Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/188/2007 • CJ GE ATA/188/2007 Généré par l'IA

Summary Judgment Standard in Employment Termination Case

Numéro de cause ATA/188/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The plaintiff sought damages after a termination resulting from internal investigation findings that included admissions of wrongdoing and were supported by documentary evidence, but the appellate court found that the lower court erred in applying the correct standard for summary judgment by improperly weighing conflicting testimonial evidence. The court reasoned that on a motion for summary judgment, the evidence and any inferences therefrom must be viewed in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, meaning the lower court improperly resolved factual disputes regarding the investigation's fairness and the truthfulness of the admissions, which required a trial.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Summary Judgment Standard in Employment Termination Case: The court reasoned that on a motion for summary judgment, the evidence and any inferences therefrom must be viewed in the light most favorable to the nonmoving party, meaning the lower court improperly resolved factual disputes regarding the investigation's fairness and the truthfulness of the admissions, which required a trial.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
cessation d'emploi interprétation de l'arrêt maxime inquisitoire négligence professionnelle de l'avocat liquidation sommaire de la faillite fixation du tort moral

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive for ordering the losing party to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
C/13276/2021
Wrongful Termination Due to Biased Internal Investigation
A/1418/2001
Wrongful Termination due to Procedural Unfairness in Disciplinary Process
A/291/2023
Employee Termination Unlawful Due to Flawed Investigation
C/9618/2020
Wrongful Termination Based on Flawed Investigation
C/23435/2017
Employee Termination for Alleged Theft Overruled Due to Flawed Investigation and Lack of Due Process

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the losing party to pay the costs of the federal court proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

    

  







!"#$%%%%%%  !" #$%&' 

' 

&''& '   &' ('&  ) *     '&  ('&  





     ()*+(

 

,2  !'3"444444%444444,5/,% ' 3  33%   6' 744444483 '3  33 #3)) 93)00+2

)2   ). ' ': )00+% ' ;63  3  '   '3  3 ' 63 3 "444444<444444%444444,5/-%'3=33 33%36  &' 3>3'3 =&'333' 63 3 3'? "3 3 @ ' '   6'>>3 >  83= 3' A3(B C !D%  /  8:)00+ &:9;61 8:)0,,2

    33'%    >'%   8' 3&   '8' 8   63  8' 3>6' 3 :3%3'63> 3'@ '3> >3 E' ':,5.,A" ("/,)2,),D @ '3>9' ? :38  =)+8,5E,A" ( ",-)2)0D2

E2  ' '383 3:833  3>;!2"444444  '(''3 3 ''3( '3 9333 833  3& 383B3& C

 ( )/93 )00+C ('8 3'  ''  ' = =&'3 @  3 6 8'3 683'8  & 3   '3 % ' 3> 3' @  "  @" 

   (3 3 3'       3  3 '3 =&'3%'3F8'3%'' '8833'32

 ( ,/ 8:)00+C ('8 3'  ''  ' = =&'3 @  3  &3=  9' 683'8  & 3  '3 % ' 3> 3'@"  @" 

 ( ,0'&8:)00+C ('8 3'  ''  9= 63  3' =&'3 @  3    9' 683'8 % '  3'    9'    3'& 3&%'&'23')/ 93 )00+ &';2

 ( )>&3)001C ('8 3'  ''  9= 63  3' =&'3 @  3  F 8'3

*,-./*)001 (E*+(

683'8 % '  3'  3F 9'    3'& 3&%'&' 3> 3'@" 2

 ( ,8)001C (33'  &'3  "3  3 3'  6 3 ,) 3 , "  ''  6'>>3  '' 3'B&A3(BC D% F '3'':  '2

 ( )/8)001C ('8 3'  ''  9= 63  3' =&'3 @  3 33  ;3G 9'( 8% '  3'    9'(8 ''  @   9'    3' &  9=8 %  8'    9'(8    >3F @ HI E02(% ' 6''3 3' F    6 '3 % 63 6  ''@6F 3''&'3 &))8)0012

-2  )/8)001%'8833'3B&''83   3'833  3&!2"444444' '38'32

  63 >33 6':9 633'&'3"3 3F3 3  33' &3 ;63 3 ' 3@'>'8 2 &3   >>  &' '8   '3   ' 3 3    6&3   ':'  3&8 & '3 #=6F 3'&'32&3    ' 3@'>'8  F8 ;63&'3  '  332 #3 8'3"3%3&3 '@'8: 3  &3  '3   &3    '8 @ 3; 32  8# 3 3  388   3  &  &  '&&'''>'8 2

.2   )5 8 )001%  '8833'  '  '  '3   = A3(B C  D  '>38 6'  83    3' 833  3& '    F 8'3% 9;6 )/ 83 )001% B &'3   !2 "444444% '9' '' @ '  '  33%  3 $ >33  6':9 6'8 3'@'=33& 3&3: 2

+2     83 @  '   ,0 &3 )001   J  83  =>>  3:833  3>%!2"444444'' 33'3 2

   ) &3 )001% 3 &3   '>>338   8 63 @ 6!2   '&3   '  ' $  3' 6 ' '8 3' ( 3F  683'8  ' 3> 3' @  =3 3' 33    >3 ( ''  >    6 '  33=' 3 '3 3=32 '3 36&3  >3 &33=>>3 ''  3 >'2>33 

*,-./*)001 (-*+(

8# ' ': 3  &3 '    $2   '3  33 6&3 3&3G(''&'3233'; 3  3'' 3'   :3 3   6 3   8' 3&   3 K  :3 ' 2

12  ,,&3)001%   83''3':& 3'2

/2   )0 &3 )001%  '8833  '3 6  ''  '%   ' =8  3' 33 32  33   '  ;%  ,5 &3 )001% 6!6 3  8 3B863!2"444444 &3  '''&'3"32 >3%'&'3@ 3 3'  3&3  & '>38',+')E83)0012

52   '   3B  '3 ; 68:  33 @  &3  3&+8)0013G(&: '383%'83B   3&>'8 !2"4444442

 ' 

,2   3 3'  6 3 ,0   '3 >   9'   6 :38    =  ,+ 93 ,5// A"  ( I ) ,0D%  3  '' 33'   3F9'B' 3>3 3'  933 3'   3' =8  6 3  3F 9' '   2  6B%33'3 3=3 )58)001L  ;  ',0&3)0012

  933 3'  36'>3F=3   '%' 3%3 3''=3;6 3,13E '3   ' 833  3&  ,)  8: ,5/. A  (  . ,0L *-E*)001.>&3)001D2

)2  "' 6 3 ,E: 3 ,    " % 3  33'  &'3 ' 6F3'  83B 3     ' 3>3% 6 '3  '8    % F >3 6  6F 3'% 8     3'  ' ' ';  33 '  >'  3 ;6    ' 3  >'8 % ' 88 3''8' 8 9;6'8B@';6>@ ': 8F3  3' '3 A *+1)*)00+,.8:)00+D2

   %  '  >3  6':9  6 33'  &'3  >'2    3& 6F 3'    33'  #'  3'  '8' 8   63 ;3> ' 33 ;33   '8  '3 3 33 >3 3 2

*,-./*)001 (.*+(

   '3 3' '  6 3 ,E : 3 ,    "  '  ' 83%33' 8'  ;'  ' 3@ '>'8 2

E2  "'6 3,E " %  3'833  3& =8  '3:';''9'3=8 "3 ' 863: 83> 68K#6F 3'6&'3' 6F3'L  K ' 88 ';M 8 63 3    '3:   3':8  F3=3: &    ;  8   '   3' #'''=3;  '3  &  8    3'%  ' % 6F 3' 6 3 '  '8= 3' 633'&'32

   %'   '863B;   '>38'F8'36'83  3'833  3&''@ ' '   &  6F 3' 6 &'3  >'2 63  9'3  '  3=8 "338'393 )00+8'3  8 '38 ';633  638'3:33  '863:3 M 2'3 3'>3F3'3 3' =8 3'' 333   3'833  3& 3 9 3>3@ =2

-2   3  @ F 8'3% '3  9;6 )/ 83 )001%       3'833  3&%   33'' 3'3 2  '& &'   6'   9@ & &         8   8   ' ;   '3  33 '8    3&'   3G( 8 3%33;66' 9@>3 83B>'32

.2   ''3 8>'%'9 2

   '      :>3  63  933;%  8'8  83@#=23'6383 %&633 3=2

NNNNN

(& '       

+ ,!-$.

&:'3 9 ,0&3)001!'3"444444'  33'   '8833'  '  '  '3   =  )5 8 )001L

*,-./*)001 (+*+(

,!".

9 L

3 ;?3? J?8'8 L

3  ;% '>'88  F  3 ,,E   3&    '3 >   3: >  ,1 93 )00. A I(" ,1E2,,0D%    K    K  '      9' ;3 3&   ' 3>3 3' (&   3: >%   &'3  '' 3  3':333L88'3''3 33;'3'% 8' 3> 8'$& ' 3= ' ''8 3L3 '3  K    3: >% ,000  ,-%  &'3 '  '  &'3  '3; F '3 3'  ? 3 -)  I2    K     3B  '3'  ' % 3&'; '88 8'$  &% '3&  K  9'3  @ ?&'3L

'883; K @!" #$%&' ' %@'8833'  '''3 =%@6'>>33'3%@6'>>3 ' ' 3'%@6'>>3>83= 3'@ %'3>'8 3'%@ ! ( I8:'32

"3= C !2$#B%3 %!2 #3%!8'%9=2

'8 3:833  3>C

=>>3B(93 C  3 C     23'("3=3  I2$#B  

'3'>'8 K  '883;F 32

 B&%  =>>3BC     

*,-./*)001