Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/255/2007 • CJ GE ATA/255/2007 Généré par l'IA

Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute over Commercial Property Construction

Numéro de cause ATA/255/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involves a dispute over the construction and performance of a contract related to commercial property, where the party claiming breach alleged that the other failed to perform certain required work, leading to damages. The court reasoned that the operative contract language clearly allocated responsibility for the specified work, and based on the evidence presented, the complaining party failed to establish that the defendant violated a clear contractual obligation or that the alleged performance deficiencies directly caused the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the defendant.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractual Breach and Performance Dispute over Commercial Property Construction: The court reasoned that the operative contract language clearly allocated responsibility for the specified work, and based on the evidence presented, the complaining party failed to establish that the defendant violated a clear contractual obligation or that the alleged performance deficiencies directly caused the claimed damages, thus affirming the judgment in favor of the defendant.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
inexécution d'une obligation contractuelle différend commercial insuffisance des preuves défauts de construction qualification du contrat propriété immobilière

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive regarding the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/1098/2006
Contractual Breach and Defective Performance Dispute
A/2303/2003
Contract Breach and Performance Dispute
A/330/2005
Construction Contract Breach and Damages
A/1661/2003
Contractual Breach and Damages Award
A/55/2005
Contractual Performance and Breach Interpretation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

       

 

    



 !"#! $! 



! %%%%%%  !"#"$%&$' 

' 

&'   ( & ) *&+ ,  '" '"&$"(" "'" )







     *+,--*

 

-2 2  3   -. ) +//4&  ' ' "' $ 56   7"8  '9$')!)::::::&-0;0&< "  '% )'" ()"')  ' "" "  "' '))"  5"+//+'8( " ='" "<""86=" "8*2 !):::::: )"7>""  " ("  "-- '"+-)7-04;? *@4--2/A2"     " "'  ("  " .4 =">> +   '>"  ( ='" " "'2

    '"    '  >'   B " 6=" "8 ''     ("  "'    "   '  C" D'"& )"*=>  ""8 5'"    )   6=" "  EF" B"$" "9$?"*9GEA4-' '7+//+2

   ' B 8 "' '& (B  $"  ' ')) " G (" ( "    "  ( )" ) &  >"7 ("  ' ( H$   "'   '"2  '>>"  ( '7 H$   '" ")"7<$') ) "') ""8( '7 6')"8    '7 ">& ")"7 <  '7     ) 2 )') (H"& '7""  "  "   ("  " -- 2  " )  6=" "8 ='" "  "  '=" 7 >" ( H'))""'(  "72 "''    ) & (" ')') "  H$)   "  7"8 )" " ( " ""'=" 7(" '$")"H ( "2 ("  "  ''"8 )" " ( "   '"7 ( 7"  " "  <(''  '))"2  ) &(" ( "  <3 8 $"2

 72  -I 5$" +//J&  ' ' "'  56  ') !):::::: <   )'" ()"')  ' ") )8  )  '))")""='" "&'" ")3)'K$"  '3  '"HB "'(3 -.)+//4) "'2

  !):::::: )"7>"'7""  "  (" "-- 2(B "'" " "'  ("  " .4 =">> +    (" )   !) ::::::    ''2

   5H B  '  >'   B " 6=" "8 ''     ("  "'    "   '  'H @"'"&

,./-0,+//1 *4,--*

""   6=" " #!E& )"*=>  ""8   )   )"')) "E2

  (B  '7""  " (" "-- 2 " ) 6=" "8='" "()L   " "2 "' '7 ) >>  !)::::::    (7  '" '"& " ( "   ' )  B 8 *" "')') ')'"H$) " 7"82(" )  ( "  ' >'") (  2

  '  & (B   '>") 8 !) ::::::  "   <('' 7"2  " 7 " )""' H2 ( "  <3 8 $"2

 2  3   -1 )7 +//J&  '   "'  5   '$'" >')!)::::::' (3 " 2

  '  < (B)   ) (" )  ''   ' ' "'&  '   "'  $ 8  "'  =)*'' $" "( 7") '"(" ".4  8(" "'"  ( $" )"    E2  ')"   "  6=" "8?"*9G A&8"$" <"=H ') "'"H2'" "'&!)::::::'" 7>"" "     7")  '"  '  '" " "" 8 ( "6=''H"88 '("<' )(" ) 2

+2   '"8!):::::: " <"' =)* ''58(+0'$)7+//J*'>"')7B5'<(    B E * " > <  "' ' >))   ""9 < '6 ?A2

42   +4 'L  +//J& !) ::::::  ""  '"  $" 6=" "8 ?"*9G @A ( )  $  (" )     > <""8*2

.2   @ " 83 " ')))$<(" )(" ".4  (5 ""'-+)7+//J2

  (      6="8  !) :::::: )"  B 3))  """8( )'"H" ' )) >8='" " "'< ( 2 @"  )"' "' $"   3  '  & ("   "  9 >  & ")$""7   H'"2  '8&   ' 8  )$"  ''($" " $<(") (" )   '>"  ( ='" " "'  "  ) &  "' ' ))  ( ' H "8 ( H < (   ' ' = '*H">

,./-0,+//1 *.,--*

' $""72  7'"   "  7"8 B"H"   )" "  (" ) !)::::::2

   @( 7' )) ' )"B' "" +/$" -J' '7+//.&4'L  4'$)7+//J2

J2   1 ) +//1& !) ::::::    @  )  '" "'   ""' 8  <  $   ) (" )   '2

  ')    ($' "' '" "$  '          ("" 6=''H"8 8 '$"  $'" (=&  5" +//1&   " ()"')     )'" < 8  $"    ')& " (")'"   ' <  '" "'   $   ) (" ) '2

12    )  @&  '   & )" "     ' "7 '" "'< ""9+0'$)7+//J&   7"  '  )"  -+ 5" +//12 " ' "$ <  ""9& !):::::: 7>"""  ( "  =H 6=" "8   6=' = "8   ' "')   ")"B ">")" =7')" '" <  '"    )" "' 6=' ' " '>9"' =)*''2

  !)::::::$"  <""')' )  '* ) " '"   ' B  (B"  '  >  "'2  -I  +45$" +//1&$" '"" ='" " "'<( 7 '  "'  ' ")"  "8  H < (   '*H">2   " & (   6="8 "  "   7$"'(B" & "     " """ ' "2 (8" )" $"  8"  !)::::::   "  < )"B $7" ' )*3    < )'" $'" ' <  H < (   '*H"> ' )  H'"2   "$"       "   ""9 $"    )"  "2 !)::::::)" H"9) 3 )"8"" "  '&8( " $')'">"" 2()7& )" H"9) ' $"B "2

  $ "''" "  "'!)::::::'" 3   7"'))""'" """"'  "$ '2

;2  +05"+//1&H "' @ !)::::::&"  ''"2

     '"'& "    8 !) ::::::  )' "  '5' ' )  "7 ( 8'8 7' "'  '  B   8" "  "  '=   8( ($"  '5'  '"   H$"   

,./-0,+//1 *J,--*

H 2 "  ""  M  8( " )'   7=  ')="''>' "') )  & ""&(7 '  '27'))"8 $7"&!)::::::  "  9 "8"     ) 'K   H < (   ' ' = '*H"> " ')'>' "') 2

I2  4/'L +//1&' '7$ "'')) "  @2

  '  B  ) <  ''  '    )  ( "  ''"8)""( "  <"=H  ">>" 2 " ' " "'& ()7   ">"  )"B  >""     8 ( '  " "8  H < (   '*H">& (  = '*H"> (     '  $'82 @"   "9 =6' =9 $"  ' B" &   "  >" )  '"7&       6) F)""8(" 8>" 8($"  '5'B") 8(  "     8( (3 "  < >"& $   H < ( 2  " 9''"7'''"H ")) " ' $"   "8 ?'>"8 ' 7"8 &  )   "') $"$" = "8A2 97""")  &")   '  $"  7" & " '$""  '  ""H   B " 6=" "8>")' 2

  H) 8"5 ">"" )" "(" ) (B" "    )3) )"9 < (=  2   (H""    $ )    ")) )(" ) )"7") <("&'>" ( )(='" " "')"" ' ) >)2

02  @   . )7+//1& @5 )$<(" (" )  !)::::::2

  (      6="8  !) :::::: $"  >$'7)  $' ">"(+//J)" )"' "'"  "'""8 "   "") 7<  8(""$" ' " ) " " )'"2        )""  ) "  < !)::::::"''H" "'" *6="82H< (  H"> )"  >8 2   "  < " 8  H  )"" ='" "'$ 'H"!)::::::)"9 '")'  &'  8('" <'H'"$H<(  '' = '*H">'772 $<(")(" ) '>"  ( ='" " "'  "  )     7'"   "  7"8 B"H" )" "(" ) !)::::::2

   @ (  ' ))  7   '  )"  -+ 5" +//1  '  " ?>2=21A2

,./-0,+//1 *1,--*

-/2  !) ::::::  ""  "7 )""  "> ( ' '   ""'"  -'$)7+//12

  @' ')' )  ($"   ($' '" "$)   8  6="  8"  "$"  $"  $ ?'  '  ""  +/ $" +//.   4'$)7 +//JN '   '> $"  -+ 5" +//1A2  "$" 8" <='" " "'" $' 5$"+//1& ')' ) !):::::: "   7  " < " &$" < )"B $7" ' )*3    < )'" $'" ' <  H < (   '*H">2

  ""& )H  '" "' '  )'" "'" 8"  "   )""& " $&HO<' "8 $"'& <")" ='" " "'& $"H <'"'8" 8"$ 2   '$"     B"H ( 8(  '"H '     <   H  " )  ='" " ""  (    " 8($" 5'(="H ' " ""'2"  "' "  "B "7 "8(' B"H"  (& B >"   >  )"" ='" "&8(B"8' '8( " ") 8(>'" ='" "8("  3 <)3)>"2

  ' )"B) " ($" @&<$'"(B" ( "8H<( = '*H">2@")'" =6' =9$"  7" & "  "  '"7  ' '"H     ") ) "'$"&') '>"8 '7"8 )" )    "')  $  "$" = "8  "   "   =)7 $ (   " 2 9 7""") &   " )    '  $"  7" & " '$""   ""H   '$ B " 6=" "82 ' (=&   "8  "    "        ""'' "'" B"H" 8)(" ) '" ')) )(='" " "'2

  (H)   @ "     9 P'$ Q  )   )""='" "" " <(6& )'$ (B )"">)'"7"" ' "2

  ' <( "'""'8 <8'" '' $)(" ) '>" ()(='" " "'2

--2   4/ '$)7 +//1&  @  )" ' '"  "7 )""  ">2""8*$"    ( 7") ='" " '$   '  " '$"   " ')   ($ "'   83   !) ::::::2 '  & " ($"   ('7$ "'  ""9 < >') >"  "9) <""'. )7+//12

,./-0,+//1 *;,--*

-+2  .)7+//1&5HH<("  "''""  '))""'" """"'  "$ '$ "' "  "'!)::::::&)'"'>$"  '  ' -+5"+//12

-42      -1 5$" +//;&  '))""' ) "'   7" ($ "' )2  (    & ($"')  "     "' !)::::::<"' ""9"7 '$)7+//J($"   ""9)  8 & '))  )'"H"  (")     'H9 (  "' B8 ("  '))R"  < '$'" 2   '" "'&=H) (" "  "''" '$'"8 'H )& 9 ''" "'  ()"' "' $   '$ B)   "  "'2  '8&  '))""'  ")"  8  )  ' (B "'$"  ' "(3 )" 2

-.2  !) ::::::    "$"  <    '7$ "'   '  " 2

   '"  -. >$" +//;&  '"  !) ::::::  "  "7 )""  "> 8(" ($"   $'   '7""    ) <" >"($"  '    8(" "'" >') "'8 ) "9"$" (')H)  6=" "82   $"  "  ' )  "B'" 7   " " "8("  ' " $ "''75 "$8 <"  "'&"8 <($' "'  ) 2

  '"" '') ) ' *B "  " 8 "'<'<(B 2

-J2  '"  )"$"(" "'" ) ?"*9G @  !A 8" ) "  7   ( +//;  H "'    "$" " ')"<)(" ) 2

-12   '"  4 $" +//;&  5H H < ("  "'     ">')' 8("$"H" (''B "2("$" <  )"   "7  8 "'   < >" $'"  $  )' ">   "' < ('   (B   "&  ' ' " @" '$"& "" #!E6=" " 6=' ="2

  '"'" @  !2

-;2  4/$"+//;&' ">') "78(($"  '75 "'<>"$'"<(' "H "'(B &" ')) 8 "'<'<*"2

,./-0,+//1 *I,--*

-I2  0)"+//;& "'  ">')8 " H<5H >'2

 ' 

-2   5   )  " $   5"" "' ')  &  '   $7? 2J1 '"S'H" "'5"""++'$)7-0.-*  *  + /JN  2 14 2 - " 2    '"   ' )""  "$  -+ )7-0IJ* * J-/A2

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

 72  (9&  "7 "'  )  "& ' ))   "H) )"B&'5H>'2(6'" ' < (  ("  "'& ' >') ( ' <  B " 6=" "8&'"" ' 2

42 2  - 5$" +//;&  '$ "'" "'   '" >  -4)7+//+)'">"  "H '  $"H2

  '>'))  < S " +  "'" "' " '"  &  ')  '$ '"   "$ B ) ? 2 J1 < 1J A   <  B "' ? 20/ A ("8  " B   (  '))" ' 5H $    $"HTUV2

   "7 )""  ">  5H 8("  "  ')   ' B)"  7"*>'""'" @$ ( $"H$""'

,./-0,+//1 *0,--*

 ''H$'"+0 )7-0;;? * .+/A& '   -J )7 +//1      $"H  -4 >$" +//; ? ,-+;,+//;+/)+//;A2

  )3)3 & "7)""  ">5H8("$" B)" 7"*>'   ""'  @ ' (H  '"   >'  $"H  )')    "   ""' 82  ''7  &    3   5H"""'8$ "7(" "'"   ) ?  !A     (" "'   " + =">> +  "'" "' " '"  1J'"(" "' '"  ( '">) "9-;)+//1? * .-/A2

.2  @' ( " -/      7  &  @  "  ( '"  ')   ' )) ') >"<(" ) &$'"=F" &='" '  " )  )7 '"  "8  ')B& '  '"  "7 "' < ("   ' ")'  9H  '" 2   "  ')   H) '' )"  ''" H "'2

   (9&  ' ' "'    < B "  '7""  " '  '')(" )    ( " .4 " -  & (B "'   "      " "'("+ )3)"'" "'2

   ' "''>") )(" ) 2

   (  )&  5H B '   ") 8( "'  '    ) &  '  ')') "  H$)   "  7"8   8(" 6 $" ")"">)'$")"H( "2  '9$"' '5'( 7") '"$ H" "'>2(9& ' "' ")8 "'  =)*''& ')   "   6=" "8& '$" 

3  '" '))   7")  '"2  )3) '" "' '"$  $'" '  ( 7")    ""9&  8   "' "+0'$)7+//J2

J2  '"$&>"" "$) '<("&)''&" >  B)" (     '    "8 8( '))   '$ "> "'? #-++I'"242-J,-1A2H'" ( "    )&  '  8(" 6  "  '   $  ' 7  H'"  ' ''  $   ) ? 3  "7 >

1 21-,+//.-I' '7+//.&'"2.2A2

  (9& @&'')'"B)"' 8 6=" & >"9$<(")(" ) 2@' 5"&  "7 )""  "> (")'   "   (H" 

,./-0,+//1 *-/,--*

 8 "' ="8 ' )" '8 ( '"  " ")   ')'& '))  (9&  ""  "'   ')  8" ? ,4/+,+//14/)"+//1 >" A2

   @  '"&   7   ' '   "' >"  '  (" "'   '   +0 5" +//1 "" 8   '  )"B& ' ))  "  -+ 5" +//1  '   & 8 "     )$" "&"'7  " 2 "9'"8(   ) ' 8" )    8( ")   $"') 8'H9'  ' ?$ "'-15$" +//;'))""'" """"'  "$ 'A2@' ' " &=H) (" "  "''" '$'"8 'H )&9''" "'()"' "'$ '$B) "  "'2

    8" 9& " '  8 " (   6="8   '  ()"'& H"'( ' " 2 )>H"   =H)  (" "  "' '"  '$'8  8""7 ")'  2  $<(")(" ) '$ '$'"8()"" ='" " '$ & (  < 5  "  8  @   ") 8  )  " &'"'"' &( " "7" 7" "88('" $ = "82

  '" "'&>$<(")(" )  '' @ >> "$) >' '>")2

  (" 8'5 2

12  "  "''' &)') R ? 2I; A2("" "H&")" '2

 WWWWW

)& '        

-./0 !1

 $7  ' " 5   - '$)7 +//1  !) :::::: ' ""'. )7+//1'"$"6=" "8N



,./-0,+//1 *--,--*

/021

5 N

" 8("( R()') &"'(")" N

"  8& '>'))  B  " I+   "$    '" >   "7 >-;5"+//J? #*@-;42--/A& ""' 3 '    5'8""$ ' ">" "'*$  "7>&$'" ') "9'" 7"N))'"''" ""8'"'& )' "> )'6$ ' "H ' '') "N" '"  3    "7 >& -///  -.&  $'" '  '  $'"  '"8 B '" "'  S " .+  #2    ""'    "9  '"'  ' & "$'8 ')) )'6  $& '"$  3  5'"  < S$'"N

'))"8 3 <!"#"$%&$' ' &'" $"6=" "8&'" '"$"(" "'" ) ""8( "7(" "'" )'">') "'2

@"H G !)'$6&" &!)E"&!2 ="&5H&!!2H   &5H 2

') "7)""  ">G

H>>"9*5" 522"2G  $"*" G     2 2'$6  

'"'>') 3  '))"8B "2

 9$&  H>>"9G           

,./-0,+//1