Appeal Regarding Denial of Extension for Petition for Review of Property Transfer Dispute
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case involves an appeal regarding the denial of an extension of time to file a petition for review, stemming from a dispute over the validity of a property transfer that occurred over a decade prior, where the appellant claimed not to have been properly served and alleged fraud and misrepresentation by the other party concerning the property's condition and value. The court reasoned that the appellant failed to demonstrate good cause or excusable neglect for the untimeliness, noting the significant delay, the availability of prior legal remedies, and the appellant's apparent lack of diligence in pursuing the matter once they became aware of the underlying issues, thus affirming the trial court's discretionary decision to deny the extension.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Appeal Regarding Denial of Extension for Petition for Review of Property Transfer Dispute: The court reasoned that the appellant failed to demonstrate good cause or excusable neglect for the untimeliness, noting the significant delay, the availability of prior legal remedies, and the appellant's apparent lack of diligence in pursuing the matter once they became aware of the underlying issues, thus affirming the trial court's discretionary decision to deny the extension.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the final order to regulate the costs of the appeal proceedings.
Texte complet
! "#$%
$%! &&&&&&&&&&& !!"#$%&'
'
'(( ' ( '( )(' * +
(' )('
()*+(
,/ !'" !00000000000% 00000000000 ,1+2% ' " "3"/ "& 4" ,115% 67 8' "'" 7 93" "' 6'" / " % " :8"" 9 3" "6 "'" 8' "'"" "'67/: )..)% !6 !00000000000 ;" 4"/ % "" ; " !/!00000000000% ' 3" < 9'88" ' ' "' ="( 7>9 ?2,@&")..)/
)/ ,+ 6:)..2%!/!00000000000'<9 6 9 '" "' @' ' / )- @&" )..5% " 6 '"' = 4?'9" 6#&9 /
""' ,2 @&" )..A% 9 8 "& 9 '" "' '"" % ; !/ !00000000000 9&" @6" 8'" '6 " <9"6%;9"9&" '" B'";" " &" ;9" 9&" ' 8""7 88" '&"&4"/" ,A&")..A 8"B<9" /
4 ),@")..A%'66""' '''" 3 ="(7> '66""'? @ ' !/ !00000000000 < 9' ""' " / ';% 9 ''3 2, ' ':)..A""6 "<!/!00000000000';" " '""/
2/ ,) @" )..A% 9'88" 8 6"3 "' =!? '' 9B "' < ' " '" '8 "' ""' &'" ' 7&/ " ,A 6: )..A " "6 " < !/!00000000000 ' ;" " '" '8 "'/ & ' 9" 988 "8/ ""' & < 9B" &6 "'C" '&:<9"";D/
5/ )5'E )..A%9 "<' !/!00000000000:"" ' #'' :/ "(";9"";9 " ;9 ' / F '6"" 8"B 6" 6'" #:" "6'"9&")..A%0000000000#G!'"00000000000/" 7&";F %!/!000000000009 B /
A/ )1'E )..A%9!"""'" ";< %& '6'"8" "';" " 8"B2,' ':)..A/" ' ""' ' < 9B" & 6 "' C' 6D/
*,))-*)..- (2*+(
-/ - 6: )..A% 9 #3 !'" #8 '" 9 6 9B "'8"9";&'"!/!00000000000< " "' 3'% "3"/ " 8"" 9':@ 9 ""' 8 &'" 8"" "& B '"/
H/ ,- 8&" )..-% '" @""" "8'6 9 ; !/!00000000000 " " '&:63 ' ##/
+/ ))6)..-%!/!00000000000 F '"3&'"/ &" ' I"73';9"86" 6"@/
"'8" @'(6F6<36"%!/!00000000000 ';9"9&" 9 '" "'@'4""2,@&" )..)/&" &"'""6'"& %;9"&" ;" J/4'" '"9&" '" &@" ;""&" " ;9" " &'"/"' ':)..A%"9&" '&/9&" 8" 6#' ''J9'"3"/ '"" 9 67% ; " 9&" '& " 9 )..2/ &" 3" " 4" " '6" ';'" ' &'" 8" "/ ' %"9&" 9 @"""/
1/ ))6)..-<).#A.%9'88""'"6 96 <9' !/!00000000000%"(" &9"8 "'<9 " )2 '" 8 @' K :"6 3 )- 6 ,12,=4 (4,5)/).?/
)26)..-%'66""'"B!/!00000000000/
,./ )26)..-<,.#5.%'66""'"' 6" "' 6"" "& !/ !00000000000 ' '" 6'"% ; '" "' 9 " ,2: " , 4 " 6"/!/!000000000008"" 9':@ 9""' 8&'" 4"% 8"" "& B '"/ B" " "" ' &" ; 9" " ' "<'8'6 /9B6 6 9 '" "' @'% !/ !00000000000 9&" ':' &9 %' " <'"'6 < ' /&" 6"&'"'6""8"B/9&" ;" 4" '66" " 8""8"B2,' ':)..A/ 8"%"&" "";<'";9"&'" ;" 4" ''J 9'"3"/
,,/ )2 6 )..- < ,-#..% !/ !00000000000 '6 & '66""'=6' " ?/ '"'%";9"' " "'6"" "&%"9 " 3B/9''" <' ' "3"/49"9 " %" " 8"/
*,))-*)..- (5*+(
9 "'8"6 "'9'6" "' 9 ' <@ "; </
,)/ ""')26)..-%'66""''8"69'6" "''96'"/' " ';9&'" &<:8"&8'6 9" /
,2/ !/ !00000000000 "" ": 6"" "8 9 ' ' ""'" 2&")..-/
:6 %"' <F '6 %8'% ''6"": "66" &" 8" /
"";" &'"'8"" F '"' = 4? F ' ' ; "' " 6' "& ' : ':' "'/ 6 % " &"&" #G !6 00000% 00000000 < 7&/ 933" < ' < ' '&' "' &'J < "" ;9< ' 6' #' ' : =.H+/000000?/ "% " " "' 6' " " " 6 & ' '6""" 4" #G ; " '&" 36 F @'" / 93"" !6 00000% '6""" #G % 00000000% '/'#" " '&'"&'"'6""78'" "" &'" & ;" 4"/ &" 8" ;9" 9&" @6" '66" 9"8 "'":"'6 "'4"/
,5/ A &" )..-% '66""' ' ' '"% " ;9 9&" 9':& "'<8'6/
,A/ '-&")..-%9'88""'"9 '''/
&' < " "' 3' &" '3" ' A &" )..- 6 "6""9&" F B %!/!000000000009 ''< &'"/&" '" <L6:'"@'(6F6/9"")2&")..-% '&&'&' " '3"< " "'"3"/6 "G( 9 " 6 'M 9" " :8"9' &:/
!/!00000000000 " '&"'"'&'"8" 9':@ 9' NL''3).6)..5/ '"'%"&" ' F ''66 6"@/ &" 36 8" 9':@ 9 ' "36 )A 6 )..5 ' B7 :" '63" 9 @ ;" &'"8" O" :"7 :/ 8"%"&" " )-' ':)..5'&'<9 3' :' "'N/
*,))-*)..- (A*+(
B" " 8" 9"" "B ' 6 ' ; !/ !00000000000 " ' " < ' 8'6 % 9: ':' "' "" ; ' '6' 6 "'/ "'" 6'J9B" 4" 86""""" "3"/ 6 " "" '' "'" "' ' 6'"% ;'8"6'66""'% "8"" <""/
(
,/ @ 6 " & @"" "' '6 % ' &:= /A- '"K'3" "'@"""))'&6:,15,( ( ) .A P / -2 / , " / '" ' 6"" "& ,) 6:,1+A( ( A,.?/ 9 36 3 ",2 "24 "";,.")'"9" "''"8 @' 9 :"6 3,-@",1++=4 QL),.?/
)/ " "' 9 " ,. " ) 4 % ": 6"" "8 "B@';""& ""/
' "'5&")..-/"'66<'" 7 6" ' # " &" ,5 &" )..-/ ,.&")..-% ": "" /
2/ !/ !00000000000 8" 9':@ 9 ""' &'" 4" B '" 8"" "& " '66""' " ' 6 "7 9",@" )..5/
" " " ' "6 " 9!% " 2,' ':)..A/
5/ 4' K " ,2: " , 4 % ';K ""' &'" ' KB"'6"7" ' "8"%K '" '6 %B8" K KB "'% 6 ' ' "' '; "" ' 8' " ;K ' " 8'6 % "" 'M " K':"3 "' ':' K " ,2 8 4 K " + " , " 5 '" K")-@",11+/
A/ @3 "' '" ""' 3" "'%"";K; "'9 6/' I3" "3"8" ' K:';K"'" &"8"" "''' '6 ":& '"/ ""% "& "' ": % " 8 6" " 6' "8 3 "'B" %"(" : 3" "6%"K':"3 "'"
*,))-*)..- (-*+(
%"8'6 B : "%'%6 '' "' ; /
-/ 97% 9 '" 6"7 " '" ;9" B" " "" ' ' ; ' " ' " < ' 8'6 ;' 9&" "6#& ' '&'' "'J9'"3" ;9"&" " ;9"8" ''J9'"3"/
9B6'"%"R ;6 '"& F "&"/ 88 % 9" &" ; ':' "' ' & 9 8"" % 639 6" 4%"9 6'";9" F " '" '6 % ' 66 )5 'E )..A/ ' ' ":6"" "8%' ''''" ' #G ; " '3 < 7&% ' ' 6' #' ' : "" ; ''' ' 6"/ " 9336 ' < ' '&' "' ;" " " < 9 ' 9 / 493" ' ' "3"% '" 36 % 6 ' ' " < ;9" 9 9J '' & 3% " ;9" '#" '&'" ' ' 6" "78'" ""&'"& ;" 4"=#/,A/A' 5 &" )..A?/ 8"% ' 9 8" 9':@ 9 '6 "' 4"/ 3% '" &6 9'88"" '" '-&")..5' <8"3"@""" 9" " ' F < #3/ 9 < @ " ; 9 '" " "69J9"8" 8/
H/ ""'' "'" 3'& ' "' ";/
" "'6 %""'' "'" '6'73 9 " Q;"B"3;6'J#'""'" '< ": 8"B(% " Q;""6';9 "6'J %'#'""";" ' 9 " 6'"3&B" F "&( '' "'" '" ( ;" 6 : 88 6 #'"" " "' 96"" '6 '" & 9" F :" = L,/)-1*)..,%'"/)P L,)A5H5'"/2/5+)P *2))*)..A )+&")..A *5,*)..A)A@&")..A?/
97%7';' 9336 'B '&' "' ;" " ' < 9 ;9" 6 "'% " 8 6 ;6" "'6"" "& "'' "'/: ##% < &'" 9B "' &'" ' F " ; "("'" 8'6 /
*,))-*)..- (H*+(
+/ & ;" 7% ' 6" ""' ; 6F6;9'88""'")26)..-/ ": ''": "'"66" !/!00000000000/"6" ' SLA../('' <#39 7&/ & 6' "8 96""' '% 6'6 6" < #39'88""'"/
TTTTT
) ' (
,-$ .
&: ' " @ 5 &" )..- !'" !00000000000 ' ""''66""' '''" 3)2 6)..-P
-$%.
96 P
""' '66""' ' ' '" 3 )26)..-"";9'88""'"6F6@'P
''& "'6"" "&&88 "66" P
' < !/ !00000000000 "6" ' SL A../( < #3 9 7&P
" ;K"K OK6'6 P
" ;% '8'66 B " 1H "& '" 8 K'3" "' @"""% F F ' %&'"''" 6"" "8% @' 7 ' "8" "'% & ": 8P 66'" ''" "";'"'%6' "8 6'J& ' "3 ' ''6 "P"'" F '"B6"6'" ": 8% ,... ,5P F "7 '"' ' %"&';'666'J&%'"& F @'" <K&'"P
*,))-*)..- (+*+(
'66"; F < ! !"# $% &' ' % < '66""' ' ' '" 3% < 9'88"" '"% < 9'88" '' "'"";9<9'88"86"3 "'/
4"3 > !6'&J%" %!!/J#7 #"%@3/
'6 ":6"" "8>
388"7(@" > &"(" > /"'(4"3" /'&J
'"'8'6 F '66";B "/
7&% 388"7>
*,))-*)..-