/  $  "   %C 5 . -*  L  . +@    "#  =":# #" 1###  ''"%/C-)2-& & ',+L .@9.-# ."#" /##  #%-' /C-)A+& & +-,8.

'.    %#:-1%#-))9$    " "  H %# #/   #" 33 #%   33#    # #"C 5!: "#3"  '+%#-)),$??-)),$%". .),)$" .)'9R#&67!:S8.

   33 $= #-#'#="C1 =#3"#$ "/  " // "  #"%# #/ 3"# " 5 C8$=#/# #"  #"/"5 .8.

  "4;#3 #" "//#G#$%# #/ / #/# #" "   #" /"    " "T ;#3 #"    "//#5 .--.- 8.

9.   /# :#3   "  "  "// #  "/   =#    "  D""# =%"  "      ".

2.  G=:#   3# =%" $  #C 3  "3#/  ##  ;" "#$  ;#   $ ; #/# #" "  3# ;%"    %# #/# % "// ##%#"" ;  ;#3 #"C #-- #%  5 ?-9--'-8.

      " M$ #   4  " #" 1##4  "//:     ""#   ## <   "#    "C##  #%#. "%#  ## " #   /  "  "   "//:3#::%# #/""  #"=%" $"4 &#  #  #   4  " 3    1 # &   ## 4  %# #/ :##     4  # #%#   " $ " = =#3 #"&"   " 3"#4  3#=#   #5 ?-9--'-$"#.'.-$.-'28. ## ; #  " 3"#C" $"4#"# #D:3# ;%" $#3#  #"/ 6:#3#4" /#/ %  ; # 9  $ ## 4  #"# #" :#  ;#  1###: # .; # #" #33 # #  #""# J J  "//# 7

 & #  %# #/  "#  < ;#  1### : # $  3#  3 " #D: %"#L

(*'+(',,* &+()&

 & #;# 1###: # ; " "M$%# #/ "##  ;#1##4"; #9#2  .   #"# D: <  #  ""  <  4# #       ;# 1###: # .D""#;%" "  #33#H  # L

 & # ;# "33   ; # 9 # 2   ;   4#$  %# #/ "%  "#   "##   #/#  "  3#  3$     ;#/# #" % < ; # --  .   #  " 3"# "C #$C##$#/# #< 4##   " # #"  ; # 9 # 2  . G 3# ;%"   "  " /C"4;<D  #3%;# 1##45 ?-9- -'-#G',,+.''+ ''@L (@)(',,*@3%#',,*L (-9(',,* -@1%#',,*8.

+.  ; #-)6:/ =# 1##4-A/-))@5 & ',+.,28%"# 4=#/# <=%"  " #3D"# #% 7 %" & :## >? @+.&$ "C"  >? -'+.&   D3 =  >?',,.&5.-8. &< >?+=,,,.&$=#/#  " #3 D"# #  5. '8. G  D # "   L  "  #3" #"" //  $=#/"  #33#    $   % # #:#$   4#   %# 3"#       "C 5.98.

@.   =6$ #    C#   " "   4  "#   "   # ;33#   4  /  #     C3#  ;#  1##4.

  ;#  "  "; #%# "M;%"  #"/C;D3 . / % :#  4;%# #/"#H%#;%" "3"#  ".

   " $  6:    #"  =#/#  %  = # -) #'  H"C#  " #" #3 = #C/ #6  .

   "    "   3#   D""#  9-1#  ',,@ 4  %# 3"#=%" $D33= $= %<-2@$9,D$ ## "C" #<@$-+D.G" # " $D""#"    #3=# 1##45 .-).- 8.3#=%"  D#33#  ## < >? 99=,,'$A+ 5-2@D9, H ',,.& K @D-+ H -'+.&8$   "/#.

(*'+(',,* &@()&

       "3"//  H ##   D $ =  < "  4 = "#  # #/  #/#   /"    D""# H  3#H   1## #" . H&#$ J  < >? 99=,,'$A+$ "  6 " #  "/    "//: / #.  "%#   "4 =/   ""# .

*.  " "D<=#  =%"##/ =:  "D D# :"//" #"" " /".

A.   "//   J  % <  %# #/ "  #" /"$ #//   " %$ "4;  C#   #  :%   4  #"  ##61 #3# 5 .-'.' 8.

).  G"  ##   C###     #"  =   " # < = # -2 # -$ '6/ D  $    #" 4  %# #/  O < #    #"  "  /" "  #    "// " < #    #"/".

 . G    #"  # 4# %  33 #%/  < "/  "//: "#%  J  #  "# #". ;    "#  # %# 4 # ;   ;#3 #"$   "# " #%     33 #%/ $#/  /#633# "//:C#5??-)), )'9&)'28.  #"O #" " /""#% J #  /"  ";#  .%# #/"# ##%#/CC 4;    # %"#  # " 4;     %"# 4  /"  #33# 5 .-="";#H%# #/;#3 #" -A"%/C-))'& &G9-'.+L ?-'+-@)8.

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

(*'+(',,* &*()&

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

   #C /##  #3 3 # =M   >  "   =#4/  #/ #< #" " /".

   "4$ # M  #  " 4  "// D#    " # J #/ "//"< #  #" " /".

-,.   "  "D 3# < =# #/ =%"# #   "//  #% >?+=@-*$A+  >?)2,.&%< # "%##" #< "%# #53#/ $;%#/ $;DE 8 "//" "M< #  #"/"$"  4=%# =J  =#/# ""//:.

  G 4   4 #" #    ##  =#  # #:$ # "%#   % 4  "%##" "    % " "%#  "//: / #C#.  $"#% J # =#/# %< # .

--.  "#"$#M#= #C<" < # =#/# " "//:/ #$"// >?9*=@*-$*+%# J <+N=6' "I  ',,@ 5 >? 99= ,,'$A+ K >? @9+$2, K >? -,=+)-$9+ & >? @=++*$A+8$ ## 4  "//  >? 2,=,,,.& % # J  < +N = 6  -- 1%# ',,2$< #  #"/".

-'.  " ##/#.=## #:/"/  >?*+,.&  /# <  D:  =#   .  #/#   " 

(*'+(',,* &A()&

>?-=,,,.&"<" $<D:=  6%5 .A*  8. WWWWW

& " $  "      

'()*+,

%C"# 1 '93%#',,*!/ 000000"  ##";# =#/# #" ''1%#',,*L

)*,

=/ L

 =""   '' 1%# ',,*  ;#  ;#/# #"    L

"<" #/# <D  >?9*=@*-.*+%# J <+N= 6'"I ',,@""//:/ #L

" <  "   "//  >? 2,=,,,.& % # J  < +N = 6  -- 1%#',,2< #  #"/"L

/ <D:;# =#/# #" /"/  >?*+,.&L

" < " $" "$#/#  >?-=,,,.&< D:;  6%L

#  4$ "3"//  H  # A'   #%    "# 3   #C 3  -* 1# ',,+ 5 ?&G -*9.--,8$    J    J  "      1" 4# #%   " #3# #" &%   #C 3$   %"#  "/ #6"# C#L//"#""# ##4"#"$ /" #3 /"M% " #: " ""/ #L# "#  J    #C 3$ -,,,  -2$  %"# "  "  %"#  "#4 H "# #"  = # 2'  ?.    J     #6  "#"  " $ #%"4 "// /"M  %$ "#%  J  1"#  < =%"#L

"//#4 J <!" #$%" " ##4=< ;# =#/# #"  <="33#31 #.

(*'+(',,* &)()&

G#: 7 !/"%M$# $!.MD6$!/>#$!. D#$!/"$ 1:.

"/ #C/##  #37

:33#6&1# 1..#.7  %#&# 7     . ."%M  

"#"3"/ J  "//#4H #.

 6%$  :33#67     

(*'+(',,*