Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/143/2006 • CJ GE ATA/143/2006 Généré par l'IA

Warrant Validity and Officer Immunity from Trespass and Conversion Claims

Numéro de cause ATA/143/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The court reviewed a case concerning the nature and extent of a party's liability following the issuance of a warrant, where the property seized under the warrant was later found to be improperly taken. The court reasoned that the issuance of a warrant, even if subsequently deemed defective or based on insufficient grounds, provided the executing officers with a legal basis for their actions, thus protecting them from liability for trespass or conversion, provided the search and seizure were conducted within the scope of the warrant's authorization.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Warrant Validity and Officer Immunity from Trespass and Conversion Claims: The court reasoned that the issuance of a warrant, even if subsequently deemed defective or based on insufficient grounds, provided the executing officers with a legal basis for their actions, thus protecting them from liability for trespass or conversion, provided the search and seizure were conducted within the scope of the warrant's authorization.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
mandat de perquisition fondement de la responsabilité motifs protégés insaisissabilité motif de révision bien de stricte nécessité

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
This provision was cited in the dispositive to allocate the costs of the proceedings.
Généré par l'IA
P/12706/2020
Unlawful Arrest Warrant for Trespassing Due to Undisclosed Location
P/8960/2024
Search Warrant Validity and Admissibility of Appeal
A/4575/2006
Statutory Administrative Inspection Warrant Validity
A/1937/2005
United States v. Leon Application
PS/39/2020
Appeal Against Police Conduct During Theft Apprehension Dismissed

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive to allocate the costs of the proceedings.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       





  







!!"#$ %!&''''''''''  ! "#$% #"&'( 

( 

 ())*   





     )*+,)



/0  !1 !(#22222222223#)45(622222222227(  ( #&#/, 18*..9&:(;1 8' #(3<!7 (# #4&  *41  ;  :#118 # 2222222222  #;(0  ($ :4'= <>?@.9*0)&"; ;;((1#0

*0   // 1# *..,& !0 2222222222  #A(1  # #(  (;1  3#)

45 7 B  ";1   #  # '   #  #( A##4& #  = :"(# # #(  ( (0   C(#  = ( '(#  (# : ##(:(AA# ((D;3#)45  7& *E '#*..,&#( ($ 8#:)1# <>E@FG?0)0

90  (#C# *..,& ( #A#6(62222222222 ##((  1(   61= <>/EF&G,4/C# *..,0    ##(  #  6  '#  ( #A# #(   6 (  #( /'#*..,9/1*..G0

?0   /9 C#  *..,&  (6 2222222222&    :(# #( ;'(#  A  ( # 3#)45 % 7& (  ' 1 #( ( ##(# 0( (  '8 # (1    0 %(  # & #)#  (1(#  ( 11      %         & = :6#(  8# ' ( :)1#& : # (1#= 60

,0   ##(  1 #(  /E C#  *..,&    1#   (# #(08#(:)1#'# H #(1  '0

G0   *, C#  *..,&  (6 2222222222 (  (1   1 #(0  (  ( 11  1# =    (#    #( A# *..? ##B:'# 6 #(*..90( # (#(0

-0  1# ##(*GC# *..,0

F0   ( *FC# *..,&(62222222222( (4  #81##  #A( ##(1 #(/EC# *.., (  = (  #(    (##    #  /,  18 *.., ( (1 # 0

   (  (    #  (# #(  8# :)1#     ' 8  &   A(    (# ;   (;1     (  #(  ( #  ? 18 /E-- 3 I  ? .,7&

+*-.,+*.., )9+,)

:;# A#6 #(' 1# 04/C#*..,& 6 '# :'B:= <>,.&-,1(#&(#  <>G.E0)0

E0   #81##  #A$  (#(62222222222=(1  (&6)#( A# '(#&/, 18*..,&B: #9/ # / '#  1(#A#/C'#*../& = #B#)

#A# =:18(: #/ #' (#  :#1(# #(  ( "$#B5 #1J    ' 3' #1(8K  I  I  9 /?70  8# ( :)1# B# ( #    ##(  :    *E '# *..,  #  '  '   : #9#9 (#A  #((11 # = @ '##& '#'    #'##   /E 1 /EG, 3  ) % F9/09.7&  B# ;#  :# #(  : # /.   " )0  (B &#)#'# H #(1 0

/.0   *. ( (8 *..,&    1#   (# #(   (   C   (0

)

/0   C   1  # '   C## #( (1  &  (   '83 0,G (#@(;# #(C###('18/E?/) ) *.,K 0G90/# 0(# (1##  #'/*  18/EF,) ) ,/.70

*0 0 ( #B#((;1 8' #(  # #1  @ 6(B('841@ 3 09/70

 80  6 A##(11 #  #( #@' ;(  @        8A### B# @$ (    #41  (#  (& =  #1# & (11  #  ' 6 B# "8#    (;1  8' #( ( B@#  '#    8A## 3!1(#     (#&/E-?&0*//,70 # #;@#1J 1(L#)# A## & #  1&(11( #8 #(# B#@  ##1 =(  # B# ( #8 #(6 D" ;#(18 =@  @# H ( #'# 3 >E,,.GK > /E-E0*.?)*.,70

90 0 : # 9/  # /     A##   '  1#  (11 :18  (     # /   #'    )&  # #8#&# #(= (( (;1 & ( =#(11 <>/.@...0)(1#4(& <> -@,..0)(6#41  <>,@...0)4 (##41((  (;1 0   A## #( :#B #  // C'# *../0  #(# #(

+*-.,+*.., )?+,)

 # '#   (  # #B #  :  B: A##  A = :#(#;( #8 #(8#B3 +9-G+*..?//1# *..?70 AA &@ #/G(#;( #8 #(8#BB# A### 1 #4#1(8@#1J ' 8(;/C'# *../&'@ '#;)0

 80 %(@ #1#)&:#1J ((8C  ('&   #( ' ;( #88&B@#(# #B(#(#B& 4(  BB@(# @(#;#&'  #(0)  1#  ' #1(8   6(  B 6 M  '   ;# #(A  (  #((11 #=@ '##& '#'    #'##  3 0 /. )70 # B@6(&  #     '0    %      #( (11 #    (  ( (#   ;# #( A# ;'(# (11  '0   B #('(##6)#( #1(8(0'  1H1   B# (  8#  @)1# B# @  B@ A(1    #( (11 # '  @   3 +9-F+*..?  // 1# *..?70 :H  #  (A#1  (# #(  #8 1##  #A ( B' 1# : B#' ' #1(8 (  (#  A# 3 +G.+*...  / A'# *...7& 1#   ( #   :18  ( 1 #( = : # / )& $ (1#'6(: #/.)0

  (B&8#:)1#M(  (#' H #' 1# A##=: #9/ #/  0

?0  (C 0

   # #;1(1 M3 0F- 70

( )  

+,-#!.

 '8  ( # C   *F C#  *..,  !1   !(# 2222222222( ##(1 #(# #((;1 /EC#  *..,K

-#$.

C K

+*-.,+*.., ),+,)

# B@#@ M@1(1 K

(11#B  H  =! "#$% #"&'(  ( ##B@= # #((;1 0

%#; 5 !1('$&# &!0$"4&!1<#&!0 "#&!1(& C;0

(1 #81##  #A5

;AA#4)C# C05  '#)# 5     !0 ((# 0('$  

(#(A(1 H  (11#B6 #0

 4'&  ;AA#45           

+*-.,+*..,