Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ACOM/51/2006 • CJ GE ACOM/51/2006 Généré par l'IA

Liability Affirmation and Damages Modification Appeal

Numéro de cause ACOM/51/2006
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Partiellement admis (Partially Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerned multiple appeals challenging various aspects of a liability determination and subsequent damage award arising from a complex series of transactions and operational failures. The court reasoned that the evidence supported the finding of liability against the appealing parties, primarily due to failures in due diligence, misrepresentations regarding asset conditions, and breaches of contractual obligations, affirming the core liability findings. However, the court also modified the damages award in several instances, finding that certain components of the damages calculation were based on speculative projections or lacked sufficient evidentiary support, thereby reducing the overall recovery in specific categories while upholding the general structure of the compensatory award.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Liability Affirmation and Damages Modification Appeal: The court reasoned that the evidence supported the finding of liability against the appealing parties, primarily due to failures in due diligence, misrepresentations regarding asset conditions, and breaches of contractual obligations, affirming the core liability findings. However, the court also modified the damages award in several instances, finding that certain components of the damages calculation were based on speculative projections or lacked sufficient evidentiary support, thereby reducing the overall recovery in specific categories while upholding the general structure of the compensatory award.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
calcul du dommage responsabilité contractuelle recouvrement d'actifs modification de la demande révision d'une décision atteinte au crédit Reconsidération

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Imposed costs on the appellant for the federal appeal.
Art. 64 LTF
Ordered that the costs of the federal appeal be provisionally waived for the appellant.
Généré par l'IA
A/355/2006
Appeals Regarding Liability, Damages Calculation, and Contribution/Indemnity Rulings
A/1534/2001
Commercial Dispute Liability and Damages Appeal Affirmation
A/2536/2005
Appeals on Damages and Liability Calculations
A/1503/2002
Commercial Damages Affirmation
A/2474/2006
Contractual Liability Appeal Affirmance

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed costs on the appellant for the federal appeal.

Art. 64 LTF

Ordered that the costs of the federal appeal be provisionally waived for the appellant.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet



         

    

  



       









 !" ########## 



 $ % 



                



        !""

 &

"&  '( ))))))))))* + )))))))))) ",-.*  ++ (//(+ 0 1(2(+3241++/(5",,#",,%*((6+ (+/(5(7(4386+9 9:;(<( (4((5*/(=(((>&

&  +++(/(+",,-412(4/4;((+/;+( 66(?(3/+1+*404/(34( ?(3/@1+5(166(6+&

   2(   /(  1(( 0 /4 0  ( 1?/ 1++ ",,-* /( 6 (+ 0  4+ ? ?/   ( ?(( 1//A/+&

  +((."B",,C7 '!"$"!",,C:*//((  1(2(+ 7(438 :  4 /( 4(/   6/+ 4 '& ))))))))))  + 51( 2( 66(2/ ;  /;  +( 5( 4  3</   6+&    2D 6(/+5'&))))))))))+(4;41A((0/4 ??/E(",,-*5(4F(((((50 1+(@+D+(1;(E(6(+?(?/&

.&  AC6+2(",,,* (;6++7 G:++(2; (4;((E+4'&))))))))))+((4+(+&

H&   ;++6( 1 ((  166 4(6 + 4  * '&))))))))))  4 1((   6( ? (</    4/(34(?(3/@&

  D6+++(/(+01((E(;",,C4  4 2( 5(  +( +( 43 ? ((4( 0  /A/ (</&

    6/+ 43   * 4    6+2( ",,,*  ++ E+ 4 +((  . 2/; ",,, 7 '!".C!",,,:& '& )))))))))) 12(  / ; 5 "$C +(  " $  ( 1?((  (?4(440E(6(+<(&

#&  ( #6+2(",,,*'&))))))))))+@ 6+/+?/*;6(51+4 ((0(E(",,-*(1+(44(;51(1((+&

!" #"! $$% .!""

  2@+4@?(66++(+E0+D<+0+<* '&))))))))))(( 12*++(2;4 +((.2/;",,,+</7 '!"H$!",,,:*6+(( 44((&

%&  1(2*( H2/;",,C*'&))))))))))+4+ 5A  D</  6+&  +(( 1((  6+  ( 7( 4386+:4@;(((& D</++4+ 4(+(2(( %2/;",,C&(/A/E* @6+7(438@:(6/+'&))))))))))5*/4 6(51(2(4+4?/6+@ +(1?/*(2(2(+(*4(1+(/((+6(((2*  ?/   4/(3 +(  ( 43 ? / 1+  /?(//6+7& %3</1+6+(  H;",,H7(438 :&  @ 4+((   5 /4+++(*4<((( +/4+(/(+?/&

  (+((+6&

-&  ("#E2(",,,*'&))))))))))+@ 5A((4((&+25+4+ @4;E?(6+9 9&

  @4(+((4(4( $E2(",,,&

C&   ". B ",,,* '& ))))))))))  /4(  5A  =?(3/ (4I/>46+(&+(+(/(+6+9 9&

  "#;",,,*@(6/+'&))))))))))5/ +( 4+  5  +(( 1/(( ((  ( 2( 6( 1;E %2/;",,C/(2;&

  (+((+6&

,&   , 2( $$"* '& )))))))))) 1 ((  5(+ 1(  +/(( 1D((  ( 4((5* /(  @   6+ 9 9  6+ 1((4(  /(6 51@ ++ 4++// +(/(+* '& ))))))))))42(41((06+055(5(&

  <(  6(  43   * '& ))))))))))  2  E+4+(( $2/; $$"7 '!"#.! $$":*1; 144((02*/A//451((4(1(+A(< 4(*+/((5(++(+(4+46+ (&

!" #"! $$% H!""

"$&   -4/; $$ *'&))))))))))+4+/2 (//(( 0 1(2(+  32*  6+  (   3  / 1D(2 $$  $$.&  .$ ; $$ *  @  (6/+ '& ))))))))))5/+(4+/(5*/4 (2(( +(* ( 2( 2( +(  4( 1+(/(( +6(((2 ?/4/(3+((43?/1+ /?(//6+4<(4(;7& % :&

  +((+6&

""&  (1; $$.*'&))))))))));/@ &%. ??/4/(3+(((&

  +++(/(+6+4+(( "; $$.&

" &  9  % 6+2( $$H*  @  E+ 144((  6(/+  +(( 1+(/((  " ; $$.&  44( ? +( 1<(  +  6(  4;3/ 4 7+* 2(* D<6/(:51(4(&+1(6/(   + (2(( (+ 0   2? +(  4/(3 +*  @   (3 ? + (( 4((3/  (   (4(( +</( 0 4 4  4+(  ?/  4/(3 +&    +*  +( +(  (6  6( 5 1( (  4;3/ 4 42 (6+*(2(6(406+*6( 42( ;(  +2 +<(  /+</ 2(<;&  //*'&))))))))))12(((+4(;((+&

".&  +((,E( $$H7 '!#.! $$H:* E+ +4+4'&))))))))))+((44(( %6+2( $$H&  ( ?4(     E(4  42( A  5( 4/(  /    +(( 1+(/((  '&))))))))))6+(&

"H&  "H4/; $$H*'&))))))))))/4(6(/4( 6/(D</6++(//((*0/4/ 1D(2 $$H* 4  (  ( (( 43   6+9 9&

   @   6+ (  1/;+ +4 51(  42( (( 62;/  /  (  1?(   6+  '&))))))))))2(++1;E",,C&

  2(144((+(/(+4(4&

!" #"! $$% #!""

"#&   '&))))))))))6/+44((",; $$H*24 1(   ((4(  ((4( (2 4  (  E( ",,-&

  @(6(2(51<(1+((5(+((+0 5(+(//((01(2(+32*1D</  6+* ( /(  ( 0 14 /(((6  +( //;E/4+&

"%&   (< 79:  % E2( $$#*  (2(( /(((2  (+(7 9 :6(/+/4+&6+*  9 9* /(  (  +(  (+<(+ 1+ 0  ((4((3&

  @ ++ +(/(+  /  1+ +/(5 ",,C",,,* '&))))))))))42(44+1((02(&

  1+(  0 E ( 5 1((4( * 4* 1(//(( +(6+&

    ; 6(<(  /( 5  +(( 42( 6( 1;E 144((43D6 9 &

"-&  /4(*'&))))))))))6/+44((5(++E+4 D6 9 %2( $$#&

"C&  (E+4'&))))))))))43 ++E+ 4+((%4/; $$#7 '!%$! $$#:&

  '& )))))))))) 4(  ( 5( 2( 0 /    +(( 1+(/(( @ 6( 1;E   4+ !H%!",,C 5( 1+(/(+4+((."B",,C7 '!"$"!",,C:((54 1A (; 6++C6+2(",,,7 &..,!",,C:&J/(  +2((*(1+(45(143*12(4+1 (+E04++E<*6/A//(6E((5 /A/6(7 G" "H-H:&

",&  A $; $$#*?(3/ (4;(++  (E+ 4 '& ))))))))))   +(( 4+(+ (2;

7 & ,,! $$#:&

$&  9 6/( 144((   6+ 9 9* '& ))))))))))  6/+ 44((   +((  "" ; $$H 76   / 1((4("H4/; $$H:&

!" #"! $$% %!""

   144(   44((* '& ))))))))))  4(  (6( /+(  % /( $$# +;( 4   ))))))))))* D6  ((5  +4/  4@D((  K+;(/ D4((K& 9  /* '&))))))))))2(+4/4@D(( % /( $$#& 9 + /  ++ 4;+ 4  ?4+( 4D(5 2+2((06/((&D<//4/ 2(+E(*(66(+( (4    4(      (  ++ /5+4<& /*/+((;E(2+/( (0(<5(++<((4(4+&

  '& ))))))))))  +</ 4(  (  - /( $$# 51( (@6+9 9*5(2F(6(2?&    1 + 4+ E((( /(((* +   ;(<(/(((*(2(+26(;E(6(/( (42(42((51(12(44+254I& 4+*(2(4((46(/45/(3  5 1/;   44(*   7/;: 6/(* 6 4+(4(+ 2(   (&  L* ( 2( 2  6 &  (* ( 2( 2   6/( 6( 6 ? (2 / 5  /(3 /(  3  6  0 / 51  <++((&  2( 2  < /3*05(42(42((4(+;  < (2(  ",,.* <(&  2( ++ 46+/ D5+* (+/+(;/ 6/+ 4  7;32: ?4+( 7 /( 1 /(M: N   * ( 12( 4 ++  /  (2  (</ ! ?/&   4* '&)))))))))) 2@( 0  44((",; $$H&

"&  "#E( $$#*@6+9 9++4(6/( 144((4+(+4+(0'&))))))))))5(+(/( 0//((D<+1((44((4D(++( <+06(4/; $$#&

&   +((  - 6+2( $$%*  @   6+ 9 9  (6/+ '&))))))))))544((+(E+&2(++?(  ( ((  ",,-* +(( 2 +6(((2*  6(/+  44((* 4(  &  4/; $$H* '& )))))))))) 2( +/( /+  +((4(   6+* / 5( 2( ++ 6+& '&)))))))))) (  +((*  /(6 5  6( 2? ( (2 4(  ?(&  (25( 2( 4( ( +// 1 /(/ 4@D<(5 ;(  ",,-  1 2((  (* 5( 0 1+45*  2(  < (2(&  /(/ (4;++//(6(+/4/*1O1+D +*  (6( 1 4@D( +  % /( $$#&  /

!" #"! $$% -!""

/(( 5  /4/  1(++ 2( ++ /(6(+ 0   1 6(5& 9   +/(<<   4(( /(6/ ;( (6/+*  //(( D<+ 1((  44(( ( 5  (6(5(6((+1(4(+2(4(; /+((1?(4+01+45&

.&   ++4( +/  2 (* '& ))))))))))  ((  1+((4+(+ -/ $$%&

  01(+((-6+2( $$%&/  +(( 1?(  ",,-* 32 5  +(/((  ++ /( 6( 2* /( 5 +</*  1 4 2&  (25  (( ?4(* (+ 0  ;(<( /(((* E(6(  6( 51( 1 4 4 1((0/40(1?/4(/4",,-& 6(*(4( 256+(+44((",; $$H&

H&   <66     (//+(/ 6( 2( 0 '& )))))))))) 5146?+((2;&(44(4+*+( +<*B/(<+/(2+*4?(<1(%# (4+/(((2" 4/;",C#7 P #"$:&

  H2( $$%*<66 F1(<(++4(5( (2(++4++//+&

#&  ""2( $$%*'&))))))))))6(42(0 +( 4+*((5(2(+4(++(( -6+2( $$%&

%&  +4"" /( $$%*6+9 9144+& '& )))))))))) 2( ++ +(/(+ +6(((2/   6+ 9 9&  44((  1(  (+ "  3</  1(2(+  - 4/; ",CC7 ".$&$%:* 42(44+ 0A((? (</6+&

  

"&  ((<++((44((-6+2( $$%(E+ 6/ 4( 43  1(+ /4+*    0  +< 2;7&% (1(2(+ %/(",-.P ".$Q&C- 3</1(2(+-4/;",CCP ".$&$%Q& % -  3</ ( (6 ? 4+ 144((     # 6+2(",--:&

!" #"! $$% C!""

  5(+(66/(+(*25(* /(3*(A+2+0&

&     1( %. (+ . * = (( 1(//((* 1?/((*1((4(1+(/((+(+( (((6(?+43</1(2(+>&

  91( *1+(5(2 4(( +(/(+1 6+441((?(</(3&

  5(+(6+7&C &" :*(44(3 @41D@4D31/?4( +((4(&

.&  ((++((4(6+9 95@   6+ 1 +/(+  "" ; $$H&  ( @ (2 ((4'&))))))))))+(0+(( %4/; $$#7 '!%$! $$#((5101A (;6++ $; $$#Q & ,,! $$#:&

H&  54+/(+(2(*'&)))))))))) 6/+  - E( $$#  2 44((   +((  "" ; $$H&

   @   6+ 9 9   + +4(  "# E( $$#   +((44((++4+-6+2( $$%&

  +5(4+354+++((3<    51 2  /(4 4+ (((+ 4  *  +( 514+6+4A460((5&

  4D6/+4(6+&

#&   +(+*  </   32   4;+/(5   +2((* 2(   (+(   +(( 1+(/((   6+

9 9*6(/+4 .2/;",,,7 '!".C!",,,:&

%&  /@/+((+62( (+(7&HC Q !C %! $$#%+/; $$#:&

 & 9 R( HC (+ "  *  +((  E 0 (+( ;(<(5R(?(/(6+2((R(C$;   7& :  5  (   /(6(+   / ;4(4/(3+((7&;:&

 ;&  2(  ( ?((  ((<   /  (+( 6(2* 5( 4 A +4+   /4* /(  

!" #"! $$% ,!""

  5 1(+ (4 1 (; 42( 144+((&  66* (0/*1(+14;(<+1/(3  1 2   6  +?/( 166(   +6/  +(( 5+    /+  7& '* ( /(((6*  $$ *& *4&.H..HH*S &H&H&"4&.HH.H#*S &H&H& :&

 &  ? /(6  +2(( /4  +?/ ;(<( R +(( * R 4*  6( 5R (/   +(* +;( 4 4+ 4+  R  /(3*  (6+  +(( 7& HC & "  C$ &   :*  R 4* R?(  6(   /@  42 2?  (/4 5 R/((+  42( T  (25   4+ 4++7&HC&"C$&; :&

 &  6( 2?* ( 2( R  6( 5(   4( +(/ 0  4+ 4++* /(  R   /  +2((7(+(:++/4AD+*6*6(+ 4+ 4++&  ? 42 2* ( (2* 4 E(6(  (+(*   44 0  6( +( 0  +(( 5+&  6( 5R R( 4 4 A /((+   4/( 43  5  6( 0 42 ( 2?*  O (  ++ +6((

7 G"$C"-"Q,,","Q,C ##QC%.C%:&

 & G(2?4224(//8(42 T +2((5R((/4*R0(0(6 R((*02(R(4665R0/(3R+6( /(6(+*R44+((E((5((2((66+//5 4+++((&/(6+2((R((4+(+6(5R (;   (+ ( 4 44+( 6/  6( &  6(544+((+4R(<6((4 +((R;426(& 0/@42 2?*((2A0/(6(R+6(*4*E</ +((/(3(<(6((27 G""$"H"Q"$C"-"Q"$"; Q ,,","QCC%.Q&'*4&(&*4&.H *S &H&H&"&&:&

 6& 6(*   2(   (+(    1( HC  * // +2((*4/41?(<5(44(/+(*  42( ;++6(( R 2 (4+(* R 2 4(5* R;(  2 44+((  6(     +((   (+(/+6(2(6(/@42 5((4BA(25+4+((7 G"""; ""Q ,C#- Q&'*4&(&4&.H.*S &H&H&"&;&:&

-&   143*    44 51 2 44+((  6( &  +2+/  4 ? 51( (   +( 0  +(( 1+(/((&   (6( /+(  % /( $$#* ( 4

!" #"! $$% "$!""

14(*</4+(04+(4( 14*(1+;((4(+2(&

C&  25(4+3*4A5E+&

  9 1( .. (+  *   4*    ?4(*/6(*4(*0D<&  (/5143*55(/;* /+4(/6(4 JG#$$&&

,&  1(    6( ?4+/ (+  1( CC  *?/5/4/4(;(64+4A (6(<+&    (( 6// 2( 5 1( 2( ((  2 6(    ( 2  +(/((   6+ 9 9* ( 1?402(/0/&  UUUUU

'  &(        

E*   / O (  2;*   (E+  H 2( $$% 4 '( ))))))))))   +((  44((   6+  ( +/(5(-6+2( $$%Q

/ '( ))))))))))  4(/  6(  4+ A+ 0 JG#$$&Q

//(5  4+ +(( 0 '( ))))))))))* 0  (2(( (  /(((2  +(* 0  6+  ( +/(5  (*  2(E((51(2(+*((51+4/1((4;(5&

9(+<8 '/2@*4+(Q ''&V(9DD*//;&

///((1(2(+8

<66(38  4+(8     &'(D( &2@ 

!" #"! $$% ""!"" 



4(6/+((++//(5+?4(&

 32*  <66(38           

!" #"! $$%