Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ACOM/67/2005 • CJ GE ACOM/67/2005 Généré par l'IA

Distinction of Controlling Precedents

Numéro de cause ACOM/67/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns the interpretation and application of several prior judicial precedents involving similar factual scenarios to determine the current matter's outcome. The court's reasoning focused on distinguishing the present facts from those of the controlling precedents, finding that the differences in the operative facts warranted a different legal conclusion, and therefore affirmed a decision contrary to the appellant's position based on the specific language and circumstances of the cases cited by the opposing party.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Distinction of Controlling Precedents: The court's reasoning focused on distinguishing the present facts from those of the controlling precedents, finding that the differences in the operative facts warranted a different legal conclusion, and therefore affirmed a decision contrary to the appellant's position based on the specific language and circumstances of the cases cited by the opposing party.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
revirement de jurisprudence arrêts en interprétation constatation de droits subjectifs motivation du revirement jurisprudentiel conflit de juridictions procédure préjudicielle

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.
Art. 64 LTF
Cited for granting the request for legal aid.
Généré par l'IA
A/184/2005
Distinction of Precedent Based on Factual Differences
A/993/2006
Precedent Application and Distinctions in Statutory Interpretation Appeals
A/1340/2005
Appeals Regarding Statutory Interpretation and Evidentiary Rulings
A/4486/2006
Statutory Interpretation and Appeals on Factual Applications
A/100/2005
Statutory Interpretation and Appeals Rulings

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for ordering the appellant to pay the court costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited for granting the request for legal aid.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

        

       

  



          

 !"







##$"%&&&&&&&&&&  !"#$%#& 

& 

  ' 





(      )             

 '()*'

 ( 

+,  !-,..........%..........+/00%&1 2 12&&32  42#2   5#%   -1 +///,   2  &-   54 2  4 6&&3242#2 67 %&8 &1    292  4  2   6&&32%     (: & &1 (::+,

(,  &2 ;&< (::=%!-,.......... &> 9 2&&-2? &242#2 5#@2'

5A  9 B  - 4-22&  2C- 4  &9&2 @ B    3% 2 &$&2 -   42#2   5#   42#2    @22#2 2B,  -  2  &-3  &22 ,

;,      * & &1 (::=%  &>   9   29&- !-,.......... ?  -  2  $ %  -& 29 ?     2?4#2 2#24 2   &2%&?4-22&   2 1&&D4&1  2&42? %& &2 D (=: 2  E% &-3    2& 4 --&2  2,  22&4 2 & 2422 2&#&2 2&,

=,  !- ,..........  -  &>  12 #&&2 &2  &2 2&%  &2  +; & &1 (::=,   92  #&2% 4  % ?  92#2  &--2????$&# 1 &% ?2 2  29922  63-  4&2  2&, 4   % &   29&- 2&  2#       3 ?4 #2  &1   922 - - 2&4F2342&1 ? , 92%?4#2 &-  2 292  4  2   6&&32%  -G- ?   F2 &92& 2&#$  ,

H,  &>9 &?424 2 &-  &    - 4&&2 2&   2 2#2  !- ,.......... D 2   &2 4&&2 2&   9&-    2 2 , 9  D   2#2  2&% !- ,..........    &>  9&-2 4&&2 2& <- -2, >3-   +;& &1 (::=% &   &23  ?  53-      1& D F23 ?  2 D4-22&&2 & 42&4 2 $3?2# ,

*,  4&&2 2& $ 9  (0$#2(::H%-& 29 ?&2 2&4-22& %& -- 4F2342

 ';)*'

?   &-3    2& 4 --&2  2%  2   -G-& & 2  ?424>#2 24>&3,

0,  !- ,..........  2 $  & &    22& 5   &--22&&42#2 @ B% (=9#2(::H,  &  1-  D 4& &2  - &#22&     9&% D 4 2&22& ?,

I,  22&+0-(::H%2  $ ?G  -&#22&

/,     -2 2&  +0 - (::H  2#  9&  4992% 42#2 &D&92- 2&22&&&2 2&,

   

+,  223& 22&&&2 2&(0$#2(::H 2 $  23 9&-2 54 &2 &-  %&  #1@ ,*(&242#2 (*-2+/0;'J +;:K ,I0 53- 42#2 0 -1+/II'J +;:,:*K ,(* (0  53-  2   29 F & 4&&2 2&    &  (H 9#2+/00'B,

(,  &- - 252#2 2 2 F &@ ,*(,+   *;    ,B, 6?  & ?2  &  4 2#2    & &-  & -2&2 2&4-22&D 25, 5#% #&2 D& 2*;2;?&2 2&42-- 2 2&&  92F   , F -  4 2 (H %  9&- 2& 2#2 2  &-&9&- 2&1% 2&2 )&2C-% 9&- 2& &9&2%  2& & --     %    9&- 2& & 2,42( 2&2 2&2?9&- 2&&9&2  G  21  22 F &   2 &  2C- 2#2 2, 92%  &   53-  L   9  ?2 92F   &2 2& L-22&F 292 &-- 2%F2C-L &9&2  F2C-L 222@ 2(02+B,

;, ,  53-  4    9  (::= J (::H @2'5  B% 21  45% &  62   22 F   @62  B, F -& 2H(6299+%4-22&F &? &2 2& 42-- 2 2& D 42#2   5# &  -2   ?  2    2 2 4 2 2#2 2 & 4 2  $3 ?2# , 4-22&   2  &2   &>   9 %  #2   &--22&2C-&@ 2H( B,

 '=)*'

 1,       3    2C- 22#2 2% &   -&2  &  2   &# 2& &    2#2   2 @ 2 H+ 6299 +     B,  #    &# 2&  &1& 2& 2 292?    2#2   5#    %  - 254 3%53- 2C- 3(::=J(::H  & @2'5' B, F -& 2=%&&#&2& &24-22&%)2 &2 G  2 242&4 2  $3 ?2#        9  &   6  &   6-  ?2 35  2C- @ 2 = 6299 ( ' B, 4-22&   2  &2   &>   9 %  #2  > 4-22& @ 2=6299; =' B,

 ,  ?' 1&& 4-22&   3 D 4&1  2& 4 2 2#2 2 & 4 2  $3 ?2#   42#2    6-  ?2 35  2C-,   F23 -2% 4-22& 2 2&2, 45%9 &2? & 4 2  2 2422#2 2 2H( 6299 +     = 6299 ( ' , E   ? 2&   & 2 232  45,

 ,  $2  &  %   2 2& D 4-22& 4 6  &&2# G 3&#2232 @ !)+*;)(::( +I -1 (::(   9 2 B,   22%  &2 2& 42-- 2 2& &2#  G  21 D &  2    & 2  3-  2& #221% ?2  -   #&2 2  2C- ?42 &5 && FF23?2,

 , 45%   ?' 2 ?&G -2   3%29 G  2 2422#2 2&4 2  $3 ?2# A 2  -2 -  4  2# @ 2 2  4 2 2#2 2B   -2% 2 4>   2 4F-2   5 ?2#   2C-,53- 2 & 9&2& 2&22#2 2,  9  2 2- &25 ?   2 2 4 2 2#2 2 &1   ?     ?2 &   &M  23  --&2  2% 2    &2 2&,   2   2&  53-  4     G   %     & 2 D       $&   &2 2& - 2%&#  ' %?2& #221 & 2  D4-22&,   ? 2 24212&&32% &1   -  D 42#2   5#%  &  &#2  32 2--  &-%    &2  53-  4  99   3%?422 &2 2&4-22&& 4 2H(6299+  =6299(' ,

=,  4 &D & ?9  ?& -22    &2 2&  2# D  2 2    2 2#2 2%   F23

 'H)*'

  452,22&? &? 23 &2  &2 G ,4-22&  3  & 9&2 2&2  2 1 2 D4 &2 2#2 2  4F-  &2   2   #  & -22&   %  9 $&2 43-342 2&- 25,4992 5 &#&>D9 &?4 -2&22  & %#&-22&&4-2?(::HJ(::*, >2D 34$& ?&2&& &22  & -22&  35 4& &1(::=#  G   K    2     # 99   & 29%  &  4> 2#2&3--  4-2?(::=J(::H  ?G -&#22&> -  $ ,

*,  #?25%&-2 #&>D 9 &?4  &2 ,

0,         2 23  -&-    N @ , ;; B, 2-2 & OPI::,''&D& ?22 &2&  2-2 -2D63L2#2  5#@ ,I0 B, QQQQ

*   (+           

,-#.!$"/

#1&2 $ (=9#2(::H!-,..........&   22&  &&2 2&   9   2 &&-2?   &2  (0 $#2(::HK

#.0/

4- K

#&2D9 2&&-2? &2&&# 22&&2 K

2 ?42L N4-&- K

& D  &   2-2   &  OP I::,''  D  63  42#2 5#K

 '*)*'

&--2?    22&%  &2% D ! "# $% #&    & %#2$22?42#2 %D9 2&&-2?  &2%22?4 - 42  2&12?,

E23 A !-&#>%2 K !- & !-RR222RR2%--1

&-&--22&&42#2 A

39925A  2 A       ,!262& ,&#>

&2&9&- 22& &--2?F 2,

 5#%  39925A