Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ACOM/42/2005 • CJ GE ACOM/42/2005 Généré par l'IA

Tax Penalty and Interest Assessment Challenge Regarding Statute of Limitations and Notice Validity

Numéro de cause ACOM/42/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Admis (Allowed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The case concerns an individual challenging the imposition of penalties and interest related to tax assessments, asserting that the relevant statute establishing the limitations period for such actions was not in effect at the time of the underlying conduct, and further arguing that the assessment notice was deficient and the regulatory compliance requirements were unconstitutionally vague and not properly promulgated. The court determined that the statute governing the limitations period applied, rendering the challenges to the timeliness of the penalty imposition moot, and further found that the notice adequately conveyed the basis for the assessment and that the regulations were sufficiently clear and validly enacted to provide fair notice, thereby affirming the imposition of the penalties and interest.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 68 al. 2 LTF; Tax Penalty and Interest Assessment Challenge Regarding Statute of Limitations and Notice Validity: The court determined that the statute governing the limitations period applied, rendering the challenges to the timeliness of the penalty imposition moot, and further found that the notice adequately conveyed the basis for the assessment and that the regulations were sufficiently clear and validly enacted to provide fair notice, thereby affirming the imposition of the penalties and interest.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délai de taxation fiscale délai de prescription assiette de l'impôt délai de résiliation condition de validité amendes pour soustraction fiscale

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Cited in order 1) for the allocation of costs to the respondent.
Art. 68 al. 2 LTF
Cited in order 1) to determine that the costs are not subject to compensation.
Généré par l'IA
A/3831/2006
Tax Assessment Statute of Limitations and Validity Review
A/2483/2006
Taxpayer Penalty and Interest Assessment Upheld
A/2946/2015
Tax Assessment Validity Based on Procedural Notification and Subsequent Taxpayer Action
A/3530/2006
Tax Assessment Timeliness and Penalty Abatement Based on Reasonable Cause
A/3817/2007
Business Tax Assessment Appeals and Penalty Determinations

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in order 1) for the allocation of costs to the respondent.

Art. 68 al. 2 LTF

Cited in order 1) to determine that the costs are not subject to compensation.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

       

  



          









 !"##########



  $ % 



&      '       



     !"# 

 & 

()  *+ ,,,,,,,,,,- .  (/0'- 1+2+ 2+-  +33+. 4 1+5+.657+318+5(//( (//!)..++76  1++ +5++ 1.  .5773 9+ 76:  ; <=1 3 1.. (//&)      . 4 1 - *) ,,,,,,,,,,  >  +7?3  88  .  .5773)    !( 73>(//&-*) ,,,,,,,,,,.. +.482 @. +.. 3+4@.8.2+47+318+5(//&A(//0)

!)  *) ,,,,,,,,,, 1 + ++  7233  +@+  2.3+= !''( 9+ 76:  7233; +7. 7  @.  + .3+=  + 9+ 76:  @.;)    (% 3+ !''(-  +7233+@3.*) ,,,,,,,,,,=.1B3 8.+= .+ .2+@-  3C >   =  1.5 4 D)&')

D)  (%<+!''D-C@.9+ 76:C;+. 1+  *) ,,,,,,,,,,   .3 +.2+   @3+  +@+  2.3+=  1 +5+. 4 7.- 5  (( <+ !''D-  +  .7  .++   +6 >+2+ .3+= 9! .75 . +@@+   3.3+;- @+ =  .+ .23+ 1>++@++7.)*) ,,,,,,,,,,+..+@3.@+ =   7  .+ .23+ 1B7+ 4  .+3++   @.)

  76 B3  +-  4 + B7+-  C  . 4 *) ,,,,,,,,,,+33734>++@+) B3 +C#>!''D-*) ,,,,,,,,,,.+.+ BB3+3.3+5D'5+!''$)

$)  63-*) ,,,,,,,,,,++.C=1++@+3 .+3++7233)&.3>!''D-C 77.4*) ,,,,,,,,,,=1+15+<3+..3+-6=1+  37++ 7  ++ =+)  .=- +  75+ 7 >++@+3.+3++1@++64=+15+ 7  6)   +-  C  77. 4 *) ,,,,,,,,,, =1+ +7+1+3.+7.++@+2.3+=!''(-.8. D'5+!''$)

&)  3+<5+!''$-*) ,,,,,,,,,,3+3+77-4 .+.732.278+-BB37+3.3+@+ 1.-372.1  3)13723-.

"!$%&"!''$ D"# 

(D <5+ !''$- *) ,,,,,,,,,, +++  +   +@+ 15+3   .5773 >- @+ 1E +7.  + B32.3+=)

0)  76 5+ . = *) ,,,,,,,,,, 15+ 7 .+ 1B3 8.+=-+3.3+5D'5+!''$-C1+@3.-7 +2(%<+!''$-B+@.-7.73 .+)

  1+5-7/<+!''$-*) ,,,,,,,,,,5+3.  +  7233  +7  + B3 8.+=   +3.3+2.3+=)

%)     !# 73> !''$- *) ,,,,,,,,,,  3.  C  +..++1B+)5+3.+7233  2.3+=-  3+  <5+ !''$-  +7  + B3  2.3+=+5+3+-43E3+-3.3++.)

#)  +073>!''$-C .74*) ,,,,,,,,,, =  .++ 1B+ 33+=.  (% <+ !''$ .+ <+@+. 7  .73.+-..<44+B7+)*) ,,,,,,,,,,+ 7++F+3.3+5.8.)+-C 77. =  3 1.=+5 G.+ 7+  +.+ = + .+7..5.>1.)

/)    +2  (! 73> !''$- *) ,,,,,,,,,,  @+3. 177+++!#<+!''$) +-+1 7+ 33  @+ =  +  7233 15+ 7 2+.  3.3+5D'5+!''$)->-4 =@.33+7B+B3-5+ 3.3++++@+2.3+=)

(')   + .   @.  <. 177++  *) ,,,,,,,,,,- 7  +2  ! 53> !''$) *) ,,,,,,,,,, 15+  @@ 7 5+.B+23>+2+-+3.3+-5.+ B7+73+7233-@+B.D'5+!''$)3 +7 5+ E 7..  33  1++7+  +@+- +5  176  !''()  - *) ,,,,,,,,,, 5+ ++.  +7 7  B3 = + 5+ 7..33 .8.) @+-  78@3.41+ 72331.+7@.- 6=1+1.+7=+12+3.3+-= .++.4.+1B38.+=15+7..>)

"!$%&"!''$ $"# 

(()  *) ,,,,,,,,,,17+.+++.76 33++7+ .2-7.(( 53>!''$-.7+4@.)

(!)  *) ,,,,,,,,,,+<..++77++! 53>!''$-5  +>3+++@-77+33.. (.3>-3+47$.3>H0.3>!''$)5+ 7+.38.+41>+3+@+  .++37+- 3I++7..+7233  3  +7  + B3  3+  <5+ !''$)   37..7.7?1.+7.(#<5+ !''&-7+...41+5+.4@.)

(D)    .3++  D( <5+ !''&-  @.    <  73+@7..33B7.)

   

()     .. @3. 5  +> 3+++@- @3.3 4 1+++   5+   3+.   .++  77++ =.-3+1@@+433++1+5+.9 ;-  77++  + !% ) !  623 + +@ B 7. G77++!&@.5+(/%%9;0$)D+ 7.3+++5(!73>(/#&9 A &(';)<.7 7.+.2@37+.++77++ !53>!''$-5>9)0!+G+5+. !03+(/%D A (D'J)#%623G+5+.%73> (/## A (D')'0J)!0!%;)

!) )  ++ 1.+3++  .+  @+B. 7  623  1+5+.9)0D)D;) + +7.5+=1.+=+>+7 B3   3+ 7  .   .+ @+B. 7  623 1..+3+.9)!!)!)>;)

 >) +@+7.+++2.3+=->+2.7*) ,,,,,,,,,,- @3+77@+1+!&)K@.- +7++6231.@.K K-.5+2( >(//0-++$/4$/@ +@ +@+7.+++ 2.3+=-=+177+=176J.@6=4+B + D#  +5  623 1.   @.  K K- .  5+2  ( > !''')  .+.  +7++ B=  .@6 *) ,,,,,,,,,,+@+2.3.+=- 7+2.3+=)+$/4$/@6231.7+7  @. 7  58 B + & 4 &B+  1

"!$%&"!''$ &"# 

623 1.   @.  + . B +@+ 37.3+- =+ .2+  +@+ 37.3+ 7+@+  2.3+=  177+=   176) @3.3 4 1+ $/  623 1. 77+> 9 ;-  @3+ 1.  7++7   7.+1)+..+3+.+@++13> .75 .. 4 1+ $/   1 7 .+ +B 3 76 1++7++7233+@+)

 ) B31)$/ -.+.7B3 =+37.75.+768=31+238.+=- .757+=+3+7+-763- .+13.3+@+1.)B3.++$ 3++33>781BJ1.84B3- +53+) @+-.75+5E>+ .3+.- 4 5+ 1.75 .+ 76 8= 3- 1.75 7+=  +3+7+-763-.+.7? 3.3+-+763)

D) )  176- *) ,,,,,,,,,, .+ ++  7233  +@+ 7+  3 1.. !''()  3+  3+ !''(- +  .8. 4 1B3 8.+=- C >  3C  D)&' B = .75 7..- ()&'41.75LC631+@3+4.@.7+L    D 4   L736 .3+=  +  15+3L)

 >)  77++  623 1.-   .+   .+ .757233.++B3-+7 5  @+  3 18+5 !''DA!''$)  + B7+-  @.  72..+<=1D'5+!''$)+37=14- 15+<7> $41B38.+=- 6 =1+15+77...75B=+5+.8.!''()

 )   1C 7 >- 4 1.8.  .+ .23+- 72. 4 + B7+-    $ 4 13>  .75  7233+@+7.+++2.3+=-14<+=1+ ...+3+.@.)

$) )  .++ 1.+3++  7+ 7  C   @.- =+ + 37++B7+9)!!)D;)

 >) K<+7-1B7+=++=+ 7++63 25 7 1.+) =   +  -  ++  5E  6 B7+ = +  @@ 7>  .. F3 75. 7  )  -  +. @+ +7    1 2 75+ 177.++-  

"!$%&"!''$ 0"# 

   = 1> 9 *"("!''&  (( <5+ !''&J *"('!"!''$(!>!''$.@.+.;)

 )    ++ <2. =  25 7>63  .   1.312+5+5625.7+@3+ 1.+ 5+ E +.. 33  ++ B7+-  ++@+=@@7>+..75.=177 +.+.3.71.+9 *('!"!''$(!>!''$ .@.+.;) 58-+@@+.@++6.3+= 7@@+7<+@+++B7+) @@-  <+..=+@@+.-33@+1B+5+. +5     .- 1.+ 7 B7+- 3E3 +  ++ 4 1 7   + 9 *"#0"!''$  ! 73> !''$J *"0$"!''$(!<+!''$.@.+.;)

&) )  176-   62 5+ 7..-  3+  <5+ !''$- 3+7B3+7233)  + 1+ 4  5+ +. 4  7 7. 1B3 8.+= 5 1.8.  D' 5+ !''$)  +3    + E +5+)17-1)$/> 7.+=+413++B. +@+ + 37+  @3 13++- ++ =-   .8.-  3 1.=+5- =+  3+ 4 13+++  7233) 33  65 ++ 4 < +  @.- 1  7++7  33  1++7++@+=1.+@+5+1.5.=+5-@+ 1E +7. 1 +23) - +   + =1 33  1++7+- *) ,,,,,,,,,, 1 7 3. =  +@+ 15+3   .5773 >- >  (//0   7.>341++7+7233-7+5+1.=+55  +7  1B3 8.+=)  +- @    = *) ,,,,,,,,,,  ++.  +7  1B3 8.+=  3+  <5+ !''$-765+.8.+B3+75765+> +.+.8.D'5+!''$7.+7233)

 >) C++-33654<+@.-= +37@+15+.5=.-+137233.3+3+ 4.++7233-.+1E+7.1B3 + +  +7-   3E3 +  7@ ++  +17.3+.3)77+- =+5+..3+>..@+1+672+.+7.+ +@+-   +     3    3  5 7 .++@+=+-33-75+E3+..)

 ) +-+B7+7E)

"!$%&"!''$ %"# 

0) ) +5=@+*3 )*)))-=++ >..@++. 1 .=+5    7233    ++ + ++=4+)

 >)  <+7  +> @.. +5 4 1) #   ++ @..(#5+(///.=1.++5+7++71.2+. +3 =1 .>+  +++ <++= =+   <+@+ 7  3+@ +>  2   ++  @+ 4 .23  =13@+ +++=+1+375+- 1 4 + =  =+  3>> 1 7 +.  3+6 ++=  ==++3>>173+6+@@.9 M(!&$ <+7+.;)

 ) @.B7++.-4+@++-=++*3 ) )   *) ) ) 1.+  + ++= 4   *) ,,,,,,,,,,- 33   =+     .-  .   . >).=-7++71.2+.+317..5+. 176)

%)  5=+7.6-<.)

#)  ++2-.337H9)DD;)

 NNNN

(   &)           

*+,-".!/

. 5>+<.$.3>!''$7*+ ,,,,,,,,,, .++77++@.+.3+=+! 53>!''$J

,-/

<J

+=1.3317HJ

33+=7..++-7+-4*+ ,,,,,,,,,,-4@. + .3+=  +-  5+ <++=  G+5+.- ++ =G .73G++7>+=)

"!$%&"!''$ #"# 

K+.2: *35C-7.+J *3*3OO+++OO+-33>



333++G+5+.:

2@@+6:  7.+:       )M= )5C 

7+@3.++..33+=.B7+)

 65-  2@@+6:           

"!$%&"!''$