Cable Provider Pole Access Dispute
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe appellant, a provider of cable television services, challenged a decision requiring it to allow competitors access to its utility poles for running rival lines, arguing that the imposed requirements for cost-sharing and indemnification were unreasonable conditions for access under a governing statute intended to promote competition. The court reasoned that the governing statute mandates that the provider must permit access to its poles for competitors, subject only to reasonable conditions, and that the imposed cost-sharing and indemnification terms were not reasonably related to the maintenance or safety of the utility poles themselves but were instead designed to shift general business risks to the provider, thus violating the statutory objective of facilitating fair access.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Cable Provider Pole Access Dispute: The court reasoned that the governing statute mandates that the provider must permit access to its poles for competitors, subject only to reasonable conditions, and that the imposed cost-sharing and indemnification terms were not reasonably related to the maintenance or safety of the utility poles themselves but were instead designed to shift general business risks to the provider, thus violating the statutory objective of facilitating fair access.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IACited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal proceedings.
Cited in the dispositive as the procedural basis for declaring the appeal inadmissible.
Texte complet
!"
# $$$$$$ %&' ()'* )'* )%(' &&
!"#
'
!* 61 ) 7/5 1 !'').12//711/ 5 81188 91 1 :1 6 4;+ <=*
>* <1 ?/4 64 )#@1!''! 84 !&8 !''>.
1D 71 . 21 966E 81 5 1 F *
$* 7 8/71 G 6 6 1/ /921 188 211 16 8 1 6 9 2 1 5 81188 H1 1 :1 6 4 ; + <=.
91 16 1 21 9 AJ6 A4G 75 9, 61 3// :1 6 4;HA 61 = 3 1 82 8 6 1 / *
(* ) @1 !''$. 1 11 / 6 1 1 1 91 621G )0 6 82 )0&' : $ '%= G 9A 61 1 J/ 61 @G9I1G1 1 9188 2 6 /1 /*
#* 188 2 / /5 8 1 / 82 !''%*
< 9 /6 1 1 6 1? 5 ./ 21 %@51 !''(6 +
91 / / K8 )!!90)#.#0 . 1 51 ,C)0'90##* @51 !''(*
8 1 71 5 8 6 1 5 77 ) @51 !''(* /81 IH1 / / 88 ,C$>9('&.)%. K 1 . G1 / 1 82 2 661 1 9 1 !> 1/ ) 61G9 51 / /5/ 9 1G1 1 9 1 *
/11 / 1 / / ?/ 1 2 /8 1 *
19811 1 9A 61 .G1 1 / 1 1 88 /8 1 *
"$%&!"!''( >"#
86 6 4 9 2G 7 K1 . ? A3 8 1 / 4 75 2 * 51 1 51 5 6 18 1G )''9''' . G1 1 6 8 1 9 2 1 8 )9%''* 6 (I5 1 . 1 @G9I G91 13 9M3 1 *
82 8 I9A 61 ,C$>9('&* 86 8 1 /1 1 69/6 3 51 1861G 1 G91 5 1 8 1 1 11 I 5 91 1 1 1 *951 6 !48 611 1 51 6 G91 51 N /6 21 3 5 J3 )00!*
@ 131 1 /7 21 :1 6 4; = 1 ,C !!'9'''* ?G 1 71 @ ,C >'9'''* 5 8 . G1 /61 )!'9''' 151 A/ 1 /* 6./ 5 I8 1 7 .151 N6J 16 1 *
/G . 1 11 1 81 . 6 /5 6 9 1 !$ . 82 8 8/ 6K 1 1 17711 *
8 / 1 6/ 1 I 1 A/ 1 3 5 6 1 1 711 9 2@ 1 7 8 11 . 9 213 I A/ 1 3 . 1 09''' . 6 /3 G + <9/ 1 6112 *< 5 1 11181 61G91 1 6 G )9%'' 6 8 1. G 1 5 1 6J 1 1 9 81 . G91 6 51 6 // 88 ,C !H!''* 6 8 1 5 1 I9G1 1 1 1 *
)'* /11 !% 5 1 !''(. ?6/1/ ? 6 1 )' 5 82 !''(
81 9 213 1 82 * @ / 8 81 . H 213 1 82 6 1 691 / / 1 1 17711 * 9/ 1 4 6/ 1 9 ?81 1 1 2 7 1*
6 1 K 1 + <. G1 6 / 1 G G ,C(09!$'* 6 6/ 1 ) 7/5 1 !'')>)81!''$. G 181 7 81 6 1/ 1 3 8 /6/ .9A 61 51 71 /@I / 81 6 1 *
/11 6 /1 / 1/ 1 2 7 1 82 8 ?13/ 6 1 1 1 6 /1 *
"$%&!"!''( $"#
)!* 1 86 1 6 ! 8 !''#. 6 1 86/ 6 1 1 *
* 11G/G 71 1 H 9 51 . 9 / 8118 A1 . 1 9/ 1 6 8 82 9A 61 . 8 1 1 6K 1 1 17711 * 1/ 1 5 1 31 2 7 1*
/ 1 9 9 /11 9 1511 / 1 1/ 1 J/ .1 6 1 G / 17 1 5 /I91 18/I G G ,C$>9'''* /8/*
6 1 7 1 6 / 5 9 88 I 82 81 181 1 9 6 1 7 *
6 1 5// 215 1 91 6 9 771 6 1 . G 1 I ,C!'#9'''* *
2* 6 / 9A 61 6 /1/ G 9A 61 951 6 1 A/ 1 3 O F . 1 6 G 6 1 51 1/IE 5 / *H1 18/951 66 19AJ6 A4G 21 188 211 19/ 1 6 41/ 71 C *
/ . 9A 61 / 1 2 3/ 6 / 17 9 6 G9 1 / I91 / /*
)>* )! 8 !''#. @3 //3/ 6 1/ 9 771 H 1511 / :1 6 4 ; = 917 8 91 51 /11 1 * )0 8 . H 71 5 1 G H 1 H H/ 1 6H 1 / /6 1 / 1 513 2 *
')
)* @ / 86 1 5 @ 11 1 86/ . 52 : *%( 1 9 31 1 @111 !! 5 82 )0$) !'%D *(>*)1 * 1 6 / 811 15 )! 6 82 )0&% %)'=*
H 213 1 82 H 21 I G 1 GH / /11 /8 1 *
>* H 1 !> . 1 6 1 5 / 1 H1 621G / / / H 1G1 1 H 1 . 82 2 * 318 H1 15
"$%&!"!''( %"#
6 116 8 2//7111 82 8 6 1 H1 / 61H 5 1 4G H1 / /6 16 6 1*H 1 1 1 6 1 6 1GI6 1 @ P 318 H1 1 71 G1 5 1 82 8 * 1 H/ 1 6 I1?6 4 5 71 *
$* +3 / H 33 8 GH1 51 6 1 )! 81 !''$. H 6 71 1 1 AJ6 A4G 75 HA 61 21 188 211 *
6 8 G11 / /5 /*
%* < H 1 !$ . 2//7111 G1 / 1 2 7 1 H 82 8 . 6 1 .G 8 P1 1 681 71 1 1 17711 *
.1 1 7 8 8 81 /1 @ 4 171 1 8 82 8 . G1 1 6 7 8 H /11 / 1 8 15/ * 8 / I1 1 H 771 H31 H 5 1 1 IHA 61 3// H31 H 5 1 1 1 *
6 H 1 !$ 1/ ) 6 2//711 H 81 6 1 H 213 1 82 ,C$>H'''* *
/ 1 H1 86 1 6 G
H 77 6 8 8 1 / 1 6 114 8
51 GH1 5 1 82 61 1O1 811 7 IH1 18/ 61GH1 H/ 1 6 // 88 33/ I 6 AJ6 A4G 21 188 211 6 8 6 8 I ?/ 1 *4 / 6 1
1 F 15 1 C 15 51 6J 6 18 1G )''H'''* 151 G 1HA 61 1 /1 6 1 11 * 71 . 1 H 81 814 /12/ / H161 / 82 H1 18/ 6 1 1 1 GH1 31 2 7 1*
6. 6 6 / GH1 5 1 1 1 17711 H1/ 1 1 82 HA 61 61GH16 1 .11GH1 H 81 H1 86 1 6 . 6 / 5 88 / 1 8 5 / I . G1 181 1
"$%&!"!''( ("#
6 1 G 1 1 8 / I 1 5 / 1 8 * / 6 / G 82 8 6 1 1 1 17711 *
#* H/ 1 . 8 81 6 GHE @ / .G G 1 /11 G 8 /I6 H *
&* 6 1 87 /. @ /* 1 13 .1 6 6 K H/8 8 : * &# D * )' 43 8 7 1. /8 8 1 81 / 6 / 811 15 >' @1 )0&( % )'*'>=*
QQQQQ
%(') '
+" ,- ./0
/11 /1 1 H811 1 9, 61 3// !% 5 1 !''(D
,-10
@ D
1 G919 66 K9/8 8 D
1 G . 7 8/8 ? 1 &! 15 1 7// 12 7// )# @1 !''% : C < )#>*))'=. 6 / E 6 E 6 / @ G1 15 171 1 6 5 12 7// . 6 5 1 8 14 1 621D 8/8 1 1 11G 1 . 8 17 8 J 6 5 6 13 8 1 D1 1 E / 12 7// . )''' )$. 6 5 1 6 6 5 1 / 1G ? 1 1 9 1 $! C* 6 / E 614 6 1 . 15 G/ 88 8 J 6 5 . 15 E @ 1 I 9 5 1D
H811 1 9, 61 3// *
<1/3 ; +* JA4 . 6 /1 . +8 5J , 1. +* A/1. @3 . +* .@3 66/ *
"$%&!"!''( #"#
8 12811 17;
3 7714 @ 1 ; 6 /1 ; * 1 <1 3 1 C*JA4
61 7 8 E / / 881G/ ?6 1 *
45 . 3 7714 ;
"$%&!"!''(