Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/161/2005 • CJ GE ATA/161/2005 Généré par l'IA

Evidence Admissibility and Sufficiency in Criminal Appeal

Numéro de cause ATA/161/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The appellant, convicted of various offenses, challenged the trial court's rulings concerning the admissibility of evidence, particularly regarding communications made after the alleged commission of the crimes, and argued that the evidence was insufficient to support the conviction. The appellate court reasoned that the challenged communications were properly admitted as they were not entirely irrelevant, and while the evidentiary rulings were subject to review, the cumulative impact of any perceived error did not rise to the level of affecting substantial rights, particularly because the evidence presented, when viewed in its entirety, was sufficient for a rational trier of fact to find the essential elements of the charged offenses beyond a reasonable doubt.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Evidence Admissibility and Sufficiency in Criminal Appeal: The appellate court reasoned that the challenged communications were properly admitted as they were not entirely irrelevant, and while the evidentiary rulings were subject to review, the cumulative impact of any perceived error did not rise to the level of affecting substantial rights, particularly because the evidence presented, when viewed in its entirety, was sufficient for a rational trier of fact to find the essential elements of the charged offenses beyond a reasonable doubt.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
suffisance des preuves séquestre de moyens de preuve recours contre décision de renvoi concours réel examen des griefs formels plainte pénale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
A/109/2006
Sufficiency of Evidence in Criminal Conviction Appeal
A/301/2007
Appeal of Conviction Regarding Evidence Admissibility and Sentencing Departure
A/3224/2005
Criminal Conviction Affirmation on Evidentiary and Instructional Grounds
A/1308/2007
Appeal Regarding Sufficiency of Evidence in Controlled Substance Possession Conviction
A/1302/2005
Appeal of Conviction and Sentence Affirmation

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The court ordered the appellant to pay the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

         

 

   

 







 !"#$ %"&   !"# $#% 

% 

&' ' & ( ' &    & ) 





     &'()*&

 

)-  !%.%/.0!% %1!%. 0 $  2. .  3  4- - 5.&6 .  3 7$  %8 . 9$   .&&. % 1 6#$  / . 8%.      :   % .0%;-

'-   <  0= ''$ !%. !% >>.. ?  .  6  !-!% ?%.%00% %#..%  -

,-  !- !%  .  %  ),  0= '' /?. #.  @.  %   %A2 2.2 A8..%#..-

B-   )B C#. ',$     ?.00= . D$ /.  # % 5.& 6E 7$?. 0..2.$?2.00%=..63 . 4- -5.&6E3 .7/.#.%  .%%%00 .% 5.&6E 4 7 /?.    0F 6  !- !%  % 0.8%%#%  -

9-   4   0.  .   #.  %   %  .%  ?. 5.&6E4  7/.@@  % ),@#.',-

G-  H %.%$4  %  /E

  )7% .?.#..@.. ?. 0..?F0..   %.    1F D0&%I

  '7F0.? . .  +0@J?.00=.D$/.  #& %-

+-   ') 0 ',$  4    0.  %. 1 ?%@@.  %  ?. .%     .%  #. 5.&6E   7-  4   22.  ?%.   % .  ?. #..   . .% %% 1  @J  ?.00=.D$/. #& %$#%.?#.2?# .%?.#.. . 0 & %. 1?.?F0.-

D-  . ?  %  ),0.',- 8 0%  =.'*0.',$.#. /E

  )7      .  .0    :2  =;  % ?.00=I

  '7   F%  ?. .% 0% .     .%    =.  /. A  . . . @@. I

()'+*(', &,()*&

  ,7?.#.... . C  %. =$1#.%+0 @J?.00=.D$/. #& %I

  B7C  . ..2#=I

  97  @J   %F %  /  2. %#.  K  % %0%  %.  %#. 1#.%'*0F0.  -

<-  ?  @@ %# % 'G0.',-

  4 %.   $@% %2.%#.& . %      -  % $   .  @0 0.   F0.  ? =.0 @@. @J?.00=.$D/. #& %-

)*-   )< C. ',$ ?      ..%-?.  .% ?# .% ?.#..  #. K .0 .#0 ..-

  ?. #.. #.  K  C  .  %.   ?.00= . +$   .&&. %- !- !%  #.  %  0   %. .% ?021?  ?..,)%L ',%/ #8%. F# ?..,)0=',-

))-   #. F./  .  3  ?      )+ C.  ',%02.?8 %.  F.=3. >4- 5.&6E F.=3. >7-?  ? %#.1>&#%-

)'-     %   ') C.  ',$ !- !%   % 6  .= 0..  .@-

  ..%/? . %@%01? .G?%%  %  .%  ?.  )G 0= )<D9 5. M 4 D)B-,)D-)B'-)7- ?  $  % .% ?%  .  0.00  =C .#  $ ?   $  .  ?0. /?%-#. %. %.%  ?8  F.=3. >/.? . .%.=0%0 N  %- @.$ .  . .%0=.   ?..  .  .%I . ? .  / % .  -   OF#. %2./0 %=.2 .%1F2 %=.-

),-   )) %L  ',$ .  3   .@%0  %  / F.= 3 . >  %.   0.% ?.  .% . .2.- @.  .0 % ?   %  ..$ . ?8. .    % .% =$ F%0.  0.  P#  #8 0    F0   %.    %.  ?=O .0 C -

)B-  %) 0=',$?  %@.0  ..%-

()'+*(', &B()*&

   A 60 ?# .%  ?.  .  % %@%0 1  2. .%  #.2   #.  K  ..-   /.  ?  %=C .@  .$   . ...%/%#. K /% - % $ 0. . %%0./0 % =-

)9-  % ./,% %=',-

  ?.  .%  # . .%   ..  .  %@%0  %. -   .   ?.00.8 .% 8.#-  ? .  /  % .  %8  /.8%. .   -%#. K  . ...% /- &.%. /%=.- @.$?  %. .  @%  / #.  ?#  %. $ .  .   ?.0%.=..  ?8 ..%?  -

)G-  ?  %@.0..%G%#0=',-

  %?2.# . .%@J?.00=#%.. .   0%A  .. %00 -  @.0   #8  .   ?6 %%0./0  % =-  %L   .   .0 1 #.% QR '*S-& -  @.  1 F=%  .@ /.  .  C/?%  .. %#.  K  2O 1   % .% .0$  /. 2.   %%0.  ?%  QR'S-&- % $?.# .0 %#. K 0% ..%  .8 -  /.  ?  %=C .@  .$  %   .    . ...%/-%  .%%. @%#%.. . .   % .  .% ? #.  %   OF .%0=.   % $   ./!- #. ?A&.-

)+-  )+0'B$ % .%  . %%. 8  ?  -

  4%  % $  @&   %.  . . . %8. .2.8-0..?A #. . - ?%.  . 8%1 =.- #%... % =.0  . 8/.#.  .%.- . /%0 %  %.  F. .%- @.%. 1..%/$.#.  %= . % 0  ?%  %. .  ?.00=  / . 8%. . %  0.20 .%. .@%/  %. #. K % . -$%. .?.00=.+$  .&&. % . #.  .0  .   /?.  .  %% 1  / ?% .   2.  # . .%  %2  % .00=-   1 !->>.. /. ? .  .   %$ .  .   .-  #. ?FA2.6  .  #     #.   .0 / %   .   %- @.$ . ? .   %.= ?%.   0.6 .@@   F0.  / .%- &.  .  %% ? %   %F 2O 1 /  @0   % . #=-

()'+*(', &9()*&

       ?    @@.0 /?. ?A #.     %# . .%. .%3 .)BC#.',-%#..  .8',0.',$.#. %   )'FB9 ),F)9  ?% 0/  2.   %.   =O .0 - ?   . . ..% ./.%%. ..0%.1?  ..% /. #.       .  .% 0== #  %L  %% -

    % $% ? %%@..  ..  %   8 = .. / // %00   %-  %    %     %.   ? =.0 -  6 @.=%..% %0.@ -

  .8. )G#.'B @.8% -  0.& .$ . #.  . ?.  .  .   % % % ?. F%...  ? %#%. .?.00=#%..@./  #8%. 8 -

)D-  %.)+0.'B$% %.. .0 . %%.%=# .%-

    .     %  $ 1 . .$ #  %. .  .00=.89 +.&&. %-? . 8/ %  % =% .  1  % .%-  C2 2  %%2  .,)C. 'B-

)<-  R.  .  1  /K   C2 2$  3 .  %@.0  '9 0.'B/?#.  .0F6?  10 ?0=2%..  !..%R%  0A .$%%. .?.00=-

'*-  ,*C. 'B$% %@.0/%. .?.00= .  +     .&&. % ?%%.  1 %  .  .%  % .00=-

')-  ?  ? 'G%L 'B.8- % .% .  #.2=$ 1 #%.  % ? 2.  # . .%  ?.00= . D$ /. #& %-. %  #%. . .00= @.?%= .%-

''-  ?.  .% ' 0='B-

',-   )D %#0= 'B$ ?    %..   .   %-  0. . %.%-

()'+*(', &G()*&

   % .% ?#.    K  %# #  %. .  ?.00= . D$ /.  #& %- 0%.$  .  .% ? .  0    .0 $ %@%00  1 ? . G<)  % .#. .  )* 0= )<*+ 5  M 4 ')*7$  %. .  @% #%..  .     .  ?  #8$1F2% ?@@  0F.#./ -

'B-   21C2)<%#0='B-

& 

)-   C   0  . #   C.. .% %0  $  %   #=5 -9G %.S%2. .%C...''%#0=)<B)& & '*9I -G,-). -%. %0..  .#)'  0=)<D9& & 9)*7-

'-  %.@%  .%S#.%0 +% %=)<D,5  &4D)B-*)7%= $  $% 2F%00$.08    . ..=%.%00% 5 -) 7-

   % .%  0%F./$  =.  5T7 %  .0.    0 .1%5.0.  .%0..%I -))-) 7-

  00   . 8.  $ . .0% $ 1 .  # .@$  .0.   0..%   0 / 0   S     F./    %. .%S8%.  .% %  /%. %%0./0 % = 5 -))-' 7-

,-  S%%   %  .%  S. 5. & 4 D)B-,)D-)B'-)7 #%.  /0..%%  .%06 0  .6/%.= %$ # % /S. S.00.8 .%8.# 5 -G-)7-

  C S@@ 2 & %. $F0.% %. S# .%5 -G-'7-

B- - S%@@. @  S#.%0 $  @%K     A2  0.  )9 0=)<D<U%00 .%F 0..0F0. %. U 5.&6E  %00 .%7$  . 1  0.  F   F0. . % #  0..% &  %. $    S .G.'.-

  4%  . .#$ S%.@.   F0. %.    )$9 0  0%.@S %.  5F.@@,'7-.8$%.  S.#.. 60%% $S%.@.F0. K @.81)00%.

()'+*(', &+()*&

&F #.00=#%..$A%)9 0 5F.@@ 9,   9B7- 4%  F.@@ +$ %/  .  .% S8.2$ S %.  .F .0%  %F0.$80%/S%  %#=O .0 @%0%08%>% %  .%.$#=O .0 F .2% -

 =-  %00 .%       2%.  %% 0..  .#%%.   .#0%V%0 C../ .   %@.   S %.  S. .%   . .=  S. .%-   ./ S  #%  0 .6 S%% .   .#$% 00  20 $ / %.$  @. %   0 .6 F./ % 8.2   %.  ..65-!$%. 0..  .@$$)<<)$#%--'GG 'G+7-

  0.  S %.  F2  S. .% %6 $ S%% 0..  .# 0%2 .%E8.. .2%. $  0  S.@.     .%.   ./$    @.  . S2.   . 0     #..=..  0..  .#    @..   % N C.. .%$./S% C2S. 0 .%#.@./ S0..  .%2. %. 6 .%$%F  % .$ % %%. ./#.#%  5-!$%-. --'GD7-

9-      ..$  %   % 0  @.  ?%=C  ? .  !->>..0.20 ?0= /.?  %%%%0=2%..-?  . ..%/6. % %/.%   /0 .%@% 0 %% %#.   %   @@.  ?.00= . D$ /.  #& %-  F0.  / ?F. @0? . . /?1D0% 0 1+0 @J?.00=. $F . 2-% .%%. ?    %%2  %.  ?# .%   %.   ?.00=   %F$%. ..+$.&&. %$ %0 % 0. 20  %@%0 1  2. .%  #.2- ?8  0   .  3 .#10K0%.%./%.$.?8. % .% =F%0.F%.  %. ?=O .0 C -  .0?61 QR'*S-& $%L  #8 %%0./0  % =   ?    %     % -    K  0% .   .%.8- % $2O1%#.  .%$@. 1F=%  .@  %   ?  ..   /. %.%  %%0. . .% QR'S-&-

   %/ $ ?    .  @% 1 8.2  F0    F0.-

()'+*(', &D()*&

G-  % .#%/@. /?..  . ...% / /&.. LK 1%=.-

 - H ? .' $./. 1?%.2.?0.   %.% @.-

 =- 0.62$ =  K %. ./.%.% %002%2.&0K0%%0% 0 S .#    %=..  5 =   %0% 0 7$ %.  . /. 8  S%=C  /.  %#%/   .  .%  %#%.  @.  %  %.  5 =   .  .%I (+)<('  ') %#0= '7-     .. $02 %.@./@.%.#  K  %    #. =    ? .  5RR )<+< $ - ++97$ %.  . /.  1?%.2.-

 - ?%$.@. % /%  1% .00.8 .% . .2.- &.      .. /?. @@  /% ..0   %  =.0 -   $  ..% /    1 C  . % -

+-   %  .  @.  ?.0%.=..  ?8   ..%  ?  $?8 .%%. ?# .%?.#..# K % .  @%#%../.?%. -

 - 4%  .. 28  %. $ . S .   1 S0..  .% S.00.%@. %. .#5 (G9,('B'B%L 'B7-  2. .% @  0 .6  %  .%  ?#.%0   %  =  S  %  .%  ?F%00    % 0..   5RR )<+< $ - ++,7-  #F$  S  % %=C   #.     %.  $ %00#. 80-

 =- ?8 .%  %.  ?# .%  K    @ 1  . ./  %.   #  %.  =.-  #  . .2 /. %.  W     %     %. .  @%  / %.  ?#  %# %  .%% %0  .=0..  .@-

D-  #/.6$% .0 0.-0%0   QR)S-&0.1F2% 5 -D+ 7-  XXXXX   

()'+*(', &<()*&

' & *     

+,- #.

 #=  % . C   ') C.  ',  !%. %/.0 !%  % ..%?%@@. %S. .%  .% #.)< C.',I

- !.

?0  .0 I

%% 1 !%. %/.0 !%   /. ? %. .% ?02 1 ?%@@.  %S. .%  .% #. ?F# #8. .80%.1%0 ? @% K I

0 1F2% 0%0  QR)S-&I

.  /$ %@%00  8  . <+   .#    %. @ S%2. .% C...$ K  K % $#%.%%. 0..  .@$   C%6% .@. .%$#  .=@I00%.% %.  ../  %.%$ 0% .@   0%A  #   %   .2   %  %  % 0 .I . %.  K    %. 80.  0%.  .= @$ )  )BI    K     .6  %.%  % $.#%/%000%A#$%.# K C%. 1S#%.I

%00./    K  1 ! "#  $ #%   %  .. /S1 S%@@. %S. .%  .% #.-

4.2 E !-AF6$. $!0%#A$Q.$!- F.$!0%$C2-

%0 .=0..  .@E

2@@.6&C. E  . E     -.%&4.2.  R-AF6  



()'+*(', &)*()*&

%.%@%0 K  %00./8 .-

6#$  2@@.6E   

()'+*(',