Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/167/2005 • CJ GE ATA/167/2005 Généré par l'IA

Validity of Prior Sales Agreements Regarding Real Estate

Numéro de cause ATA/167/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case involved a dispute concerning the validity of several prior sales agreements affecting the subject property. The court determined that the agreements were void because they violated certain statutory requirements regarding the proper execution and notarization of such transactions. Specifically, the court reasoned that the documents failed to meet the necessary formal prerequisites mandated by law for conveying or encumbering real estate interests, rendering them unenforceable against the current interests in the property.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Validity of Prior Sales Agreements Regarding Real Estate: The court determined that the agreements were void because they violated certain statutory requirements regarding the proper execution and notarization of such transactions. Specifically, the court reasoned that the documents failed to meet the necessary formal prerequisites mandated by law for conveying or encumbering real estate interests, rendering them unenforceable against the current interests in the property.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
transactions immobilières fortune immobilière condition de validité nullité des ententes titre représentatif de marchandises droits et obligations précontractuels

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.
Généré par l'IA
C/13016/2003
Property Sales Agreement Amendment Validity Dispute
C/6572/2012
Real Estate Sales Contract Void Due to Missing Essential Conditions in Authentic Deed
A/30/2007
Property Sale Contract Validity Dispute
A/1833/2002
Contractual Validity and Property Transfer Dispute
A/3309/2005
Contract Validity and Statute of Frauds: Property Description Sufficiency

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This article is cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

      









      !   ! 



      !!! !  "!# $% 



&&&&&&&&&&''  !! "#$  %& &'("





     )*+,)

!   

0&  "!!1111111111%& &2") 34"55"!!6  5 "7   85""'  ""5"' 9$'  :   (" "(!";"3<"=3:&

*&  % 8"'"!!!!5!!8"9"!!7""" 3 !"8"0>>> !";&

?&    !" 8"  9"( @  *..0'  "!!  ("!  5!!8"  "( 5     AB 0*C.D0C,D-&)    "  "( 5 AB,CD,.C?D*&)&

  %5";E5:"F'"!" !"!;( 9:"   !!  :!  9(5! <!!  ""& 7)" ( "  "":(9":" ABG.9...C...&)&

  ( ?0!(5*..0 !""8   AB 0,/C0,,9/D?&)H  "8'  8 !< 9!:" = AB00-C/.,90.0&)  AB DGC?0.C>-.&)   :  "!!  < 8   ABG,CD,.C?D*&) ABG.C0->C>*-&)" 5!!8"97"&

/&  0>!(5*..*'9("""8"2") 34 B 6 "8"!="!!57" :"" AB*C,D?CG??'-.5! $"88!! "55&

-&  0-I:"*..?'8""""#$  %& &2") 34 8"""6'(! "!!'8" :"=9 B ( !8"""8  " "  ":" ""5!  AB /-C...C...&)'  ;" "( ";"' '<(" ""( 5= AB*?CD,.C?D0&)&

G&  00:"*..?'9 B "8"!="555"8""8 9 (  AB *C>-?C->.&?.&  5!!8" "( 5 !" ! "$<!  ;   " "( 5 :" !! ! = AB *,CG.-C.0D&)& J B   !! =   "  !"!<  (  AB /C,*/CG/-&)  "  E "  ""(!F ""( 5&!!88! (K   8( ""  ""! E!(""   "   ""(!   "!L  ("    :  ""F&  ((  ":" !:  AB G.C...C...&)  !! I!  (  :"!!< &

D&  G("*..?'"!!! !!("7"  9"(!""8"""& 8":";""5"9":"

+*-,,+*../ )?+,)

 :" L"("!=:9""';9!"= ;9 B :"("97"9 "  ""(!&

,&  !""0DI"*..?'9 B ("7"&: 8( ""  8!   ":"  AB /-C...C...&) 8"( :!!!("="55'(""9!""" (8" "  ""(!&

>&  >I"*..?'"!!"I!!""9 B   3   ((""     ("3 9"( @ 2") 34  ((""6 <(!I=!: !!("&

0.&  !"":(5*../'((""(" "!!8"(("8&

   "  "( 59"?."C"( ""  (*? (50>>/2M)?0-6!" " !:"!! 388"!97"@&  ":"  :"   = 9!<  "" ;9 ((  !$!& 8"'"9!5""5"?0!(5*..0' 3  ! ""  5!!8"'  ":" = K  AB /-C...C...&) !"     "!! :  ""&  "'     9(8"(""5'"8"!<(  3!"" 9(5! <!!  "! ;  "!! :" :"   5"  "8;"" (":":"&8""!;9"8 5"'  3 ! ""  5!!8"' ( "' = $  ":" = K'  ;" :"L8"!=0..N 8!<&% 5'  ((""  !! =  :   9('  :"=";9"9K:"  "  ""(!&

00&  *0!(5*../'9 B !""(("" ="=8"("  !""0DI" *..?&

  (("":"!!(""97"9 "   ""(!  "! ;  ""5"  ":" :"  8" !"(   8( 9 :(   3& " :"  !;;"8""5"""8':""" 3<":=) """&9((":"L"<! 0-N' ="8";"=(K(5"'=  ";""! "((!"  5" =  ( (""5  AB0--C-,?C/-G&)'= """(! AB/C,*/CG/-&)""= "   <5 AB*,CG.-C.0D&)((!""0D I"*..?&

+*-,,+*../ )/+,)

0*&   ?0 I:" *..-'  8"""  !      =  I&

  %("(((""'(""!! ":" 7 (L( "' " 95   "   ""(!&  ("";":"=""5 :"L;"8"!8!<  ?0 !(5 *..0 ("' = " 5"""'  ("     ((""  9( 8"( (""5  "   ""5"   3  ":" "  97" *..0&   5"""(' "  ":" !" ;"8"!   : 9""' 95) """ :"L!(!  "(  ::!"849(("! AB0G/C.,?C/-D&)  !8!< AB0G.C/.,C0.0&)2" AB00-C/.,C0.0&) 8!<( "  AB/-C...C...&)":"6'" 9K:""" """(!?0!(5*..0&

!  

0&  I!  (  " :  I""" ( !'    :5 2& -G  & ?   "  C<"" I"""   :(5 0>/0)) *.-H&-?"!0" !8"/5 *..0)B"O?0D6&

*& &   "   "( 5  "!!   "7   "!!  !": (    ")"    ") "" "    " ""5!!'!::!:"!(K 5!!8""( !2&*,M6&

 5& 9" ?. M' ""!  "   ""(!'  :"<  " 0I:" 0>>G' !:" ;   "   "( 5  "!!   "7   "!!  !":  <(!      8 !<;"!(";("("5 "  &

  "!! ! !<"<:"'"=("8""  D 5 0>>/   " 8!!  9"( @ 8!! "  0/ !(5 0>>. 2% G/*&00) B) & D-' I9$" 5<!6    " 8!! 9$(""((0/!(50>>.2%G/*&0/O A ) & *> & ?6&  " "" "  (  !(""   "  ""(!' !") """& ":"!! 8<!!"(  ";"!7"I"   "58!!'("!""("!79!:"8"&!("'  I"   "5 8!!  !"( <   "$(";""!=9!:"&

+*-,,+*../ )-+,)

  %  8 ;" :" "(  ""(  !      ;"   $ : "   "   ""(!&  "3 (  !8"" " 9   ! 98"(!<$";":""""!  " 7 !  8 7 (L( "; ;  !")"" 2M  0>>-+ &/0,-6& ("'"9<" (:!"8""   "!!   =   "! 9(  2 B 0.* 5 0-0 "& - &0-06&(P8"<5" !"78 !<(""5'"8(97" "  ""(!&

 5& %59"?.M'9 B !"!"":28(" G+>D>50>>DO") 34"":9 B 6;" 7 !5! 9("""8!!"5"2""G GI"0>>D6& 9 B   !<(!5"8("2"" 6    5   8"<   "":  : = !("   "  ""(!&

  "":'9 B 8"7 $; "87"";  "(" (7"( (""5  8 !<& ""' (('  E";""!F : L 8"! "!<(   8 !< 20..N6HE! ":" "F(L(;E !F=,-N&

?&  9 3'"!!( """(!""<"74 ;"8""  ' 9<"  ":" = : 7 ""H  7  "5=9"8:=:"":"H "( "8= :( 5:!&

/&   :" 97("  95  ;"8""  ":"  9((""5&

  9(5!<!!9"!!K(!(""5(9( " 5!!8"!5"!:"!:9""5" 2&)M&  '   8""!  9 "'  0>>/' & *G/6&  """= 5!!8"!5"'   ; 3<!<""!! !2&GG.&0 6&!;' ":";8"7! 9(5!<!!"L"!!((   "!! = 9!<   ""    8"      !(""  97" 9  " ""(!' (( 9  = I "  9 B  ;  ((""&  8 : ;  ;"8""  !<( !;5!!8"; "!!!"9"(  8   "( 5&  9 3   "5 97 (  ":"   ! ""  "8  8   "( 5  8 !<'(($""8""55&

+*-,,+*../ )G+,)

   !;'  (  AB/-C...9...&)    ":""L "( "!:"" 9!5"(  9( 8"( (""5   "!!' (( 98"=I"9 B ((""!""&

-&   " ":< !<(   "  :" 9" 8 "! ; 9"8  5"'  3 ! ""  5!!8"' (  ) = $  ":"= KO ;" :L 8"!=0.. N 8 !<'((98"(("";"8" ""8&

  5"(("!(""8"&%I"  '( !5"8(!(73<"(("" "!8"'=(";"8" !:"3<"  !"8";2 L "58!!*&0,/+*..?*0I"*../'"&*&*  ""H Q&  %' " 8" "' *3( !&' R *..*' & 0,06&  9 3   "5  ;"8"   9"8  "! O "(=;"8"<5");"!!":"5" ";""!"((!"" (:":" 3'; AB//C-,0C?0*&) AB/-C...C...&)":":;   "8 ";" = (K (     ";""! "((!"&  ;"8"" S!<(((8!'9 '":"  L:! 32&)M& ' &"&' &*G/6'9 ' "9K ""!: 99"8":"= ""5&  "' " 97"     I"8"" (  9!  7 8"7!   "":  9 B '  "5 7 "8 "  ( 9((""5&

   !   ;" !3 ;  ;"8"" 9 "   E! ":" "F  E!!" "( ":"F :L8"!=0..N 8!<;8" (("" L8"(!&!""(("":3 L! "&

G&   9<" 8"(  !(" ; :  T " L "  (      9( (""5& %  "   I" '  !(""  8 ;"  L !(";( "("5= "  "8"= "::!"8 =8" !"8"= ":( 5' "; !: !8  2 B0.*50-0"&G &0G* H0.?-?D"&? &-?>HU&V% &'!""8" "'  *..*' & *D-H Q& %'  & "&' & *0/H & A A' &U  '%$''*..0' &/>?H&)M& ' & "&' & 0-DH & W'  :T "<T " "( $#"X"$ %$'  0>,/6&  "  (    : :!  "8  9""7 !( !:"":9 B &

+*-,,+*../ )D+,)

   3<  "5  5"  "!! K( 7"<  8" 8"<  5"  : (""(  T = !("   "7 9;"""'Y:"E "7<!!( ";!($!= 5"F'":":!($2&GGG 6& ' 5(??'??N'I"8""'("8"(   2&M '""% '?3(!&'*../' &*GD6& ""' :( 5T "5"88!::! "38"< 5"" !"7:&

   9 3'  "55  8" 8"<   !"  9"( @ *..0'   5"; Z GD&*. E"""  9"("  T  ($"F'( AB*.C,,>C/?/&) E:( 5F T   (  AB?.C,,.C/?/&) =  5"; Z GD&0. E "7 9;""":":($'""8!"F' ! "" =  5(  ?*'?,N   : ;9 88"( L  : :!& ' " 9 B  "  (("" 9 "  (   :  !"  T     9( (""5&  '  !"" ( S("8;"(!9 B   ((""=! :'"(="": "5& !;'!""9 B  L8"(!&

   "  :K! = 9 B  8" ;9 !(" 9!:  "  ""(!( ::!T&

D&     "( ("   " :K! = 9 B   :7";" !3&

    ;"!   '  !((   [   "("!  !  "  !& 9""(! 9  " =  "("! !'89K:"2&,D 6&

 \\\\\









+*-,,+*../ ),+,)

$ ! ( !      

)*+,-.

! :5"I!*0!(5*../ 9("""8" !""((""("3C"( @ :(5*../H

+,/.

9( "(H

:""=9("""8" :!"" "!H

";C"C  [C!(('"!9"("!H

((";  ! L = 9(""" 8" ' =  (("" ("3C"( @="#$  %& &'(" 91111111111%& &

%"!<4 M&K$3' !"'M(:K'A"'M& $!"'M('I<&

( "5("""84

<88"3)I"4   !"4     &")%"<" B&K$3  

 "8(L!!((";!7 "&

 3:'  <88"34       

+*-,,+*../