Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/197/2007 • CJ GE ATA/197/2007 Généré par l'IA

Taxpayer Barred from Retroactively Recharacterizing Financial Instruments to Claim New Tax Benefit

Numéro de cause ATA/197/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute concerned the tax treatment of certain financial instruments where the taxpayer, who had previously claimed deductions based on the instruments' characterization as debt, later sought to recharacterize them as equity following a statutory change that negatively affected the debt deduction. The court reasoned that the prior consistent treatment of the instruments as debt for tax purposes created a strong presumption against the taxpayer's subsequent attempt to retroactively recharacterize them as equity, which was necessary for the claimed tax benefit under the new statute, affirming the principle that a party generally cannot adopt inconsistent positions in tax matters without a substantial factual or legal change.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Taxpayer Barred from Retroactively Recharacterizing Financial Instruments to Claim New Tax Benefit: The court reasoned that the prior consistent treatment of the instruments as debt for tax purposes created a strong presumption against the taxpayer's subsequent attempt to retroactively recharacterize them as equity, which was necessary for the claimed tax benefit under the new statute, affirming the principle that a party generally cannot adopt inconsistent positions in tax matters without a substantial factual or legal change.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
instruments financiers dette fiscale prestation statutaire imposition des gains en capital sûretés fiscales objet du litige

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision dictates the allocation of court costs, as referenced in the dispositive order regarding costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2212/2003
Recharacterization of Financial Instruments and Transactions for Tax Purposes
A/2707/2006
Tax Treatment of Financial Instrument Payments
A/3212/2023
Taxpayer Challenge to Reassessments Including Previously Taxed Annuity
A/1465/2019
Taxpayer v. Tax Authority: Fiduciary Sale Proceeds Recharacterized as Taxable Dividend
A/3218/2021
Fiduciary Claim Barred by Prior Tax Declarations

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision dictates the allocation of court costs, as referenced in the dispositive order regarding costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

  

   

 

!"

#"$%&'





&'#"())))))  !"# $%%&'(% 

% 

* + ** ,,** *+- , 





     )*+,)

* 

/0  !%$ 111111' %2$$$ 3  "%'   $ $ 4 2$  %$%("$32% $*,5($/6,70

*0   %$%$% $82$$  $5'%  5$ 4%89 42 $ 2$%$442%$' %%/:% %8*..:'$%4;<($ 0  2  ; *28*..:*9($*..-0

70   /, 2 *..,' 4$   $  (%  4  %2%8$   %   = ) >'    %  ' 3  ($   ,6 ?2+"' 2>  $  $ ' % @  ($  2;$2  %$  $   -. ?2+"0  2 ($ $$ /6?2+"0

:0  *A9$*..,'!0111111;$@($ %2%8$  ($> $% B$)<C = D @4$ ($  '  $  $%' @  ($  3   %$  $ A.?2+"0

-0   $$%  A 9$  *..,'  =    $  2$  %$  !0111111%42%$$ $%4 $/,$/ %$5$ $%% $</628/6-EB )=A:/0./D0 % 5$;  @% $    2'  =    %2       4$ '  $@         7/ 28 *..:'  5(%80

,0   2$3% /69$ *..,'!0111111%%   $$% <  $8 2$$  $5' %  3 %  $%    %% 4 ( $2 0  ($  %22$  5  ><' %(  5$ 4%89 4$2( $2 0 ($ 8%  ';< ($ $F  %":7%$ ' $($   $% 4( 5$ 34%$>$$$%@0

A0  %4$%2 $%% $ 28 *..,' 4$   $   % %0   %  $    @$5$ $% %89 $(= 2$5$  $ %2 $8(( $2 0

  = 2$ $$%0($ $@ $@%5$2 9$%4$%$  (<>%%(0

  =@%$' >39>0



+*,-.+*.., )7+,)

* , 

/0   9   2  $ (   9$$ $% %2  '  %   (8B 0-, %$G%>$ $%9$$$%(28/6:/) ) *.-H 0,70/$ 0%$%2$$  $(/*  28/6E-) ) -/.D0

*0  "%$  $>; 2@  $$$>; 5$; ($ 2;$2B 0*A0/ H 0/, G%% $>$ $%% $<- 28/6A6)=)=A:/0*/H I/.E,*D0

70   ($  %$  %9% J    ; $% ' % 22  ;  $$ ("$ ">2 '$$@G;%$ $%% '  $ $%     ($$8$$ 0 ; %$  %K % ("$ %$  >J  $ $%'%   $ 2  'G$5 'GJ ' % 22 ;%$ %K($$8$$ G 8%';$  $%@G$  28>'$$@G;>3$(B 07*0/ D0

  G $/,$/ $ @2$%$ J  $ %@G %$ %  @%$ $%>$(%  %  %   2$ % %@   $ $% %  %8$> $% $2%  $$'%$('G%  %8(0  $ %$ J  ;$% B 0/,07 D0

  %$ 8$ $$$ $ $% C

 )$5 $%><B 0/,0/ 0 8 DH

 )$5 $%2%F2 >(B 0/,80/ 03 DH

 )$5 $%>(B 0/,0/ 035 D0

     $< >%$'($% $%>(G<> $ $%'G $6."$55* '%$ %K%  $;>%$ G $%$$@B I /*7/.,' /66AA*-'%$0*8'0A*A)A*E 50$ 0D0

   $   (%    (%$    $%  $) $ '   @$  %   %  '  %   ($%  $%$ $% $ 0

:0   G$ $  %$ '  ($  2;$2 >  ("$    $ -. ?2+"' %@  %$ $%   % '   $ $%    ($$8$$ % 5(%8%G $:$/ G%% <>   $ $% % $<  /7 %(28 /6,* B  ) = A:/0//H I /*/  /*A'   /66-  ,,:D0 =% G$ -    2J2 $%$ $%' 

+*,-.+*.., ):+,)

$>; (  $$@ G  ($  2;$2' )$    $8 $ $2$  $%>($ 0

  =%  9$  $8 5  2 $<  2   ($  3 G$ $ G %$ '  2    ($  2;$2  %$  - 3 *. ?2+" % $   $5 $% >< @$ 9 $5$  $2 ( $2 G $/,$7 B I/7A' /66A A77'%$0/'0A7AD'%  @% 4$ 5$ 4%89 '  ;   ' 4  $   2$ % 4   2 2$$  $(B 0/,0* D0

  4<'2 ($  %$% $ $5 $% ><'%224% 2  = 0

-0  /9($*..-'%($%$ $% $( $ 2$ %$%  ($>B*..*0*A',A D0 % 5%$'% $%$ $% $ %$   %('   $<  4$@ @4; $5 $%;$%$ $%$ $%% $<%22$<%   ($>0 "@ 5%$ @4  %  $  5%      $%4$%$ '$%($ 2@L  23 %%$%$4($ ">0=$4$%$  5(%8'$F $4$@$$%$ $%$$(( $$ ;2$ $%B!M '%($%$ $%> $ 2$ %$$ I*..:'07,/ % 22 :*7 H +,E,+*.., /628*..,D0

  % 5$ 4%89 4 $ 2$%$/:% %8 *..:0 4 <%4$%$ @$4$@0

,0  =%  9$  $( 3  $$(    5  ><' (%( 4 ($>4  '$% $%2  4$$( 4$%%$<2B I/*E E,'E6)6.D0

  '2 $ %% ; 4(  5$ 34%$>$$$%@04F($ <%$4 $ %2 0 (428$% ' = $ $$L ( $2 % 0

A0   (   @$ <'  %  2$0  ( $2   % $  $ 2$42%$%% = '% $$% %$ 0

E0   4$  $ $>'  2%2   NI :..0)  2$ 3  ">  = 0$2$  NI-..0)%% '3">4   <(0

+*,-.+*.., )-+,)

 OOOOO

.  *,  *   

/ 0&1"2

(8%$ 9 /69$ *..,!%$111111%  $$%($ %2%8$ ($> $%A9$ *..,$ $ % 2$%$%42%$H

0&'2

42 H

$$%($ %2%8$ ($> $%@4%%  $ 2$% H

( $2 % H

2  3  ">  ($   %2%8$     ($> $%  2%2   NI:..0)H

%$2$  NI-..0)% '3">4  <(H

$  @' %5%22  ;  $ E*   $(    %$ 5   $8 5  /A 9$ *..- B I)= /A70//.D'    J    J  %      9% @$ $(   % $5$ $% )(   $8 5'   (%$  %2 $<%$ 8$H22%$%%$ $$@%$%' 2% $5 2%F( % $> % %%2 $H$ %$  J    $8 5' /...  /:'  (%$ %  %  (%$  %$@ ; %$ $%  G $ :*  I0    J     $<  %$%  % ' $(%@ %22 2%F  (' %$(  J  9%$  3 G(%$H

%22$@ J 3!"# $%%&'(% % $$@G ($ %2%8$ ($> $% 3G%55$5% 30

=$> C !0F"<'$ '!2N$ %'9>0



+*,-.+*.., ),+,)

%2 $82$$  $5C

>55$<)9$ 900$0C  $ C     0 I0F"<   

%$%5%2 J  %22$@; $0

 <('  >55$<C           

+*,-.+*..,