Construction Defects and Contractual Liability Dispute
Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Synthèse Legislator
Généré par l'IAThe case addresses multiple claims, including alleged defects in construction materials, resulting in various disputes regarding liability and damages across several agreements. The court's reasoning involved meticulously analyzing the contractual relationships, the nature of the alleged defects, the timing of discovery, and the applicable statutory periods and terms. The various claims were either affirmed, dismissed, or remanded based on whether the evidence supported the allegations under the governing contractual and tort standards, particularly concerning breach of warranty, negligence, and adherence to specific performance timelines stipulated in the agreements.
Regeste Legislator
Généré par l'IAArt. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Construction Defects and Contractual Liability Dispute: The court's reasoning involved meticulously analyzing the contractual relationships, the nature of the alleged defects, the timing of discovery, and the applicable statutory periods and terms. The various claims were either affirmed, dismissed, or remanded based on whether the evidence supported the allegations under the governing contractual and tort standards, particularly concerning breach of warranty, negligence, and adherence to specific performance timelines stipulated in the agreements.
Mots-clés
Généré par l'IADispositions légales citées
Généré par l'IADécisions connexes
Généré par l'IAQuestions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator
Généré par l'IAImposed costs on the appellant for the federal court proceedings.
Denied the request for legal aid.
Texte complet
!"
#$%& " ''''''''''
(
) *+ ,(
!"#
)
() * + ,,,,,,,,,,- . ,,,,,,,,,, (/&/- 0 +1+ 1. + - 2 . . 3 0+33 + + 4 0+5 + . 65 3 + . 37 (//'- 5 +5 -6 3 +0 7 (//(- . 1 +5++ + 8 9+ 2 6 8 . )
!) 2 6 : 3 0. -+2 . . 3 ;1 3 8 .). .3+ 8 . 2<; 1+ + 0. + =+ 2 6>8 .?- + 2<; 1+ -42 + 3 0;+5 (//!@(//A) 3 + 3 (//B- *) ,,,,,,,,,, . . .+3+. . 2<; 1+ ) C++ 0 22 + + - 8 . 5 .++ 0.+3+ + +.0. + 4 2 . - +6 8 +-4 + 0 :3 3 + D+ (//B)0< 2 .+ :3 4 + - < 8 . +8+.4*),,,,,,,,,, .++ 0.+3+ + . 2<; 1+ - !$D+ (//B)
A) / 7 (//B-*),,,,,,,,,,. .3+4+5 . + + 0. + =+ 2 6> + ? 8 .)C01+ 0 3++ + + -+. + .+ 0.5 + ('+ . 8 3 + =E? & E 2 . + 0 + 5+- 2 4 + 0 :3 0 7 (//#)
$) + (A 5 37 (//B- 2 .+ + +8 3. *),,,,,,,,,, F - 32 +5+ . 4 3+ 32- G3 . 2 32 < - 37 0+ . 8 3 + F0+ 5+ ; 5 3 0. .3+F (//B @ (//# . + &) 0. + 7..8+++ ++ F 3 -+ :-2 3+ 33)
&) !% 7 (//%- *) ,,,,,,,,,, . . +8 3. F0+ . + .+3+. . + 0. + -6 F0+05+ F+F / E40.;. .+8+:.4 7 (//%2 ; 5 33)C++ 0 22 + + 8 3. / 5 37 (//%- < 8 .- !' 5 37 (//%- . .++ 0.+3+ + H *) ,,,,,,,,,, . . +. 4 ; 5 33 2 7 (///- 2 + 0.+3+ + - 2 5 .7 +8 :+63 < 0. 3 I;+5 (//% (///)
B) *),,,,,,,,,, 3. :+63 < I. 3 I;+5 (//% (///- .+ :3 334 + 3 (///)
"$%&"!''& A"#
#) +1 $ 5 37 !''$- < 8 . +8+.4 *),,,,,,,,,, .++ 0.+3+ + :+63 < + + 0. + - 3 + J ; ; + 5 + K- 3 +8 F0+ 5+ +. 37 0.; .8++ +82. + 4A' .+ )
%) .++ -*),,,,,,,,,,8 3. 22 + + A' 5 37 !''$) .++ 0.+3+ + 32 7+++ 3+6 . .; ) + -+05+ 22 F0 8 + + 3 +6 :3 F0+05+ 2 2 . .5+ . . 32 7++. 33 .; ) 5+ + . 2 763 . 0. !''A- G3 .2 +8+ 3.+-F+05+ 2. .2 + +. + ) 3. 4 2 5 + L 3 2 + . 8 + - 5 0 :2 2 . ++ + )
/) *) ,,,,,,,,,, . . 2 33++ ; 1. 0+ + 0 22 + + - BD5+ !''&)
(') + A(D5+ !''&- < 8 .+8 3.0. + F 22 + + 5+ . . D . )
(() *) ,,,,,,,,,, + D . .++ 5 33++ 0+5 + .=+ 2 6> ?-2 3+42 ( 3 !''&) 3 42 5 + 3+ . + 5 + 2 2: 13 2 . . 22 + + -F+. + D + )
(!) 5+ . 4 .2 - 0+5 + . - . 3+ + (& 5 + !''&- D 4 8+ 3 + .++ F. )C01+ 32 7++ + :3 - 0+ +3. 3+ F + 2 + + 3 61 3 0. - 33 I :2 + +6 :. 7 5 + $5 +!''&-D + 4 .2 ) + - 5+ 7..8++. 4 : 2 + 0 + .++ 0.+3+ + +0<5+ 2+ -5 ..3 .5 F.-0 ++63 . 1 + ) 8+- + + + F 5+ 33+F.4I+ +3. +8+ 3.+3 + D5+ !''$- 5 2. + D+ 4 7 !''A- 5 7..8++ I 2 M . +8M : + I :3 I. . !''A) - .3 ; I. + 2 57 )
(A) .2 0+5 + .- 321. 2+6 2 + - . . 33+F. 2 (/5 +!''&)
($) + (#3+!''&-*),,,,,,,,,,++ . 2 763 . .2 + I :3 I. .!''A) 2+ . . 5 <. 4I+ +3. 2 +8 3 + - !A3+!''&)
C - . .1 . 4D1 )
"$%&"!''& $"#
() + +1. .++ 22 + + A(D5+ !''& + D . .+.1 8 3 2 + 2 6 0 + . 32. - 57 = )B! + 0+5 + .!B3+(/#A @ (A'H )%# 61 3 0+5 + .# 2 37 (/%% @ (A')'BH )!B !# 61 3 + +8 : 2 . 0 22 + + !& 8.5 + (/## ?)
!) + + I.+3+ + . + 8+:. 2 61 3 I+5 + . = ) BA ) A ?) 0 ) !! +. ! +2 F I. + F+ .; 4 :3 4 + 0 :3 :F + 2 2 2 . 5 61 3 0. = )? F+ 7+ 2 :3 3+ 2 . .+8+:.2 61 3 I. = )7?- .+3+.) 0 26 - 3+ 61 3 0. + + 0. + !!3+(//B=+ 2 6> ?)
A) : 3 0 )(!;)( ) -0. + F+02F+ !$' .+ 2 1 33 + .++32 +2 0 )B;)( -4 5 + (B 3 3:+33- (! 3 3:+3301+ :+63 < 0. - .+3+..8++ +5 3 + )
7) + -0 )!& -88. 4+ 5 3 + J ; ; + 5 + K 22+7 0 26 - +2 F0 . + .8++ +5 3 .+3+. . :+63 < 0+ - 33 - 7 .; .8++ +84 37 0E 2 42 A' .+ H0.+3+ + :+63 < N 0.+3+ + + = )!&;)! (!;)( ) ?)
$) 0 26 - .7 . :+63 < 0. 3 + 0 7 (//%- F0+ 05+ 2 3+. 33) . + ++ . ; 5 2 1 33 + .+ 3:+33 O 3 - + 5 3 +0 7 !''$) 22 + + ! 5 37 !''$-F +.!'( .+ C4 .;. - !$' .+ C F+2 61 3 0. )
&) 8 3.3 :+2 + + 2 + -0 4D 4 + F 8 . .+3+. 3 (B 3 0. - (! :+63 < - + +0< 2F+ .+ 2 1 33 + .+) + - + 0 2 . + 0 :3+ + 88 +5 3 7 37 0.; .8++ +8 2. + 4 A' .+ C)
"$%&"!''& &"#
B) 61 5 + . 2 763 . D+ 7 !''A-F+ + 4I +1+ +88+ .4; 5 . .+)
#) ) I + 2 .+ FI+<5+ + 8+ + + + : + 2 .5 2 - F+ 5 + 2- 4 5 + I+5 + D 3 +8- I 2 - 2 + 32 + + : 2 + -I 2 = *"B/"!''&% 5 37 !''& +)& .8. + . ?)
7) + AB A# - 0. + F+ 2 . 2 4 + 2 F + + + 4 .2 5 2 F + 5 F. F+ + + ;7++ .48+ 5 + D 3 +8 + ; 1 2 5 ) 2 ++ - + + 2 + +33.+ 3 +8+ 3.+2 + I+ 37 3 = )A#?)
) +2 + + +3++ - F 2 .5 + . 1 + 2 +7 4 . . 2 3+ :+63 < = )B ;)$ ?- 8 3D 40 + 0 :3 = )/ ?) : - < 22 .+ 3 +8 +5 F. 3 . + 0. + -. 2 .+. 2F + F+ 2 . 24 :3 2 + 3+ I+ - + 3 +33.+ 3 +8+ 3.+ < = )/;)! ?)
) D +2 - +8+ 3.+ + L 2 + 2+ 3 - + 1.. 3 : D +5 0 :3 F + I 22 . .= *"&/"!''&B 2 37 !''&?)
) I 26 - + 2+6 + FI +8+ 3.+ . . 5 <. 4 0+5 + . 3 + D5+ !''$- 5 2. + D+ 4 7 !''A) I 4D + F I+ +3. +. .F 2 + - FI 5++ + I :3 D+ 7 !''A- . + 3+8 3 +5 )
%) 0. + .+3+. 2 L 3 . 4 8+ 5 + - 2 . + 3 4 .+3+ + - + F+0 + 32L;. 3+ + -F0+02 5 8+ 5 + + D 3 +8 = ) !! ) A ?- 5 +7 22 .+ + 0 + . .3+F 8+ 0.5+ +1 : +5 2 ++ 0.+3+ + ) 4 :3+ + 0 2 . 0 + : 2 + 0 + !!+.A)
/) ) C D +2 -I : 2 + F + + F+ 2 ++6 3 1 5 2 I. + ) F + - + + 5L 6 : 2 + F + 88 2 7 . . G3 2 5. 2 ) D +2
"$%&"!''& B"#
8 3 2 ++2 0+ + 0 88+ = *"$("!''& / D+ !''$ +)#H *"(A"!'' !''&- +)&?) + .8 + +2 I 1 2 5 + I22 .+ + - F I7= *"("!''&((D5+ !''&H *"('!"!''$(! 7 !''$ .8. + . ?)
7) 0 + D1 F 2 763 1 5 . 5+ L +. . 33 + + : 2 + = *"#B"!''( A( 3+ !''(H *"&'"!''! (# 3+ !''!?- + + 8 + F 88 2 7 + . . 2 5. F0 22 + . + .3 . 2 0. + = *"((/"!''! ( 5 37 !''!?) ++- 3+ F0 . + + 0 3+ ;< P+ +32 5 2; 3 2 ;+ - N + 3 3.+3 : < .++5. 2 . . + + + + : 2 + = *"$B"!''$!$3+!''$?)
(') I 26 - . 2 763 . I. . !''A)C3++3+ 2 763 - F : +0 2 88 2 7 4 3 + I 7 !''A) 2 ++ - I61 2 5 + . 2 763 . I. .3+F !''A !''$- + + I :3 8.5 + - D+ 7 !''$)0 + F +8+ 3.+2 + I 2. 3+ - 22 + . 5 :+ 0 + 4 . + + 0.; F 0 5. 0. 2.3 .= *"&/"!''&B 2 37 !''& .8. + . ?)
(() .F - D .)
(!) + +1 .3 3 2 9= )AA?)
QQQQQ
* )-
./01#" 2
. 57 + D . ( 3 !''& 2 * + ,,,,,,,,,, .++ 22 + + 8 . 2<; 1+ + I. + A(D5+ !''&H
"$%&"!''& #"#
01#$2
D H
+ FI+I 22 9I.3 3
33+F 2 . .++ 4 * + ,,,,,,,,,,- 4 8 . 2<; 1+ + I. + - 5+ D ++F 0+5 + .- ++ F0.2 3 0+ + 27+F )
C+.1 > *3 5<-2 .+ H * 3 3+ +5+ OO++-3 37
3 33++ 0+5 + .>
1 88+6 > 2 .+ > )* +; + ) 5<
2+ 8 3 .++ . . 33+F. :2 + )
65 - 1 88+6 >
"$%&"!''&