Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/150/2005 • CJ GE ATA/150/2005 Généré par l'IA

Contractor Payments Deemed Wages Based on Employer Control

Numéro de cause ATA/150/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute concerned the proper classification of payments made by a contracting entity to subcontractors, specifically whether these payments constituted wages subject to withholding and related payroll taxes, or rather payments for services that should be reported on informational returns. The court reasoned that the determinative factor was the degree of control retained by the contracting entity over the manner in which the work was performed, finding that because the entity controlled the means, methods, and sequence of the work, the relationship was one of employer-employee, thus classifying the payments as wages subject to statutory withholding obligations.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contractor Payments Deemed Wages Based on Employer Control: The court reasoned that the determinative factor was the degree of control retained by the contracting entity over the manner in which the work was performed, finding that because the entity controlled the means, methods, and sequence of the work, the relationship was one of employer-employee, thus classifying the payments as wages subject to statutory withholding obligations.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
paiement du sous-traitant contrat d'entreprise moyen de paiement cession de salaire responsabilité de l'entrepreneur rémunération du travail

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the imposition of costs in the final order.
Généré par l'IA
A/2366/2004
Wages vs. Disability Payments Classification Dispute
A/4115/2021
Cantonal Compensation Fund v. Company Regarding Classification of Subcontractor Payments as Wages
A/3959/2006
Workers' Compensation: Employee vs. Independent Contractor Classification
A/1710/2002
Employment Status and Statutory Benefits Dispute
A/2454/2007
Contractual Payment Obligation Upon Delivery to Public Worksite

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the imposition of costs in the final order.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

  

    

 

  !"#$





%%%%%%%%%% 



& ' && (( && & ') ( 





     !"# 

& 

'(  )* )++++++++++, -  '%'., *///- 0 12,  // 34*//-5/-/2-012!%6'%78(

!(   !# 2*6 !&&$, 0 &.9##,  //  2/     )9/://32/  9*(

  419*/;,-4-2-9/034493 //*42///-2-<2-9/2 /2( /2-09)//,=3>4 -2/  // 2  5 ?/ -69/     //  32@//* A2?/-/6/( /*4-     3    2/  //  59 4/   6/?- 0 /  //   4  < /2  -4  2-9/   3/-;/4;/34-/-/-45(

   *4*  /- 3/ 3 4/  5*/(  5-,03/B,?)*)++++++++++2/ -4-2-9/3-/-4-32/03-5< 5   (  4,  3-/ 4 4    ?  4*//*4////;/6/5/* (

7(   -//  !' C2/ !&&#,  2/  *6/    2/5/ D/ 41E  F G  4-  2/* 0 3  3/--/-?32//;-51<15 // /1    3/ 'H /- !   / ;--   ///1'%-*6'%#.D IF8$'(&'G(

  -/* < ;/,  F  2/ ?/  )* )++++++++++  4/ 3 /;/ *-/( / /, -6/  '8 C2/ !&&# 4  *-/ /F ,-/40/4?34 (

$(  /4-!.C2/!&&#,)*)++++++++++41  /6*///;2/*(

#(    /  *4/ 4  $ * !&&#,   <4-?C?/,2/*/2/(   2/ 4 2-   */ -/ 4//1* 6*<( F , /-, 3*4>9/ 32/  6 2//6//-(  5 2/ 4?32/4-/150B-3(

"!$%"!&&# 7"# 

   32/ C*/ ;/ 36C 3 ?? * *///2  /-/?32/*-/*/;**/// *   J  2// 0   2 /;/(   *///3/2/*(

H(   4-  F   4/-   -// ?/  4/2/ 4  4/6//-/(

8(  F?/,--5-0C5(

& ( 

'(  C-  *4 / 2  C/// *4-,    26D(#H /K5//C///!!2*6'%$'    !&#L(H7('/(/4-*///2'! 4*6'%.#    #'&G(

!(   ' C2/ !&&#,  2 /4//      -  2/5D!&&!4(!8H8G( ;/,/4//// 2,/1344/??3</;////1 /41-2/5,*-23/ / * -5/ 4  /, ; <4/  -/-  341( 3         7' -*6 !&&$ ?/ 344/? 0  D "'8"!&&#''C2/!&&#G(

7(  ?/2*/;///*9,4<*44 6/?,-4,*4--/4K2/0 ,K2/-5<5?/2//2 //?K<2-9/?//2D(7$(7 G(

  ///-// ?/--- 45,344-3/7$/-7 4-/-(

$(  4,//2-9/*6/4>*/0 //44/412/;;-B 23/%3-53*//4 2-9/0///1!86'%8HD IF8$'(#'G(

   341,   6/5/ ;/5/  !&&$ -C0   4*/  /-/---;/*-4*-/ / '8C2/!&&#(

   4, )* )++++++++++   4 ?  C  ;/   4/40** 0(-?;/ 2--(

"!$%"!&&# $"# 

#(  /-?3/35// 03/;/-513/ 'H/-! ,F ;//44-/// 341?4-32/*,?/4/24 4*//,4?3>;/*-(

H(   ?3  // 3 4*/  / 4/ '%78, )*)++++++++++ 3 C*/ ;/ 36C 3 ?? *    3<--(/44/;/-6/ 24/-;/?34/44/(

8(  C-(3///5,-** MA7&&(  */095D(.8 G( NNNNN

*  &( + &    

,-.#/

- 26   /C-  !. C2/ !&&# 4 )* )++++++++++ -//2/*6/2/5/!'C2/!&&#L

.#$/

CL

*095-** MA7&&( L

/ ?, ;*-* < / %8  /2   / ;-- K5// C///,4->4>4-,42//*///;,   C 1  /;//, 4 2  /6 ;-- L  *-*/  ///?/,*/;*:424/5 */L//>-/<*4/*/ /6 ;--, '&&&  '$ L  4- >   4/1  4/  ,/2?-*:42,/2>C/0K2/L

/?4->0)*)++++++++++,//2/*6/ 2/5///?30K;;/;--0(

F/-5E )(:91,4-/,)*M/,,C5(



"!$%"!&&# #"# 

* /6*///;E

5;;/1 C/C(E  4-/E     )( / A(:91   4/;*>--/?-<4/(

 12,  5;;/1E           

"!$%"!&&#