Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/188/2006 • CJ GE ATA/188/2006 Généré par l'IA

Disability Benefits Denial Remanded for Insufficient Credibility Findings Regarding Subjective Pain Testimony

Numéro de cause ATA/188/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The petitioner challenged the denial of disability benefits, arguing that the administrative law judge (ALJ) failed to properly consider subjective pain testimony and other evidence supporting the claim, specifically pointing to a prior favorable finding on a related matter and medical evidence. The court concluded that the ALJ did not provide a specific and sufficient reason for rejecting the claimant's testimony regarding the severity of their limitations, particularly since the testimony was partially corroborated by medical records and prior administrative findings suggesting a similar level of impairment, thus requiring remand for further consideration of the evidence and proper explanation of the credibility determination.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Disability Benefits Denial Remanded for Insufficient Credibility Findings Regarding Subjective Pain Testimony: The court concluded that the ALJ did not provide a specific and sufficient reason for rejecting the claimant's testimony regarding the severity of their limitations, particularly since the testimony was partially corroborated by medical records and prior administrative findings suggesting a similar level of impairment, thus requiring remand for further consideration of the evidence and proper explanation of the credibility determination.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
prestations d'assurance-invalidité moyens de preuve médicaux droit subjectif procédure d'action en matière d'assurances sociales doute raisonnable audience d'instruction

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/870/2014
Disability Benefits Denial Upheld Despite Pain Claims Due to Insufficient Objective Medical Evidence
A/3014/2013
Disability Benefits Denial Remanded for Investigation of Unexamined Medical Issues
A/4589/2005
Disability Benefits Denial Remanded Due to ALJ Error in Weighing Medical Evidence and Subjective Complaints
A/358/2017
Disability Claim Remanded for Failure to Address Aggravation and Somatoform Pain Evidence
A/2905/2010
Disability Benefits Denial Remanded for Further Evaluation of Multiple Impairments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

  

    



 !"#$





%%%%%%%%%% 



& ' && (( && & ') ( 





     !"# 

& 

&(  )* ++++++++++, -  ++++++++++ &./.,  *000- 1*0 ++++++++++ 23(   00 4 5*0  0 50  !. 6*7&.8%(

!(   -  0 50 5  60  *70    6020 90 5:;  < = >, 0 ?  @:  60 0  &8 A-60!''$,04605*05 *0!#60!''$(

B(   !% *0 !''$, ? &'1'/, 40-- 00  60     )200:6?8&C*"1,*2-0--0,>4?  0,  60 -0 0*0- ? $' C*"1( 00,  -5*  --  !& C*"1(

/(   D-  B' E60 !''#,  <   0-  5*0  0  )*++++++++++ 5 @ *0,  5500  40 &#7   0 A--   00 0:  &! -*7 &.$% 9   < 8/&('&=( 40-  @5- >4 4-0 --  *00** -2  0  4--40--47705A0-*0     E05( )* ++++++++++ -0 5 0-, 5-0,?06-10-205-0F, ),*D*>6-105>5*004-05 -0(

$(    5-  &$ A-60 !''#, )* ++++++++++  00  07 *000A45005*?40* 50 ?   , 7000*, ?  -0 ?  *0(  4 5 -  A0 >0 0 -0 51-, *0  A0 60 >  5060  5*0026-50420060A*00(  AA,  *0  , *000- ? 23, 450 : 06*   *:  )(++++++++++, )* ++++++++++, >0 1700  ? ( 2-  .& ,  0 AA0   *0 4 G10*  4 -2--   -0 >0 460  50>* 62,   >4607040*-050606?  *00(  0 0 -0  55- 5  0A0*0: >0  30?16>0-0560-5*0( ,0 00*70457 *:,500>*0 4705,600*5-06*055*0(

  )*++++++++++E0?G,*-0  )* ++++++++++ 50 5  602 , A0*  0  

"$%&"!''# B"# 

(  AA   A*0 60 E> ? 5-   *00 ? *00   50,  >0 -0 507 6  0 *-0 5*,   60  )(   )* ++++++++++,   5- ?  -0 0057(  500   02- H>4 A0   200 0>0 4226, 577*  *0: -6:,4--)*++++++++++I(

#(  50--*505&#E60!''#(

 ( )* ++++++++++  50-   *   ,  00   A0 >  5060   5*0  *0   00 : 0AA00,64200>00( A0*->4 *0-0?45*:0>400?2 ?*005-60>4505:(<04-05, 4-0  *0 >0  0 1> E ?  5   060(  632060,-5*5570505 *5( 60AA0D05075A00G,>0 60600(

  < *0 -0 550-0 4 0-- 06   *0   -60    20 407(   0,    600056500, 1*72600700:,(

  <420   5*0: 0A0,    @5- >4 460 00500:;-0:-20- 5  00 5A0 5-0,  >   4 A0 5 -(

 7( < 50--00-5070@5-(6- >*2*J6,5-4--,-0>0*(

& ( 

&(  E-  *5 0 6  E000 *5-,    679($# 0K200E000!!6*7&./&    !'$L(#B(&0(0 5-*0006&! 5*7&.%$    $&'=(

!(  1 0 5  02@   *> ,  500,  02@A0@60*@0*9(!8(& L&#!!K 02000:$5*7&.8.M< <8/&(!&L F&'% #!=(

"$%&"!''# /"# 

B(   K0-0  0-,  60 *@0* 2--  6-10 5 0 $' C*"1, >  00   ,   00   600700-A67K0/0-&K :2000:&B6*7 &.#!9  <8/&(&&L F &!&&!8N &..$##/=(

  <  E05  07 A--  *0: K@:  60 ? K0-0K0-,-5*60*@0*0-$? !'C*"105260->0E0A00*560* K0&#0-B 9 F&!!B8N &..88BB,0(&5( 8B8=,  -6  0 500: 9 F &!B  &'# N   &..8  8!$,0(!75(8!% 8!.-A(0(=(

   -5*  !& ? !/ C*"1 0, > ? 0,  0A0 *3*260*50>:22--05*0 K0&#7 (

   61,  -5*  !$ C*"1  5 O  5005  070205*00,A*0A@5056E0A0 K@:60@AK*700,6260-*0 2 >K0 56>(   0 ,  E05 0: >  060020:K:2A* 9(&#(&((.'1(! L F&!B&'#N &..8 8!$,0(!,5(8B&-A(0(L F&!BB8,0(&,5(/' /&L<&..8 5($!8 $!%=(

  050055507>00000 A67    >  --   A0A 0 7  *60(  K20,  AA,   *0:, K  -0-  0   A60>507K-20-0*E0079 F&&.7 &$#L<&..B5($B$L F&&%&.'L&'%7#8L&'/7$&=(

   K5:,  -5*   60 0-,  *  -,  --  !& C*"1, 5: -0   *2  -0-( )D* 0 4@:  60  0 ? 4@D* 0*0 0A-0    260- *3, 0 420 -*0 4 0A0   -20, 00 5 40 &#7 0- &    , >0 0*50>  :2 2--  0  5*00,*00***0(

  A0,    *50 5  50,    @5-AP60>05*00-50 2610@60A05A*0++++++++++,06 *00?*00*:)(++++++++++( -*1,5D 5060,-0AA22*A05 -5@,>*-00A0*-(->,< 

"$%&"!''# $"# 

0Q0*5620,*00A0> 60    4@-0 2: > 4 & C*"1  O  50055-40*560*(

  *5>05-:, 07*000A0*0- 0K*0,A0@00*00**-2(

/(  5->*0(40002,-** RF/''( *0?12< 9(%8 =(

*  &(  &    

+,-#.

- 67   0E-  &$ A-60 !''# 5 )* ++++++++++ -0060*706020B'E60!''#0 05*05@*0L

-#$.

4*L

A0* 4D- >-   >40 5  0  5*0  0  )*++++++++++,

A0@-*?*0L

*?12< -** RF/''( L

0 >, A*-* @ 0 .8  06   0 A-- K200 E000,5-D5D5-,5600*000A,   E :  0A00, 5 6  07 A--L  *-*0  000>0,*0A*356502 *0L00D-0@*50*0 07 A--, &'''  &/L  5- D   50:  50  ,06>-*356,06DE0?K60L

0>  5- D ? )* ++++++++++ 00 >K 60  *706020?KAA0A--?(

<0-2; )*63,5-0,))(31: 1-0,E2(

"$%&"!''# #"# 

* 07*000A;

2AA0: E0E(;  60 5-0;     )( 0 (63   

50A*D--0>-@50(

 :6,  2AA0:;           

"$%&"!''#