Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/248/2007 • CJ GE ATA/248/2007 Généré par l'IA

Assignment Priority in Security Interest Dispute

Numéro de cause ATA/248/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute arose from a series of transactions involving a security interest, where a party claiming an assignment of rights under a prior agreement sought to enforce its interest against collateral held by another entity, which had subsequently entered into agreements with the original obligor. The court reasoned that the assignment, although purporting to transfer all rights, was valid as an assignment of a contractual right to payment, and that the subsequent agreements did not effectively subordinate the assignee's interest, ultimately holding that the assignee had a priority security interest in the collateral because its rights were established prior to the later conflicting claims and the procedures for perfecting those rights were satisfied.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Assignment Priority in Security Interest Dispute: The court reasoned that the assignment, although purporting to transfer all rights, was valid as an assignment of a contractual right to payment, and that the subsequent agreements did not effectively subordinate the assignee's interest, ultimately holding that the assignee had a priority security interest in the collateral because its rights were established prior to the later conflicting claims and the procedures for perfecting those rights were satisfied.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
cession de créance cession de créance aux fins de sûreté conflit d'intérêts opérations portant sur des titres paiement des intérêts droit acquis

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/2566/2007
Assignment vs. Security Interest Dispute
A/1554/2007
Secured Transactions Priority Dispute
A/4127/2006
Security Interest Priority Dispute Over Corporate Assets
A/1934/2006
Priority of Security Interests and Perfection of Liens
A/2170/2004
Security Interest Priority Following Collateral Transfer

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court orders the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

       

  

    



 !"!#$%&





%&"!'()))))) 



* + ** ,, ** * +- , 





     !"# 

* 

%(  )*++++++,-***.++++++,/ '%%0' 123,**4 5-**6/&.-6%778(

!(  9*5* *6-***:,4 54..-*;***;(

&(   %! 5-6 !''# < '71%=, )( ++++++ **  2 4 2*     3  **  3 >, ?4*  5  -@*   2.1*(   5*2*   2  5 2.(   2*A>,*..*5.5A :*;(

  9  55  5* .6*  %! 5-6 !''#, )( ++++++ 5.**A3.*4.6*..,<2**42*>3 *B.(4.1>-;*5,*2*45*A?* .6*34->!,%'AC(

  )( ++++++  .. D.  *  2*  41E  5*   A(

  *****..*:*.1-5(

$(   .**  %! 6 !''#,  2*  -6*    2*A* F* 5;G 9 H  5. < 4  )( ++++++  ***:*A5-**.A***,< * 5.2*: 5  . *.-*., 4* *2**  -.* .A F* 5;G )H . 1A.  5. <  3- 55:*  4.25*<*2.1*<-4*..(

  *.**5.**?42*54::5*:(

=(  )(++++++** *6-***:4.** 5.*.582-6!''#(

   4 5 .  :* ?* * .* 51. -*  *-. ? 4***  * 5  . *.-*. .* 5 .2; . . ?4* 42* B-* --* 4*:*   -*;( 5*  %!5-6 !''#, * 4.* 6   --*  6* *.5*B-  (43--.**-6* 5 .* 5*?4* 4.* 2*- -* <  *2*  *- -.*(

"$%#&"!''# &"# 

  5*B:*,*AA*5*---. 54).*1->(2**?:<*(

  455**35(

#(    *  -5* 5  %% .-6 !''#, )(++++++:*-.-(

    5*  ?4* 2* 2 <  5.  2. 4> A* --, ** ?4 *   -.* *   -*-(

  9 ..?45;.-5.*.:* .  >, * * 4 4  -*;   * 4-*(

0(  925,BA..A.<4** 4.5*!=B2*8-!''0,**-5* 5-*.*%=:.2*!''0,5*%=-!''0,55*  - 2*.   5; 26  4*  -5* 5-*.(

8(  !!-!''0,)(++++++--*?.*6. .4>::.%&-!''0.*A.**I.1>*? J',%'A"K(

  &'-!''0,9 5*..**5*(

7(  %=2*!''0,5*--5.-*,< 2*, 3  .-  6* -.* @ 6* < 3 5*2  I2*K, -.*- 1.5*? 5  *-  4*- 1*?   35**  (   *,  *  5.*. ?4* 4.* 5 .5  4, ?  :*  %!5-6 F!''#, H .* *.  4**2*   3  *::*. :**;  ?4* 4.* -* 2*-   5*  *--.*(62*54.**5B-*6*( <.2**.**5*<?**.* *5>(

%'(  *25*;,9 5*..**(

"$%#&"!''# $"# 

* , 

%(  B.  -5 * 2  B*** -5.,    26F(=# *LA**B***!!2-6%7$%     ! '=M ( #& ( % *(    *   5. -***2  %!5-6%78=    =%'H(

!(  4A 4 5-*  * .A 5 D **  2  *5**?*455*?*5-***F($=((% 4.A4-**52.1*<** *;!06%70#   90$%(=%H(

&( ( 9 4* %# *. %  6   * :..   ** *;%7.-6%7=8F  90$%('%H,5-***. 5.*.-*.<5?*::4:-.5 *5<*(

 6( 4* &'   5-  * < * 5.2*:  5-*  * ?4*3*.*3?<45*<*4(  4A* 4 *  .*., ?* 4 5  5*, -*  - -***22*<.*.:*( B*:**A-5 ?*AF "%=!"!''=%&-!''=H( B*5   *,  5*.  *   ** 5 D -*   ** -6*(  5 ?*  *  2.1*-6*56*?*2*:.:*( *,*.*.L*&'*.5-*  * D . F D  *6 :.. # (%%%"!'''  !' - !''%M "!8%"!''%  !$ 2* !''%M ( 9 N //N 9 , *  1O*P*19 2Q11,2(G* -***2-1-, %77=,5(=$H(

$(  ?**<5*?3- 45*< * -6* * D . 5  5 ?*  *.  . 5*  6*55-*;:**?,..:*3.5 *6:.. <!,=AC,2*<%,0=ACF D *6:..# (%%"!''%  &' - !''%   .:. *.M / %!#  %8= ( !   .:.*.H(

=(   45;,   4 5 4..  -*;  ** *;34->!,%AC45.(

   5*; 5* 5      .*. 4 *2* -.* 5*  -* 46 !''#(  -.*- 5* *  

"$%#&"!''# ="# 

3, 6 -**.      3*-* 3 5*.(  *,  -.*- 5 *:  5*.  .*,  5*  -5-  *  2.1*M  455*? 5**;-  ** 2 4(   .A,  *6 -***: ;2 ?  -.* . 4 .-*  55.**  45* < *  (

  **,:?4*3***.*3.5  ?   *, 4*. .* :. < 2*    45*<*(4*519 42* :*A5*6**.?*4*&=*.&   ***  * < * 5.2*:,  4  .  435*<?*5.4)(

   >  * :*  5.* ?  - ?.  .5* 5 4::/,--(

#(  B.(4***A,-*5*-5  ** :**; 5.*  ,  .-- .*  N/!''(  -*<1AF(80 H(

 RRRRR

.  *,  *    

/01%'!2

.26*B.82-6!''#5)*++++++ .**%!6!''#2*-6*2*A**:* ***:*A5-**.A***< * 5.2*:, 6   1A 4* *2**  -.* .A5.<3-55:*M

1%&2

BM

-<1A.-- N/!''( M

* ?, :-.- 3 * 8!  *2   * :..   *6 :..  %0 B* !''= F / 9 %0&(%%'H,  5. D 5 D 5.    B ?* *2  *:** 5 2  *6 :.., 5  2* 

"$%#&"!''# #"# 

-*;*56*M-.-****?*, -*:->525*A-*M* * D .  *6 :.., %'''  %$, 5 2* 5  5 2* .*? 3 **  L* $!  /(  5. D   5*;  5*  , *2?. -- ->  52, *2 D B* < L2*M

--*?5.D<)*++++++,2*-6* 2*A***?4<L::*:..<(

9*.AG )-2>,5.*,))(>1; 1.*,BA(



- *6-***:G

A::*; B*B((*(G  2* 5.*G     ( (2>   

5*:-D..--*?.35*(

 ;2,  A::*;G           

"$%#&"!''#