Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/145/2007 • CJ GE ATA/145/2007 Généré par l'IA

Contract Dispute Arbitration Award Affirmation

Numéro de cause ATA/145/2007
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns a dispute over the validity of an arbitration award stemming from a contractual disagreement, where one party sought to vacate the award alleging bias and procedural unfairness in the arbitration process, citing the arbitrator's failure to disclose potential conflicts and misapplication of governing law. The court affirmed the award, reasoning that the grounds asserted for vacatur were insufficient under the governing statute, which permits vacatur only for egregious misconduct or clear departure from the arbitrator's authority, and found that the evidence did not demonstrate the level of bias required or that the arbitrator exceeded their mandate by interpreting the contract provisions, even if the interpretation was arguably erroneous.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Dispute Arbitration Award Affirmation: The court affirmed the award, reasoning that the grounds asserted for vacatur were insufficient under the governing statute, which permits vacatur only for egregious misconduct or clear departure from the arbitrator's authority, and found that the evidence did not demonstrate the level of bias required or that the arbitrator exceeded their mandate by interpreting the contract provisions, even if the interpretation was arguably erroneous.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
arbitrage validité du contrat confirmation de compétence litiges du travail valeur litigieuse arbitrabilité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/3554/2006
Confirmation of Arbitration Award Despite Claims of Bias and Exceeded Authority
A/4261/2006
Confirmation of Arbitration Award Regarding Contractual Breach
A/3820/2005
Arbitration Clause Validity Versus Contract Validity Dispute
A/913/2007
Challenge to Arbitration Award Regarding Contract Interpretation and Alleged Evident Partiality Upheld
A/1345/2006
Arbitration Award Enforcement Challenge Based on Exceeded Authority and Contract Misinterpretation Upheld

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to order the appellant to pay the court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



        

        

  

    



 !!"#$%&





%&$!'''''' 



( ) (( ** (( ( )+ * 





     !"# 

( 

'(  )* +,,,,,,- .  '/%!-  0***.,,,,,,-  1(   **230**.4(

!(  +*205**0*36*05* 6*4*7* 389+ :-266*0  !; 5 !&&$  * 2 .30   6* *.   ***(

<( (  '/ =* !&&#- > &<?<%- 2*.. **  6*     2 ?**@*>%'A0"?-04.*..*-B2* *C>;&A0"?( **-.306**.  *.. <'A0"?(

 5(  !< =* !&&#- > &$?'<- *  00*  6 D8  6*  !% A0"?B*6 -E**>F%A0"?-B2*3 C.3;&A0"?(

$(   G.  '! .05 !&&#-  +   ** > )( +,,,,,,  H* 4   30*  * .4   ** * 3 B 0*-33**2*'#*H..***8 '/.05'/;%7  +F$'(&':(

;(     '/ .05 !&&#- )( +,,,,,,   38  *5 0***H   .**   >  .*   .   03*>(23.D86*B**.* 3?.-0*D3.B-*6*.3H*24 .*.HH.6*I3**6*0J-*6* 5*.0**330*(+6***>.3>  33 > 2*  * B* 36* G 6**0 2HH*- 24*-( 6*2*..D238(      2 ?- * 2.*  ?K  * 3  0 4*(  * 3 5*  *D- * 2.* .   3  26*33G.4>03( B*6 -*.*.40 *6*D20-626.?* 03@( *.**3.>2HH>26D2*6*G3*6. 30* 3   .( 3- *  .**  +  6* > G H*0.- * * **.( H*- *  6*60 4.  *H* B* * .*3?.**.H*B2>26*-**33(

#(  3*..03*3;H.6*!&&F(

"$%$&"!&&# <"# 

 ( )( +,,,,,,  H*0.  9  * B* * 6* .. *H*4. .*3.68-035*3H*(+*6*>G H*0.-*3*03*(

 5( + D3.B200E*6*3*.**-*6** 5*3H*( .B-*3..* .2***>*0*-*0**00.4(

 ( =4..4..>)(+,,,,,,.*.?.!&H.6*!&&F 3*H0*5*B2**>(.. *H0. B-  6   3-  *5 4*   > =4  2.*(

F(  =-233*6*5(

( * 

'(  =.  03 * 6  =*** 03.-    657(;# *24**=***!!605'/$'    !&;L(#<('*(*3.0***6'! 305'/%;    ;'&:(

!(  ? * 3  *4D   0B -  3**-  *4DH*D6*0D*07(!F(' L'#!!M *4***8;305'/F/N+-+F$'(!'- 1'&% #!:(

<(   M*.*  *.-  6* 0D*0 4..  6.?* 3 * ;& A0"?- B  **   -   **   6**5**.H65M*$*.'M 84   ** *8  '< 605 '/#! 7   + F$'(''L 1 '!''!F- '//;##$:(

  +  =*3  *5 H..  0*8 MD8  6* > M*.*M*.-.306*0D*0*.;> !&A0"?*346*.B*=*H**036*0 M*'#*.< 7 1'!!<F- '//FF<<-*('-3( F<F:-.6*3**87 1'!<'&#- '//FF!;- *(!5-33(F!% F!/.H(*(:(

"$%$&"!&&# $"# 

   .30  !' > !$ A0"? *- B > *-  *H* 0@046*03*B844..*30* M*'#5 (

   6?-  .30  !; A0"?  3 O  3**3  *5*4*30**-3*60***H* 4+*30**.4-H0*HD3*36 =*H*MD86*DHM05**-646*. 0*4BM*36B(*-=*3*8B 00*6**4*8M84H0 7('#('((/&?(! L 1'!<'&#- '//F F!;-*(!-3(F<'.H(*(L 1'!<<F-*('-33($& $'-+'//F 33(;!F ;!%L "<%!"'//%'#=*'//%:(

  *3**333*5B***** H65    B  ..   H*H * 5  06*(  M4*-  HH-   0*8- M  .*.  *   H6*B3*5M.4*.*0=**57 1''/5 ';#L+'//<3(;<;L 1''%'/&L'&%5#FL'&$5;':(

   M38-    00* D .30   6* *.-0.-<'A0"?!%A0"?-38.*   04  .*.(  24* *5*50  D  46- ** 3 2* '# *. '    - B* *03*B- 3   ** 230**.4-3.2**** ***(

$(  + 2* '# *. !      . 0**0  *  30**0*3800**2*H*46(

  *6 H *6 G 3*  *.*- 00  46*. 5=*6  5=*6   H-  ..  2*.. ** B  5* 3H* 7( << ( !  L 1 '&% 5 !;/L ( ++P " (+ - ****8-00*-'//#-3(!'%L )( -.*6*30**-'/%!-33('%%:(  D0-  .B  2*H* 00*  * 6*  *H .**6 7 1 '/F% 3( !%%:(  3-  . 2 0  3*52GH*D. >0**00.4-0G0B2*.. 5..7 1'/%'3(;&:(

  238-+ **H*430* * .4  +* 3 B 0*(   2*  03* 3  3*- *  **B. 6* 3*  .**  0.*5*3H**3..*  .   0  0**00 .4- * > * 0*(  .B- 

"$%$&"!&&# ;"# 

.**H*0.( *50***H33>)(+,,,,,,B- 32D.*0-*6H.*6.?* 3B30*23.*+*(

;(  6B*3.8-**0*(

   2*  **4-  .00   3Q-   @ >.*.0+ @3.H*D 0**00.4(

,  (*  (    

-./%!0

.65*=.!!.05!&&#3)*+,,,,,,  .**  6*  05*    6*4*  '! .05 !&&# * **  H* 4   30*  * .4   ** * 3B0*L

/%&0

203*0L

H*0.****4*B23**** +*L

   6*  05*    6*4*   B  .  2****0*L

=3L

*B2*233Q2.00L

* B- H0.0 D * %!  *6   * H..   *5 H..  'F =* !&&; 7 1 + 'F<(''&:-  3. G 3 G 3.    = B* *6  *H** 3 6  *5 H..- 3  6*  0*8*35*L0.0****B*- 0*H0@363*40*L* * G .  *5 H..- '&&&  '$- 3 6* 3  3 6* .*B D **  2* $!  1(  3. G   3*8  3*  - *6B. 00 0@  36- *6 G =* > 26*L

"$%$&"!&&# #"# 

00*B3.G>)*+,,,,,,**B26*05* 6*4*>2HH*H..>(

+*.49 )06@-3.*-))(@?8 ?.*-=4(

0 *50***H9

4HH*8 =*=((*(9  6* 3.*9     ( (6@   3*H0G..00*B.D3*(

 86-  4HH*89           

"$%$&"!&&#