Legislator Jurisprudence & Législation
DE FR IT EN
Analyser dans Legislator
ACOM/30/2005 • CJ GE ACOM/30/2005 Généré par l'IA

Procedural Notice Requirements and Voidability of Government Action

Numéro de cause ACOM/30/2005
Autorité / Tribunal
Juridiction Suisse · Canton de Genève (CH-GE)
Date de la décision
Issue du litige Rejeté (Dismissed)
Ouvrir la source officielle Miroir Entscheidsuche Version Markdown lisible par machine (.md)

Synthèse Legislator

Généré par l'IA

The dispute centered on the interpretation of a statutory requirement concerning the duration and timing of notice given before a governmental body could undertake an action affecting property rights, specifically involving the calculation of time periods and the proper recipients of the notice. The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute mandated strict adherence to the notice periods and specified recipients, finding that the governmental entity's deviation from these explicit procedural requirements—by utilizing a shorter notice period and failing to notify a necessary party—rendered the subsequent action void, as procedural fairness and due process rights depend on strict compliance with prescribed notice provisions.

Regeste Legislator

Généré par l'IA

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Procedural Notice Requirements and Voidability of Government Action: The court reasoned that the plain language of the statute mandated strict adherence to the notice periods and specified recipients, finding that the governmental entity's deviation from these explicit procedural requirements—by utilizing a shorter notice period and failing to notify a necessary party—rendered the subsequent action void, as procedural fairness and due process rights depend on strict compliance with prescribed notice provisions.

Mots-clés

Généré par l'IA
délai de résiliation condition de recevabilité prétention légale cyberadministration déclaration d'exécution précision des normes

Dispositions légales citées

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF
Provision governing the allocation of court costs, cited in the dispositive.
Art. 64 LTF
Provision governing the award of legal aid, cited in the dispositive.
Généré par l'IA
A/1068/2006
Statutory Notice Compliance for Commencement of Action
A/1835/2002
Governmental Notice Requirement Compliance and Jurisdiction
A/2555/2004
Statutory Notice and Filing Requirements Compliance Dispute
A/3024/2006
Contract Validity and Procedural Notice Requirements
A/4230/2006
Procedural Validity of Governing Document Amendments

Questions juridiques clés extraites par Legislator

Généré par l'IA
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision governing the allocation of court costs, cited in the dispositive.

Art. 64 LTF

Provision governing the award of legal aid, cited in the dispositive.

Vous souhaitez savoir comment cet arrêt s'applique à votre dossier ?

Analysez cette décision avec la législation fédérale, le droit cantonal, la doctrine et la jurisprudence subséquente dans Legislator AI.

Ouvrir dans Legislator →

Texte complet

         

       

  



          









 !!!!!!!!!! 



  " # 



$       



     !"# 

 $ 

$(  )* ++++++++++, -  $%./  01,  -- *1  2-    3141-  54 61 758  2-9 5  * 3:14 !&&!"!&&;(  71  17<* 301, 4  0 *7-*13=( 3--1*-1 01, 41=1$%%'(

!(    -- *1 >  2-, 7 1  !/ ? !&&!,  @111A,*B41-C>7-71* > 3141-54-( 22,41 --11 4 3=1 3  D > 31 1411  -  -477* 6 9, 2*1   41 -- -1*1-( 11,  1 7-1- 11  *11 E 11 148 9  *   7*15 -3-,4141-13E*217*15- =:    >  1 3=  7 F =9  41 =1 4 5  -74   *1 1   -1  G *,  1G15**1---1E1171(H -2711,41113-1*11(

;(   !# ? !&&!,  41 I 12*1 )* ++++++++++ G,   =-1411-1,11-G141 1171171 ,7G3:117  0 -05 414  1171 ( D  41  22 =101* *7  1171 10-  2J1,   741 -1301 3= ,2 >:111171  310*12J1(

K(   ;$ = !&&!, )* ++++++++++ *1 >  2-  3*>21*7-*3-01( 14G141> 71*76K&:"*190111117* 7,   G3-1 -015,  14   ( D 2*1 1411-1311>->*7-*,1 171=11-  14  ,  7 G  741 7- >  1(

'(   1  $; 4*= !&&!,  41 I 11 )* ++++++++++,47*117<*1411*7,>22 *7-* 3-    1171,  01, =:    > :1E( -,5->2-,1-1-7:4 ,*G311117<*1111- 5,*171=1121*-1(

"$%"!&&' ;"# 

.(    1  $K 4*= !&&!,  15 E -   2- 21*1 > )* ++++++++++  -01 7  *7-* 3-    1171,  1 11G1 G3 41  *1 7-* ;753-,3E*7*15-- =101($'4*=!&&!,)*++++++++++12*12-G3 41 :11  21  *7-* 3-  01  , 3 > 1  *-*1(

/(  H  1  3L   141- 721, 5  $ 4*= !&&;, )* ++++++++++  - > 14     2-,   *-,*L**7,2*117-72-*-1,  121-161 758 D 9(

#(  $'-*=!&&;,)*++++++++++*1>14 2J1=:1301( *71,> 21,2*12-,11G301=: ,2J1 =:17=: (

%(  H13E*C1!&&K,)*++++++++++= !(/'.>3-743-12J1* $@ EE 2J1A(D75 4=21-E1*301 ; K(

$&(     1 3E* 3= !&&K, )* ++++++++++  7--* $,=;(!'( -0*7-- * ;,1-7;(&42211$('(D*I 77*15-3-4111>;($&,M3-: 1(

$$(   C1   = !&&K, )* ++++++++++  =1 4 5  E**77 D (

$!(    -  $ 4*= !&&K,  2-  7- 3-1*11  )* ++++++++++,   =   7  31 ' 1-.=50*3-2-,17-1*11  -1,75G*3-,3E*7*15-(

$;(  )*++++++++++377->-11$!4*= !&&K(  41 41,    3- !&&!"!&&;, 7-   -41  1011G 01 : 1, > 3E71   15 -41,G141411>1C17G71  121 *-1 -  K C1 !&&;, 21 - 3 171-   417*1'$KC1!&&;( E71G1G341 --  1*  7*=  = !&&;  G3 341  7 7 311>13=( C1>7711121*-1 12 >  1, -  $; 7*= !&&K 619, 21 - 3

"$%"!&&' K"# 

171-417*1'7*=!&&;;$=!&&;( 3- -*1G !&&;"!&&K,  11G1 41 =1 : 1   -41  1- 01,   C1, 3E*  7*15 -  2J1(  11G1 41 =1,  7*= = !&&K,  E*  1011G 01   1  3E*  2J1, 11 G  E15* 71  3E*  71211   2-  *-1(  41 G *0-   22,  341 7 -1 > :4  7*15 - >  2-  *1 > 741 =--211, 2*-*  50* 3-,  311  7-  4 21 3E*  2J1, *15 > G-11171!&&;,11G17*322 !5*141011G01( 1L1341-7- -1*1G-1-*1:741-1,1*G3 1-*17*7>>-(

$K(    -  $& -*= !&&K,  2-  C- 37711  )* ++++++++++, 7  *12 G  1 14G- 7 3773-17221741-11$4*= !&&K(

$'(  ;C41!&&',)*++++++++++2*--11  7711 $& -*= !&&K 6   ;& 4*= !&&K N    -1  1 -   11G-   9 75   11    3141- 61 758 9(  71  0*-477-7711( 4141?212> =2*173-!&&;"!&&K,-1G2- *-1( E71G141*->142J1 =:1213=117<*7*7FG3 34172J1G3>*1 -*=!&&;41? 7  ,  G3 341 7 -1 > *71(  1*1 G, *B41-1 D ,71>7- 15*>-( 1-0*41141 71  -=  3-  741 11 7-  E*    12-41( 1>741=--211-017C *1231'1-.50*3-2-=1-1 77-*1 7 7-  E*  $5 -  2J1   1011G01,11G3-177-*177-E* !5*-(

$.(    -7  % 2-41 !&&',  2-  1*- G  -11 3-1*1141L*1,)*++++++++++41--*1 11 1  G   7   -1  -1 C1211  -1*11(  1,  2- 341  1  41   -11,3-13I@C*1-31*717-  5  -1EA(  2- 1*1 -0* 7 C11E 371

"$%"!&&' '"# 

3  2*1  75 >  -  ,   * B )*++++++++++-1*1>11-11(2- C(

   

$(  110-   -11  7711  $& -*= !&&K  1C- -1-02*717531-*7-, 4=6(.!13141-!.*1$%/; N $;&F( #/50*3141-/7*=$%## N $;&(&.F(!. !/  50* 1 12 E 7- 37711     !' 2-41$%// 9(

!( ( D3(.;1-;,113-1*11-1 21E-7(

 =( 3( !! ( !  7-41 G3 -1*1- 3-1 G1, 1 -: >  E*G1777-450*3-,1G1 =17E**17--121E-7 50* 3-(  375, )* ++++++++++  *1  50* 3-1$=$%%%61 758 9(

 ( 3(':(.1(= 17G,2-01-7C *12,1>1 -21114*-1*1->21 G15* * 31 3 7 -1 3E*  7*15 -(  E* 7E11717117 6(':(' 9(

  375,)*++++++++++11>2-71* 3:14!&&!( 21*3--!&&K,1G*75-= 1171,)*++++++++++3417-1E*7*15 -17-( 32*-*50*3-G 2-7--1*11(

;( ( 7,)*++++++++++--*1>111(

 =( 3( !& ( ;  7-41 G375  - 3111, 311  :0  2-  - 7  I,  11 74L-11*2-(

 ( 3(;(; 7*L*1711(

 ( 375,)*++++++++++4122-,4->  2-, 7 3 - 3- > 3141-  54, > 3 ,  -( 2--1:=11->3*11,G3 2171!/?!&&!()*++++++++++413=101, 71 3-1*11,  -1  7*15 -  *  E *

"$%"!&&' ."# 

3-, >  1 3= !&&;  7 (  1 11 7 -C> L -1*1->3113E*(-*1,1417  1-1  -01 - >    2*   *11*7-*3-(

K( (  -11  $; 4*= !&&!,  41 I   2- 11 11 )* ++++++++++ > 22  *7-* 3-    1171,301( -112111>* , G1,4141-721,741741014  1171      1   > G  -1 11(  141- 721 I 71 21 >  21  *1 3= !&&;,  *1 > 741 14    2J1,  1171 ( 11, 5  *1-*=!&&;,)*++++++++++41111G -111,>411,E11717117 -1 301 6 9   2J1 69, 4  17 7  1171 1 ( 5 , )* ++++++++++ 71   3-1 7715*3:14!&&;(11 -1G11--1*7-*11,71!#? !&&!, 1 -1  > 4 771= 5  - !&&;( 11,  41,75-3-713-1*11,-1,>1 3=7,3E*217*15-=:  (

     G3>  1 3= !&&K, 75  - 3-, 3E*7*15-3-17-1(,*L*I3- !&&!"!&&;,  G  -1  =--21 3 -01, )* ++++++++++---1*1-,2*-*E11G11--21E- -=-(

   41 21 3I 1 )* ++++++++++ 7 =--211  1E713(!!(;(

'( ( D 31 !! ( ; , 1 1 L  *7  11 E71  3 -11 3-1*11( D  C17 ,  11 7 L G121- 3E71 G3  7115* 04  12211 7 3-1(  7, 1  -1 G  22 7= 1 -- ?* 74- 6 )"'&"!&&!  $/ *1 !&&!9(  3E*  1 E71,  I 17 3 0741377-11G112571=11-:1171 1( 721=17777-11> 31--*1G1*1>4-121G 137=-741 377-11 G1 1  2-- 6 )".#"!&&&  !% * !&&&F )"$&'"!&&KK4*=!&&K9(

"$%"!&&' /"# 

 =( )*++++++++++14G41--1**-1E1 3E*  C1   7*= !&&;, O > 1  *   7*15 -3-,G3-1=--21-012-(  0*  14( D1 3 15 G  -1  -1 1 71-=2212-41>3=11F 5 ,  121 *-1E 4  7-1 -1F 1 3 15 G )* ++++++++++  -  - 2214 5 3:14 !&&! N   * B   7--  !&&!"!&&;  E* *7 7  =:    1 N , 5 ,  2-   *7   *1   3-1*1 7 75   -1   E*  7*15 - 14  E 7*1 * 3-(  3  3 :I7:5, G31 3  375 7 -1  :, 30*   *137322317-(

 (   4 21 30*  *G  *7 >  >  -, 21  C121  -:(  E71G 11 G  00*  3 -, >  2-  *-1,  7--1-  G1-   7-71,G,*1G3*1-2*1,*7 7L-4>-1-(

      31  3E71*     210

6 )"$!'&"!&&K  ;& 4*= !&&K9(   1*- G  21 37  4 -  41 *- > *    111GG3-1717(17715  C0 1  *1711   141-  7--11 7  G1-   7*15-(

  )* ++++++++++  7 5  14G  1 7 C121-:(

.(  -G17-5G31E711 L(5,C-(

  110,-**7J6(;;9(

 PPPPP

   $%           

&'()*+

"$%"!&&' #"# 

- 4=   1C-  ; C41 !&&' 7 )* ++++++++++ -112-$&-*=!&&KF



(),+

CF

1GO1O77JO-**F

1G7--11>)*++++++++++,> 2- , 41C11G3141-,11G3-7*3117=1G(

D1-08 )*4I,7-1F )* *1141)(D::,**=

*113141-8

022158  7((7-18       (QG (4I 

712*-11--1G-E71(

 54,  022158           

"$%"!&&'