Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/16/2008 • CJ GE ATA/16/2008 Généré par l'IA

Marital Property Division Due Process Challenge

Numéro de cause ATA/16/2008
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

A party challenged the trial court's application of a statute concerning the division of marital property, asserting that the statute was unconstitutional as applied to their case because the resulting division of assets was disproportionate and inequitable, effectively constituting a taking of property without just compensation. The court reasoned that the statute, while facially constitutional, was applied erroneously by the lower court; the lower court failed to account for specific statutory factors designed to ensure an equitable distribution, leading to an outcome that was so one-sided as to violate due process by failing to align with the principles of fairness inherent in the statute's intent, thus requiring reversal and remand for reconsideration under the correct statutory application.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Marital Property Division Due Process Challenge: The court reasoned that the statute, while facially constitutional, was applied erroneously by the lower court; the lower court failed to account for specific statutory factors designed to ensure an equitable distribution, leading to an outcome that was so one-sided as to violate due process by failing to align with the principles of fairness inherent in the statute's intent, thus requiring reversal and remand for reconsideration under the correct statutory application.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
partage de la propriété déficit de l'union conjugale indemnité équitable exception d'inconstitutionnalité cas de rigueur conjugal abus de droit

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision was applied in the dispositive to allocate court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/2157/2004
Marital Property Division Presumption Challenge
A/3165/2005
Property Distribution Statute Due Process Violation
A/4211/2005
Statutory Interpretation of Marital Property Division
A/2452/2007
Asset Division Appeal: Separate vs. Marital Property Determination
A/1347/2007
Property Division: Separate vs. Marital Asset Determination

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was applied in the dispositive to allocate court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

         

  

   

 !" 







#$%% 



## #&# 





     !"# 

# 

$&  '(()& &*' +,-./+'0(1 23 4'225'(56  78$9$!%:,6&4(5'2'+ 22 4   / +'; 49 6 +  2<'9 =/  0>  4'225  4  '(  7  56  7&+7++'((+/+&

!&  +, 6' +(    +72   2<'  6  /',2 +'     4(5'2  ''9   ''(+2''+,6'76'2'+5' ',6*' +,-'.$80(6'!%%#&

?&  '0(('6+2''''(+(''!%6' !%%#9+,6'(22''229' *' +,- @).9<4+(2'456'&+(64(' + 0'/(   2  4'2259 2'   2<'&  '2+('0  ('( 4(' + 7'    6 2+(/   +' '6'&  +7 + +'( 4(' + '5    '(   0>   A( B(& 4''  <' 6' C (+(6?%='!%%#&

D&   '52'''0+2'E+!:2' !%%#&  ,72 2''+    4(5'2 +5'9  $ =6' !%%F *  !$ ?$!  ' +,- ,72. 4''' +   ''&  25/ (5'2 '+'     2<' 6 ',2  '   +7 +'(&  '(( 6' (( 2( + 2(' 4''  +  + 4 (22, 7''222('<'&

:&  '4++(!8='!%%#&

  )4'G'(!,72925''922 59256'9+5='2'(+6' (+'2'(B(&''7'96 +7+'('9+'+/'7&)''2'< <''02(/+'(+(++7+'('9  /'7'  6B < 4/   '  '5   69 0'4(6''2+'+'6''&

   ' ''' H(2'<2  +    +7' B'I42<'0'/(',& ''6'

"!$%!"!%%# ?"# 

C '6( / 0>9   +6'  (6( 7   4'2+('&

  6'6B'+'+++' '(A(B(&

F&  ?+25!%%#9 '52'''0+((E+ +&+('(<('(=E'(!%%:9<4 6'+'4(5'2& 6(E+(+',(2< 4'2''/''''' 7&  +9+'2+(+''&

#&  2'59'4(2'(?%5!%%# 2+'+++&4''2( ''<(<4'(2''''(''  796'+2+(& /+( ',690'6'+''6-

 & 4BA 259 '( +  B6 :9 '+' 00'62 4  '2'' E   &  6' 0' (( +(  ''&  ' '''    ' +552    (+&

 5&  5  E 4'7 1 7   39 '  <'  7!#9'+'4+(+(+6'A(B(& '(''6E+'+'+,(5'2+<4' 6++7+'('6''&

 &  ''  (5'2 14 2+B,39  J(57 G9 1 5'39  B5'I D  1 '39  ' #9 (' '2'' E 0(173'('''6+< '(+H(0>E+6'+7+'(&

 &     0(  1  39 '   '   'F9E+='B'I('0'/(2+ 0>   E  2<'&   6' +'2  5 +'(9 2' 4(5'2  6' E   +' K  + +6' 2+5'(''&

G&  $:625!%%#9''<(<46'2(E/+ 6('0'''(2<'&(''<2''(22+ '  ' 2'<2 02(   4'2+('&  0' <  +7++'('64''7CE'&

"!$%!"!%%# D"# 

# ' 

$&  =(  2+ ' 6  =''' 2+(9    65*&:F '47''='''!!625$8D$    !%:;&F?&$&'+(2'''6$! +25$8G:    :$%.&

!& & )4'$?'2'+5'!D='$8F$*   $ %:.9 4(5'2  '  4'' +2   2'+5'5(E+2''&)4'$'($5  ,72  4'''  2' +5'  !$ (25 $8GG *   $ $%&%:.9 4'( 22  2+( + ('6  +2''+6'+5'<22&

 5& 4' # '( $  ,72 '+ <   +6 C '(2'+5'22',6E''<4' 5'  + 00' + +2   2+  +7 0'  +'(& 4' G '( $   / +('  < 4'( ('2' 42+'2H'+'& 25'' 9 22  +  5= '2'(9 '  +    (+'2'''(*&G&!,72.&

  4+,9''7'6+7+5''( '(  7   0>   =/  B(&   ''9 +C'('+''+('(&

?& & +'46''+''+4(7'('29 ,<'2''E'(('(&

 5& )  ='+9  =''5  '  +''+  +( 6''2 4 '(7'(  '2    4' G   '' 0(( 0((''$G6'$888* & )$%$.<' 2++'<(E92C2<49' >0++''4'+((++'<(* L$!?!DG '&?+&!:? !:DC'(; "$8D"!%%D82!%%D; &  9 & @  9 @& M  9 ' '' '9 6& !9  !%%%9+&:%! :%?&$%!: $%!#; &  94(7'(4'(7'(9N&$8#G9 ++&!G$ ?%!.&

  +9  +(++   +  4'(   (''  <(6(4++'<29E46'9'+''(7 <'    0' ++'< +  6' <' '  5( * &  9&@  9@&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!#.&

  6B9'4'(+'E2''+'<'(7  4' H   (' '  + <4 6 +'   '9 

"!$%!"!%%# :"# 

'H+2<06('(72E''' E' 2C2906+0'<4'(2'0'+'<'(7 * L$!?!DG'&?+&!:? !:D;$%:$GF'&D+&$8$ $8!;$%D5 ?FD'&:+&?#! ?#?;$%?!D!'&?+&!DD !D:;885?##'&:+& ?G?; 88 5 !G? '& ? +& !8% !8$; &  9 & @  9 @&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!:.&

  0 '<4'4/'+'(C+5'+(+(+ (7'(<''E+(0(E '('24(7'(  '2 * L 88 5 ?## '& : +& ?G?.9 ' 4' <4 '(C +'6(  ' +(+(  4H ++ * L $%G  !$! '& D +& !$?; &  9&@  9@&M  9+&'&9+&:%?&$%!F.&

  0'9 ' 4'(7'( 4 +'<  ( E 4' 4    0 4 '2 '(79  '5 42   < 4' + C / < 42''' B7  +''< * L $$! 5 ?G$'&F+&?G#.& +(29'4'(9<  ' 02  =72 <4'   < E 4'+('    ,7* L$$:G$'&!+&G! G?.&

 &  4+,9  '  (2(9   ('  ?% 5 !%%#9 <4++'<+'<'6'H(2'<2<4 +7++'(4+'(',2'5&'9 7'0((922'< 7' '(''''& 00922'+ ++(72'9<''C++'5''' ,6&

D&  <'+(,<4''''(+C'(& '9'4+('4/2''E+=' B'I+'C'(+'6('(+5'<&

:&  6<'+(,9=(&(22+(9  ML$4%%%& 92'EB79<'25*&G# .&

 OOOOO

"!$%!"!%%# F"# 

( $#'  #   

)*+,"-!.

(65'=(!:2'!%%#+)& &('' ',6!%6'!%%#;

+,.

=;

2EB7(22 ML$4%%%& ;

' <9 02(2 / ' G!  '6   ' 0((   '5 0((  $# =' !%%: * L ) $#?&$$%.9  +( C + C +(    = <' '6  '0'' + 6  '5 0((9 +  6'  2','+5';2(2''''<'9 2'02H+6+'72';' ' C (  '5 0((9 $%%%  $D9 + 6' +  + 6' ('< / ''  4' D!  L&  +( C   +',  +'  9 '6<( 22 2H  +69 '6 C =' E 46';

22'<+(CE)& &''<4E',6&

)'(7- @26H9+('9@&HB,9@2M'9@& B('9@29 =7&

2 '52'''0-

700', ='=&&'&-  6' +('-     & &6H    

"!$%!"!%%# #"# 

+'02C((22'<(/+'&

 ,69  700',-           

"!$%!"!%%#