Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ATA/139/2006 • CJ GE ATA/139/2006 Généré par l'IA

Buyer's Recovery for Accepted Non-Conforming Goods

Numéro de cause ATA/139/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Frais judiciaires à la charge de l'autorité
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The initial dispute involved a contract for goods where the buyer alleged the seller breached by failing to deliver conforming items, leading to a claim for damages based on the difference between the contract price and the market price plus incidental damages. The court reasoned that the governing statute provided for recovery of damages for accepted non-conforming goods based on the diminished value, or the cost of repair/replacement, plus incidental and consequential damages, but the buyer, having retained and used the goods, could not recover the full market price differential as a measure of damages unless the goods were worthless, ultimately limiting recovery to the difference in value or the cost of repair, offset by any payments made.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Buyer's Recovery for Accepted Non-Conforming Goods: The court reasoned that the governing statute provided for recovery of damages for accepted non-conforming goods based on the diminished value, or the cost of repair/replacement, plus incidental and consequential damages, but the buyer, having retained and used the goods, could not recover the full market price differential as a measure of damages unless the goods were worthless, ultimately limiting recovery to the difference in value or the cost of repair, offset by any payments made.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
acheteur valeur litigieuse versement de dommages-intérêts défaut de la chose valeur au cours recouvrement des frais

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Applied for the allocation of court costs.
Généré par l'IA
A/496/2006
Buyer's Acceptance of Non-Conforming Goods
A/683/2001
Goods Non-Conformity and Contractual Liability Dispute
A/3242/2005
Goods Non-Conformity and Contract Damages Dispute
A/1248/2006
Breach of Contract for Non-Conforming Goods
A/662/2007
Contract Breach: Non-Conforming Goods Sale

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of court costs.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

        

 

   

 





!!"#$ %!&''''''''''  !"#$%& 

& 

())( )   ()  *   () ( )



+     () ( )   (,))&   -) )

  !!"#$ %!(''''''''''  !!! #'(& $%& 



    ()*+(

 

,0   + 12  )..3$ !4   !&2 5555555555 62(" 7  2 248 &  &22   2% 9  &2 2&  & 2 &    94:4  9   ;   (&&4   244< &2   !&25555555555$2 5555555555$;25555555555 &44"%$ 2& 2 $=9$555555555550

  2    &%  )"4 >&  &  2&$ :  2<22  0 ?, )"4 :9244<@ 2&& ?&2 <2  42?A& 2 &:4 0

)0  2,-BB$!4 !&2555555555562("7& 8 & & 29$&<1 @C  &2 2&& 20' ?&2    &  &2;;   &  2% 2  4&   24&    94:4    &0  &    <2  & ;&2   22  !0 5555555555))&D )..E&E.12)..30  22 2&<2  &   "   &4422&  &22 2&  4 2"  <?   &'$ 2& (%  2<<? &'0

E0  F&   %2  %2     4   94:4 $  9@24  &:4 6%2& 4 &  2&   #&&:292;&4 2&A2("7 4 8$&&   94:4  2 2  % 9?&2   ;   (&&4  22 # 42@$9 <24 % &4 #2 20

      G2  2&    4$  %2  &  &  2&& <2  '&4 &2&2 62("7F8$  ,.4<)..3$%2;%&<4 @C $&% G& 2&4&44 20   :$ &? 5555555555 & ::&2,4<)..3$=4G2& 2&?2   $ G2;;2$=22& 2&&44 220

   2  "%  %2 ;%&<4   @C $  )E  4< )..30 %2%2#<2 <22 ))4<)..3&   42&<1 2&0

   22&  ,, 1%2 )../$ G&;;2  &  G2 2&     2&  %2  &%   G4:4   $  2  & ;&2 @ &  &2 2& G 2  %< @ & G4:4   ;$   &<24 2&420

30   ,, 1%2 )../$   4   2% G &2 2& &22 $  %2F,.4<)..3;2  22 : 22&0

*,-++*)../ (E*+(

/0   )- %2 )../$  &4422&  &  &  4 2"  &  2& 62("7  &4422&8  1   & 2 1   ,3 ;%2 )../&?55555555550& 2 &;&4=&2    % &    %2  F$ @2 & 2 2  9  &2 2&9 &2 2&& 2$%&' =4&  2%=    &? 5555555555$ 4 2   &2 9 &2 2&  & 2&44&;&4=&2;&  2&G%2&4  B& &<,-HE6 IFH,30.,80

+0      + 12 )../$  &? 5555555555 &  & "  2<422  2;& 22&&4422&)-%2)../$J -42)../0 ;&4 2&&&2;; (&&4 2 & 924&   2 &&   %2  C  242 =  &% 2  2&$9 2B9&&&  2&& <2  ,/4<,-H+6IFH,303,809 &2 2;2%2 &%2  2  &42;2 2&  %242  @9 & 9?+=90$&4422&%2 ?42 & 4&'  242   <2 $  2 2&  22  % 2& & ?  2,2) ,,2) 0

B0  2 24& &&,312 )../0 ;&4$2(2 %2  C   2%<$ ;  G2 C  & :20 F<2224 $  & %2  C  1 $  2 2%&@   &     % 4%G &2 2& = : 2   :2 2&0

H0  ,312 )../$ 4 G :4 &&&0  @C  %2    2 2  & 4  &  & 0  %2  F    % @G2  <22   2  = 4C4  : 2   ?2:  G0

-0   2<  <?   &'    2    1: :  ,-4< )../ & &K  9     & *),+.E*)..E &&  & &2 29244<2 =22 2&<20

,.0   = 2 &2&$  2<  <?   &' 9 &;24 @9< 4&24)..+@%2  :=1:0

,,0   2&  2;&4;2 &2-4)..+0F$   :=1:0



*,-++*)../ (3*+(

) 

,0   2< 422  2; ?42 G&;;2   2<4   %<22   & 6 0 ,, 0 )   &2   & 422  2%  ,)  4< ,-H/( ( /,.A *,)3*)../H4)../80

)0   1  4 2% 122 2&&4  $& =  : %< 6 0 /+    &2  9&:2 2& 1222  )) &%4< ,-3,II )./A 0+E0,2 0 80

E0  F&9 2+. < $& @2 &&2 & & @2 &  &# 2 4    22&   &   2 C  2:  &  2&=@9&2 &4&2;20

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

/0   &  & 2  9 &   ;&4 2&  ;   ( &&4 &  & 2 C  &#2 4 22& %&2 2 C  2:  &  2& =  @9 &2   & 4&2;20  2 24  &   0

   2<422  2;1=9&2&&&@2  & &2  & 2  &%   & 1222 %  <2 " %&2 &    22 2&   <2$ & @    2&  9244<@92#<2 2  2 %&1 &  2&0 2< 422  2;1: @&& 2%2 C  2%<$; @2 &:20 2<422  2; @@&2 @92 %2  &   9 &2 2&$  & 2  &   &  ;J&  &#   22& & 0  ;; $  9#'& #" &O  <? 2 

*,-++*)../ (/*+(

42 $&1 &  2&&2 <& 2 & 292  92 C =&2022 4C42&: 2 &;24$  $  &1  2   4 92% = 4$    &   2  &&&  2&2 2:2$9  &4  & 2 6 *-,+*)..3  )E &%4< )..380  ;22 2%$ @ @ &2  9#'& #"  $  & 2 G&   2 C  & 2:  &  2&=&2& 9 &2 2&6 *+//*)..)/&%4<)..)80

+0   2  2& 9   2;;   9"0  2 2: 2%2 &&   &  =  <2 G   & #0  $ @ @ &2  92 &$?(29& 92 C =&2& 9 &2 2& & ? 2 240   122 2&  <?   &'  & &&:  <2$    &1   &  2$  2%4  %   9?2 2&2&&: 2&&< 0 9%#22 2& <2 &2  &;24$    &  I 9    & 2 I 9&   2 C  2:  &  2& = &2 &   &1  @2   & 

6 */3H*)..3,/12)..380

B0   &  &  2%<$ ;  92 C  & &2 6 0+. 0< 80

H0   92  2 2:$  4&4   PQ /..0(  42 =  #:  & 0242  PQ,9...0(&?2 246 0HB 80

 RRRRR

( )      

 2%<  & 2 1   + 12 )../  !4   !&25555555555 &   22&   &4422&  &  &  4 2"&  2&)-%2)../A

4 =#:!4 !&255555555554&4 & PQ/..0(A

&242  PQ,9...0(=!4 !&2 5555555555=#: & A

&442@ C =!"#$%& & $=&4422&  &  &  4 2"  &  2&$   4   &  2&    #&&:2  G2;&4 2& 22 @G= ! ! ! #'(& $ %&   2 240

*,-++*)../ (+*+(

F2: 7 !0 '#"$ 2 $ !4 P2$ !0 #2$ !4 &$ 1:$ !0 $1:( 0

&4 2<422  2;7

:;;2"(12 107  2 7     !0 &&2 Q0'#"  

&2&;&4 C  &442@? 20

 "%$  :;;2"7           

*,-++*)../