Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
ACOM/60/2005 • CJ GE ACOM/60/2005 Généré par l'IA

Multi-Issue Contract and Statutory Dispute Resolution

Numéro de cause ACOM/60/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The litigation involved disputes over several separate contracts or transactions, each concerning distinct transactions and statutory contexts, as evidenced by the multiple dates and section references in the ruling. The court's reasoning, which is interspersed with citations to various statutory provisions and previous holdings, consistently focused on applying the specific legal tests relevant to each discrete issue—such as contract interpretation, statute of limitations, or specific regulatory compliance—to determine the parties' respective rights and liabilities under the governing legal framework applicable to that segment of the controversy.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Multi-Issue Contract and Statutory Dispute Resolution: The court's reasoning, which is interspersed with citations to various statutory provisions and previous holdings, consistently focused on applying the specific legal tests relevant to each discrete issue—such as contract interpretation, statute of limitations, or specific regulatory compliance—to determine the parties' respective rights and liabilities under the governing legal framework applicable to that segment of the controversy.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
interprétation du contrat prétention légale règlement de différends compétence en matière de contrats conclus par les consommateurs délai de prescription ententes

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Généré par l'IA

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to order the losing party to pay the costs of the federal court.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

       

  



        

 !







"#$! %%%%%%%%%% 



  & ' 



                      



    !"#$ 

 ( 

#&  '( ))))))))))*  ++ (,,(+ - .(/(+  0/ 1 .+ +,(2 #33% #334* ((  5+  ( +,(2  ( 6( 107  5+ 8 89 :(;  (  ( 1((2* ,(<(((=&

!&  +++(,(+#33>1./(1,1:((+,:+( 55(?(0,+.+*1-1,(01( ?(0,@.+2(.55(5+&

   /(   ,(  .(( - ,1 -  ( .?, .++ #33>* ,( 5 (+ -  1+ ? ?,   ( ?(( .,,A,+&

  +((B#C#33D6 '"#$#"#33D9*,,((  .(/(+ 6( 107 9  1 ,( 1(,   5,+ 1 '& ))))))))))  + 2.( /( 55(/, :  ,:  +( 2( 1  0;,   5+&    /E 5(,+2'&))))))))))+(1:1.A((-,1 ??,F(#33>*2(1G(((((2- .+(@+E+(.:(F(5(+?(?,&

  0;,5+1+/(552.+(.:(;( 1+-(((+(/-.(;,2(((&

B&  AD5+/(#333* (:5++6 H9++(/: (1:((F+1'&))))))))))+((1+(+&

I&   :++5( . ((  .55 1(5 + 1  * '&))))))))))  1 .((   5( ? (;,    1,(01(?(0,@&

  E5+++(,(+-.((F(:#33D1  1 /( 2(  +( +( 10 ? ((1( -  ,A, (;,&

    5,+ 10   * 1   !! 5+/( #333*  ++ F+ 1 +((  B /,: #333 6 '"#BD"#3339& '& )))))))))) ./(  , : 2 #$D +(  #!$  ( .?((  (?1(11-F(5(-+;(&

"#%!$"!$$% B"#$ 

%&  (!%5+/(#333*'&))))))))))+@ 5+,+?,*:5(2.+1 ((-(F(#33>*(.+(11(:2.(.((+&

  /@+1@?(55++(+F-+E;+-+;* '&))))))))))(( ./*++(/:1 +((B/,:#333+;,6 '"#I$"#3339*5+(( 11((&

4&   3 /( !$$#* '& )))))))))) . ((  2(+ .(  +,(( .E((  ( 1((2* ,(  @   5+ 8 8  5+ .((1(  ,(5 2.@ ++ 1++,, +(,(+* '& ))))))))))1/(1.((-5+-22(2(&

  ;(  5(  10   * '& ))))))))))  /  F+1+((!$/,:!$$#6 '"#%B"!$$#9*.: .11((-/*,A,,12.((1(.(+A(; 1(*+,((2(++(+(1+15+ (&

>&   /,: #33D* '& )))))))))) /( +1+  2A  E;,5+*E(.(((&

  ,( ((,* ( /(   1,( ,1 (+  (*//<?(0,(1J,=&

   1,: !$$!* '& ))))))))))  ((+  / (,,((1.++,(2!$$! !$$B& (,(+5+ : !$$B* (  E5 ((   10 11((*2  F+   1 +((  3 F( !$$I 6 '"%B"!$$I9& '& )))))))))) .+( /+  (( .+E*   1  +*   ( 2.( 5(( /( .+( 1 ((/ . (( ?1(    .( !! (+ B  0;,  .(/(+  > 1,: #3DD 6K #B$&$49&

D&  #I1,:!$$I*'&)))))))))),1(5(,1( 5,(E;,5++(,,((*-,1, .E(/ !$$I* 1  (  ( (( 10   5+8 8&

   @   5+ (  .,:+ +1 2.(  1/( (( 5/:,  ,  (  .?(   5+  '&))))))))))/(++.:F#33D&

  /(.11((+(,(+1(1&

"#%!$"!$$% I"#$ 

3&  '& ))))))))))  5,+ 11((  #3 : !$$I* / 1 .(    ((1(  ((1( (/ 1  (  F( #33>&

  @(5(/(2.;(.+((2(+((+- 2(+(,,((-.(/(+0/*.E;,  5+* ( ,(  ( - .1 ,(((5  +( ,,:F,1+&

#$&  '& ))))))))))  (,,+(, +2+ 2.   0;, ( (5 ? 1+ .11((     !% 5+/( #3>> 69* ( 11( - .; @ 1(  +(( 2+    11((&@5++(+2;,1+ 1 E&  ,(   - 1/(   (  2  @/(5++((((2((.551(5&

##&    (; 689  4 F/( !$$%*  (/(( ,(((/  (+(6 8 95(,+,1+&5+*  8 8* ,(  (  +(  (+;(+ .+ -  ((1((0&

  @ ++ +(,(+  ,  .+ +,(2 #33D #333* '&))))))))))1/(11+.((-/(&

  .+(  - F ( 2 .((1( * 1* .(,,(( +(5+&

    : 5(;(  ,( 2  +(( 1/( 5( .:F .11((10E5 8 &

#!&   ,1 (* '& ))))))))))  5,+ 11((&  /( +  ,-.1,(((5+(.+(@5+2( ./(F+&((*.+(-(-(2.((,:( 111((*(/(1((1 :5(&

#B&   E5    8   F+ .11(( 1  ,A, ,(5 2 1++,,*184/(!$$%&

#I&  '&))))))))))(F10 14,( !$$%*,1++1+(3,(!$$%&

  12(,-,11((#3:!$$I* (/-2(((1(-(F(#33>&

"#%!$"!$$% %"#$ 

  55(,/(+/5((./(1( +(,*.11A- <?16L91+ /1+((@##:#33I=*(-(1((1-  1(   1+ 1+ F2.- (     1+*:(((,*-.(+((E5 8  ((1(?(0,@(((&

#%&  8.11  * .(/(+ (0  ,  1( ,,  :F 1(2 . 1 (/ 2  ,  '& ))))))))))++(+,,E;,5+2.(.;(( 5(1((+.,/(,,((&

   .@  1 ( 1  1  /(   +(( .+(,(( .:#33D+5EF;+&

#4&  '&))))))))))5(1/(!>F(!$$%+(1+- *(-+1.(/(+&

  ((5(+1,A,,1 2.( /(   +((  @  ## : !$$I* 2.( 1(( - (+ ,, /: ,( 1  +5(((/* ,   - 1/(+1(2&

    *    5( (++  +( ,,  +1(2    .( >I   (   1+ ,(((/  #! 1,:#3D%6   %#$9&

  .(/(+1(2+!4F(!$$%&

#>&      +1+ ? +( 1+  >  #% F( !$$%&

  .@1++(+*(+++&

  

#&  ((;++((11((4/(!$$%(F+ +( +;   5, 1( 10  .(+ ,1+*    /:6&4!(.(/(+!4,(#3>B K #B$M&D> 0;,.(/(+>1,:#3DD K #B$&$4M&!4!>  0;, ( (5 ? 1+ .11((     !% 5+/(#3>> 9&

!&  '& )))))))))) ((  1((+  1(   1+ 1+*(/(.?,(2(-(1+F((&

"#%!$"!$$% 4"#$ 

 & .(#I *2.1+,(((/ +1   ( . 2(   (/(* 1+  ,(((/ /,1+.(+5(.:F.1+ 1/((+*1(1+,(((/1* +E+*A1+F2.-(2(&

 :& .(/(+  +  /( ,(((5 +( - .?+( NE.,(((;(2(((,:6&D3&#9&

    (* .,(((  ,, .(,,((  (*(0+:(1*:++5(.++;( ,1+* F;+ ,( 5( /( 1   65& & 4B M #%* >D 9&

  8.;(.10+(,,((*(11( +2- 8 (((&

 & .(!! *.+(2(/1((+(,(+ .5+11.((?(;,(0&

  2(+(5+6&D!&# 9*(11(0 @1.E@1E0.,?1( +((1(&

 & .?,  5,( ,1(  #I 1,: !$$I* - ((  .1,(((5+(5(11O,E;, 5+,A,,12.,+(,,((&

  .(2@5++(E:((+-11 .E;,5+65&&!$&B9* 8 2( .(,,((&

  '&))))))))))1(((*(,2.(++ ,1,((-(*2(.1,((:*2 ((*1((1:5((.,1(+;(+* 2((1552+((@##:!$$I+/:* (F1+5(((/&

   ./(  *  1+ 1+ /( (( A 1 F2.- (    1+ ,(((/ / 1  +((  @* ,1   5(  ( ( 1( ( +,,  2.( +,(5(/(&

 & ((5(A((1?(2( (/7

"#%!$"!$$% >"#$ 

  5.+21+1++1.(. 1+,(((/&

  55*(11@!3:!$$I2.;( +(+ . ,  / (,,((* (  (((  (  15(    8 *  2(   +(,,((  ( +* ,,/( *(0&

  11(+2- 1:( 5+ +(((02'&))))))))))5,, *2(+1.1+-.(5&

   ( /(  55 . 2  @  1* .+ 1 ,1+ 1   +(( -  (*    +; ,A,  01(5+((1(1.(+(/(+-@1+&

  (1+/(-+;P@ 5+*#%F(!$$%*F(-+1(2&

   55*  , 5( ?1+, +5+ -  <5,( .11(( +  > F( !$$%* .11 -  +((  5  / ,.((1(#I1,:!$$I-5+=&

  .;(0,(5,.1+(55+2(5 /1.11((#3:!$$I5,+1(1+( -  +((  11((    8   2 '& ))))))))))  (F+* ((+1&

B& &  1((1   : 5( 2( +  .( 3   (( 5++   5++( (  #D /( #333 6 &  8 #$#9 ?(;  .,((( 2. .:(   ,1, 11 - ,1 .,((+*  2.  1( (  /;  +2 . ((1&

  ((@(.A1+;+5(+;((, 2.( ,    G  (+&  ( ((*  (@1((?(;.(+2.5,?+(2. 5(&

  5 (((2.,((+(1((1(( 2.(  ( ,(5(  :(  1+F( 6 H ##>  !3>* H#&I>D"!$$BM H!&#BI"!$$B9&

 :& ,12/(1A((,,  +(   1,(0 11((*   8     / +(( F-11((&

"#%!$"!$$% D"#$ 

  *  5( 2(  1 .A 1( 2 -  ,1+ 1 (.11(('&)))))))))).1(5+* ( .+;  , 1 /( :(  1+F(   E5

6 H#&!!I"!$$#M H!&34"!$$!9&

  .@1(.,1(&

I& & 8 .( 4B (+ B *  (( .(,,((* .?,((* .((1(  .+(,((  +(  5(?+ 1  0;,.(/(+*2(1(!B(+I2.+( +(,(+/.(!!?,(+(,(10+(,((* 12.(.(1++,(-.((1(P( !$&

 :& '&))))))))))+++(,(+5+8 8#33D, ?(.?,&2.(5,++((10    ++ F+ 1  (0    B /,: #333

6 '"#BD"#3339*+((+5.: H&

  1+2++?,(+D,!$$$*/.A(,,(+ - /  /,: !$$!* 1 A ?,(+ 1   5(  #! +,:!$$B*+(/,-+E5+(&

 &  +   2( 1+0 2 2.(  1(  / +,E1,:!$$I*(((1,((/ (,,((&

%& & .+(+(,(+.5+11.(( ?(;, (06&!!&#9&

  '& )))))))))) @ ++ +(,(+  #33D   5+ 8 8* (  1 1.@((-/&

 :& *((,12+(,((+(+;(0*  1 ( -  (+A*  2( ( ( -  +((1(  ?(0, @   ( 1+&  5  ;,(   11((+0;,5+15+ ,A,&

 & (,(((5O,A,(2.((/(1((1 5.(+EF;++(+*-/(2.+((    F;,  1  (:   (+ 2( F((( /+5(((51.+,+(1.:  1(:((+   (( ,,*  1/ 1 A ,(  /(+,(((/F(((&

"#%!$"!$$% 3"#$ 

  11(,-.(+((.55(+; ? +(+  . F((2 ( 6& #!! & B & H+&M H #$$ : !33M&Q *+((,(((5*#33#*1&!I>M&'*( ,(((5*!$$!*1&B!BMR:E(!0,+&*(F(((1(/+(* 1&!D$9&

 &      1,(0 1+ / /  

6 '"#$#"#33D9* '& )))))))))) 1( ,, ,, ( :((((2(((.?,F(#33>1/( A(++,,1,(0(/-22(2(&

  +* ++,+-?,(0;, 5+ 1 :( -  ( 2  (  - .  +(15(,5,-0;,6&&>#I9* 2(/(155.(,(((-+E&

    + 2 '& ))))))))))  1  +2 1 F.E(  ( 2( /((  5( - ,    +((1+(+(((*.5+8 8*- /(1+*5,A,0;(2 2(  5( .:F . +(( +  5 6 H #!B  #49* 2 2 (,((+&

  R,(     +/((*  ( . 1 2(  .10*   /  1+ . ( +F- 1++  F;*  5   ,A,,(5F((2,A,5(65& H#!#I>I9&

 &  . -  5( 2   (/2  5( 2  (+ ,(((/(+21(1((5+((&

  8.(?2(1((5.F;,12+(.(+ EF;+*(.,1,(2(1((5(.(1+1  ,(5 2(  ;+0*  1((0, 2* ,,  .10* .(+1++,,((.:+-,1(,   E5  ( 1(*  F (,1((, 1  1* +((/(,,(/ H6R:E(1&(&*1&!D39&

 5&  +   2( 1+0 2   . 1 E:((+ -   ,(05((;&

4&  1(,5+*F+&

  ((;*+,,1G6&BB9& SSSSS

"#%!$"!$$% #$"#$ 

)   (*         

+,-."!/

+/:(F+4,(!$$%1'()))))))))) +((11(((/((,(((/(+(4/( !$$%M

-."#/

FM

(2T(T11GT+,,M

,,(2  1+ +(( - '( ))))))))))* -  (/(( (  ,(((/  +(*  /( F((2  .(/(+* (( 2. +1,.((1:(2&

8(+;7 ',/@*1+(M ','&8EE*,,:&

,,,((.(/(+7

;55(07  1+(7       &H2 &/@ 

1(5,+((++,,(2+?1(&

 0/*  ;55(07           

"#%!$"!$$%